3.51 AVERAGE


I really enjoyed this one! I liked her writing and the story! The characters were great, too! Only one question I think I didn't get answered (involving what I said before about CeCe and Livy and Peter). Full review to come soon!

4/10

What a mess this book was. The characters were all two dimensional and boring, there was no actual plot tension or energy around this alleged revenge scheme, the end saw not one but two “plot twists” which were both boring and uninspired.. yikes. Just don’t bother.

Nothing spectacular; nothing terrible. I was expecting it to be a bit more dramatic.

Word of warning: for the first fourth of this book I had my doubts. The story did not mesh with me in terms of connection to characters or amenability towards the slang of the Bright Young Things. So if you too find you have similar troubles, then I would advise to read on because the book really does improve once the plot begins to unravel the darkness that lurks behind the glittering façade presented by the characters.

The Other Daughter is the story of Rachel Woodley, who learns from a newspaper clipping discovered after her mother’s death that the father, whom she was told had died when she was four, is still alive. And not only is he alive, he is an earl with another family. Disbelief soon turns to anger for Rachel; under the force of her rage, however, there also remains the remnant of a four-year-old girl desperate to know her father had loved her and did think of her as the years went by. So with the help of man loosely connected to her uncle, Rachel masquerades as Vera Merton to place herself within the company of her father’s children to gain access to him.

As mentioned at the beginning of this review, the initial introduction of Rachel to the Bright Young Things set was not the easiest to get through. It is a series of parties, and empty conversations; I have always read characters from this time period and wished that I could be shown some depth, because I have always had to believe there is something there to a person. When The Other Daughter shows the truth behind the people, it became a story I was much more invested in. Emotions do exist for these characters, the most notable in my mind being the truth about CeCe and the two scenes in which Rachel comes face to face with her father.

When the truth behind what really happened to Rachel’s family twenty-three years ago is revealed, I was not too surprised for my thoughts since the beginning had fallen along the correct lines, even though I did not grasp the reasons. Transparency aside, I was still engaged with the unraveling of the mystery and motivations of all parties involved. I leave the book satisfied with the answers given. In conclusion, with the exception of the vapidity displayed by the Bright Young Things set along with the exclusion of true presence for Rachel’s sister despite her often in the same space, this book was a decent enough read that fans of Lauren Willig’s stories should enjoy.

apetranoff's review

4.0
emotional hopeful lighthearted medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: A mix
Strong character development: Yes
Loveable characters: Yes
Diverse cast of characters: No
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

An enjoyable read with an interesting story and characters. A bit predictable but fun. 
adventurous dark mysterious medium-paced
Strong character development: Yes
Loveable characters: Complicated
Diverse cast of characters: No
Flaws of characters a main focus: Complicated

I liked the premise for this book and I was interested enough to finish it. Some of the plot bothered me though. I was surprised about who she ended up with at the end as I didn’t really look at their relationship as a love thing, it didn’t feel like that was happening between them as he wasn’t really up front with her ever about his motivations and feelings. I don’t understand how they fell in love. One thing that really bugged me throughout the whole story also was Willis’s use of the term “by-blow” as Rachel considers herself the illegitimate daughter. I understand this is a correct term but did she always have to throw it in every single time Rachel was thinking about her father? It got very annoying. I also would have liked to see something more with her finding out she was legitimate. It would’ve been interesting to see something at the end of the book between Rachel and her half sister Olivia since they did get to know each other. I would’ve liked to see John get his comeuppance and Olivia come into her own. The book wasn’t even 300 pages and I felt that.
adventurous mysterious fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven: A mix
Strong character development: Yes
Loveable characters: Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes
emotional funny hopeful medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Character