Scan barcode
kathydavie's review against another edition
5.0
As Newsweek says, "A novel full of miracles." Although, I had my doubts!
My Take
It took some 58 pages before I got into it. It's a slow-moving, meandering story that takes its time to set up everyone's background, and it just took Kingsolver that long before she got the hook in.
While telling this tale of a strong woman and her equally strong daughter, Kingsolver manages to include a telling history of the Trail of Tears and all that the Cherokee accomplished until the federal government finally managed to finish the job of destroying them.
What they can't destroy, no matter how hard they try, is the sense of family. We need more of this in all our lives. Family that blurs the lines of who a child answers to. Blurs the lines of who they can love, who they must hate. I heard the stories of how my farther-back maternal side was with all the bickering and meanness. I'd rather go the Cherokee way, with love and respect.
I love it that Turtle believes the Mutant Ninja Turtles live in the sewers. I also love that Taylor backs her daughter up. She doesn't let the authorities override her or disrespect her daughter.
I do understand Annawake's point, but then there's Turtle's happiness. Her sense of safety that must be considered, and I don't think Annawake takes this into consideration. With the things Annawake says to Taylor, how else is Taylor to interpret what she's saying? Sounds to me like she plans to tear Turtle away from her mother!
Oh man, I did like Cash's proposal! It was so perfect.
Have patience. Take your time. You will enjoy the ride.
The Story
It's Turtle's observations at Hoover Dam that sets it all off. Seeing Lucky disappear and then her mother's insistence on getting someone to pay attention are what get them to Oprah Winfrey. A notoriety that brings them to the notice of Annawake Fourkiller, who is vehement about Cherokee children NEVER being removed from the reservation. Or their families.
There is no way that Annawake is leaving a Cherokee child with a white mother. Just as there is no way that Taylor is giving up her child.
And they go on the run, leaving everything behind.
The Characters
Turtle Greer is a six-year-old girl abandoned three years ago with Taylor Greer. "Jax Thibodeaux is Taylor's boyfriend; a keyboard player in a band called the Irascible Babies." Not someone Taylor prizes, although Jax adores her and Turtle. Lou Ann Ruiz is like a second mother to Turtle and is Taylor's best friend. Mattie is her boss down at the auto parts store and a friend. Gundi is their free-spirited, artist landlady.
Alice Stamper Greer is Taylor's mother. A strong woman who raised Taylor on her own. Harland is her second husband. And a big mistake.
Sugar Boss Hornbuckle is Alice's second cousin and famous for a one-off picture taken in Heaven, Oklahoma for Life magazine. She was one of Bonnie Fourkiller's friends. Roscoe Hornbuckle is her husband and a Cherokee. Their kids are Quatie and Johnetta. Boma Mellowbug is Quatie's mother-in-law. Actually, it seems as though most of the kids and people we meet are related somehow to Sugar.
Lucky Buster is the mentally handicapped boy who gets rescued. Otis is his friend and a train engineer. Angie Buster is his mama and she runs Angie's Diner and a motel. Barbie™ is a Vegas waitron with a few screws loose and totally hung up on Barbie dolls. Kevin is a bigoted jerk at the Handi-Van company in Seattle.
Annawake Fourfiller is an up-and-coming law intern for the Cherokee Nation. Jinny Redcrow is the secretary in Franklin Turnbo's law office. Dellon is one of Annawake's brothers. Millie is her ex-sister-in-law. Gabe is the brother, Annawake's twin, who was taken away and adopted by a white family. One who was ashamed of his Indian heritage. Annawake's family was destroyed when their mother, Bonnie, got put away and the family broken up per white man's law. Uncle Ledger is the tribe's medicine man.
Cash Stillwater is a Cherokee adrift. One who wakes back up to the importance of family. He also does beautiful beadwork. Lacey Stillwater is the child who is missing. Andy Rainbelt is "a social psychiatrist who works with Cherokee children". Letty Hornbuckle is the county gossip who loves to interfere.
The Cover
The cover of the book I read is red, white, and blue with its brilliant blue sky, red mountains as the sun sets, and the author's name and title along with other text. A pale green succulent is down and center---I'm thinking a giant agave.
The title is a reference to a Cherokee folk tale about bad little boys and the Seven Sisters, The Pigs in Heaven. A tale of similarities.
My Take
It took some 58 pages before I got into it. It's a slow-moving, meandering story that takes its time to set up everyone's background, and it just took Kingsolver that long before she got the hook in.
While telling this tale of a strong woman and her equally strong daughter, Kingsolver manages to include a telling history of the Trail of Tears and all that the Cherokee accomplished until the federal government finally managed to finish the job of destroying them.
What they can't destroy, no matter how hard they try, is the sense of family. We need more of this in all our lives. Family that blurs the lines of who a child answers to. Blurs the lines of who they can love, who they must hate. I heard the stories of how my farther-back maternal side was with all the bickering and meanness. I'd rather go the Cherokee way, with love and respect.
I love it that Turtle believes the Mutant Ninja Turtles live in the sewers. I also love that Taylor backs her daughter up. She doesn't let the authorities override her or disrespect her daughter.
I do understand Annawake's point, but then there's Turtle's happiness. Her sense of safety that must be considered, and I don't think Annawake takes this into consideration. With the things Annawake says to Taylor, how else is Taylor to interpret what she's saying? Sounds to me like she plans to tear Turtle away from her mother!
Oh man, I did like Cash's proposal! It was so perfect.
Have patience. Take your time. You will enjoy the ride.
The Story
It's Turtle's observations at Hoover Dam that sets it all off. Seeing Lucky disappear and then her mother's insistence on getting someone to pay attention are what get them to Oprah Winfrey. A notoriety that brings them to the notice of Annawake Fourkiller, who is vehement about Cherokee children NEVER being removed from the reservation. Or their families.
There is no way that Annawake is leaving a Cherokee child with a white mother. Just as there is no way that Taylor is giving up her child.
And they go on the run, leaving everything behind.
The Characters
Turtle Greer is a six-year-old girl abandoned three years ago with Taylor Greer. "Jax Thibodeaux is Taylor's boyfriend; a keyboard player in a band called the Irascible Babies." Not someone Taylor prizes, although Jax adores her and Turtle. Lou Ann Ruiz is like a second mother to Turtle and is Taylor's best friend. Mattie is her boss down at the auto parts store and a friend. Gundi is their free-spirited, artist landlady.
Alice Stamper Greer is Taylor's mother. A strong woman who raised Taylor on her own. Harland is her second husband. And a big mistake.
Sugar Boss Hornbuckle is Alice's second cousin and famous for a one-off picture taken in Heaven, Oklahoma for Life magazine. She was one of Bonnie Fourkiller's friends. Roscoe Hornbuckle is her husband and a Cherokee. Their kids are Quatie and Johnetta. Boma Mellowbug is Quatie's mother-in-law. Actually, it seems as though most of the kids and people we meet are related somehow to Sugar.
Lucky Buster is the mentally handicapped boy who gets rescued. Otis is his friend and a train engineer. Angie Buster is his mama and she runs Angie's Diner and a motel. Barbie™ is a Vegas waitron with a few screws loose and totally hung up on Barbie dolls. Kevin is a bigoted jerk at the Handi-Van company in Seattle.
Annawake Fourfiller is an up-and-coming law intern for the Cherokee Nation. Jinny Redcrow is the secretary in Franklin Turnbo's law office. Dellon is one of Annawake's brothers. Millie is her ex-sister-in-law. Gabe is the brother, Annawake's twin, who was taken away and adopted by a white family. One who was ashamed of his Indian heritage. Annawake's family was destroyed when their mother, Bonnie, got put away and the family broken up per white man's law. Uncle Ledger is the tribe's medicine man.
Cash Stillwater is a Cherokee adrift. One who wakes back up to the importance of family. He also does beautiful beadwork. Lacey Stillwater is the child who is missing. Andy Rainbelt is "a social psychiatrist who works with Cherokee children". Letty Hornbuckle is the county gossip who loves to interfere.
The Cover
The cover of the book I read is red, white, and blue with its brilliant blue sky, red mountains as the sun sets, and the author's name and title along with other text. A pale green succulent is down and center---I'm thinking a giant agave.
The title is a reference to a Cherokee folk tale about bad little boys and the Seven Sisters, The Pigs in Heaven. A tale of similarities.
mkmoore00's review against another edition
3.0
I LOVED "The Bean Trees" but was really let down by the sequel. It took me almost a month to read this book because it was just so dry and slow. The plot meandered about 50 pages in and didn't pick back up until the last two chapters of the novel. The plot wasn't bad and the characters were still compelling, but this just didn't hold my attention.
cdjdhj's review
3.0
This book is the sequel to Barbara Kingsolver's book The Bean Trees -- it has the same characters but is set three years after the first book when it is discovered that Turtle's adoption by Taylor isn't really legal. I did not like this book nearly as well as I liked The Bean Trees -- in fact it was a bit of a chore for me to get through it. The story line was somewhat interesting, but not compelling. The beginning of the book seemed completely disconnected from the end. the character Lucky Buster, who was the catalyst for the entire storyline, just sore of disappeared. There were also some little details about the inconsistencies between the the two books that bothered me...for example in The Bean Trees, the main character describes her Native American Cherokee blood as her "ace in the hole" but in Pigs in Heaven she and her mother Alice seem almost surprised to find out that they have Cherokee blood. Did they forget a little thing like that? Also, in the first book, Turtle's "real" name is April but then in the second book, her real name is "Lacey." Maybe Kingsolver needed to re-read The Bean Trees before she wrote the sequel. I have heard that this author's other books including, The Poisonwood Bible, are very good and worth reading, but after Pigs in Heaven, I need to take a break from Kingsolver for a while.
mjgoob's review against another edition
emotional
informative
sad
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.0
exlibris_ariel's review against another edition
emotional
funny
reflective
tense
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.75
lmstone1's review
emotional
funny
hopeful
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.0
spclteach's review against another edition
5.0
continuation
This story gives the background of the Cherokee Nation and the adoption of a little girl named Turtle. It tugs at your heart, makes you cry, but also cry happy tears. I loved it and would like to hear more of the story.
This story gives the background of the Cherokee Nation and the adoption of a little girl named Turtle. It tugs at your heart, makes you cry, but also cry happy tears. I loved it and would like to hear more of the story.
lillycano's review against another edition
3.0
Not as good as the first book in the series, but happy I read this one. It was slow to start, but the second half of the book was great.
kcrouth's review against another edition
4.0
Another great story from Barbara Kingsolver. "Pigs in Heaven" is the sequel to "The Bean Trees" and wraps up the story quite nicely. It does a good job of showing the uncomfortable inside of many of the issues facing some of the poor and disenfranchised people in this country. While the first book dealt with immigration, this book largely deals with native American status and contemporary culture, and the threat of the larger so-called American culture on it. The characters are rich and endearing, invoking concern and empathy from the reader. I have fallen in love with Barbara Kingsolver's stories, and more are on my future reading list :)