Scan barcode
girlvsbookshelf's review
DNF at 40%. There is some beautiful, rich writing in this, specifically in the ‘Trumpet Of The Graveyard’ passages where the voice of Death opens each chapter. The rest of the book is entirely dialogue, and here again the writing is sharp and vivid, with multiple voices that remain distinct from each other despite there never being any explicit indication of who is talking. Unfortunately I found the content (it can barely be called a plot) to be very boring, and can no longer interest myself in the repetitive mundane gossip of these bitter and dislikable individuals. I expected the satire to cut a little deeper, and perhaps to gain a little more insight into the lives of the rural Irish at the time.
daneekasghost's review
5.0
I really liked this. It's certainly modernist (the entire book is dialogue that weaves in and out of comprehension) and the characters aren't particularly likable. They are all dead and interred in the local graveyard, but they are no less petty and provincial. Old insults fester and new insults bloom throughout and watching the dead continue on in their profane, affronted, unproductive afterlife still somehow makes for a dark comic narrative that was an enjoyable read.
marcella's review
3.0
It was pretty fun to see everyone's character unfold via neighborhood gossip. Are people exaggerating or do they think more highly of themselves than their neighbors do?
whatthelog's review
3.0
‘Graveyard Clay’ (original title Cré na Cille) is an experimental novel written by Máirtín Ó Cadhain. Originally written in Irish, this 1949 classic has been re-translated by Yale University Press and published March this year.
The novel’s basic premise is that the dead can speak to each other in the graveyard. With each new burial there is new gossip, new feuds, and new huge personalities. It begins with Caitriona’s death, and follows her into the grave. Everything she knows – her horrible “pussface” of a sister, her weakling of a daughter-in-law – is eventually called into question by the other inhabitants of the graveyard…
‘Graveyard Clay’ is made up almost entirely of dialogue, with no indication as to who is speaking. Some characters are very easy to pick out, as they have their individual phrases and ways of speaking, but others are not. This is quite interesting, as it definitely made me think about the anonymity of the dead (especially when they don’t have a cross, a huge point of conversation in the novel). In the beginning it works very well, especially as we are introduced to Caitriona and her loud personality. However, it does get a little annoying as well, especially when voices less interesting than Caitriona’s begin to dominate. I was very grateful for the small prose sections that divide the novel.
There are many references to Irish history and mythology. This isn’t a problem because there are succinct footnotes that explain them, which was very helpful. There was also the interesting decision to italicise all the words that were originally in English, which I found absolutely fascinating.
It is a long novel, I’m not going to lie. It could be a hundred pages shorter and still get its message across. However, I found it unlike anything I have ever read, and I’m glad that I took the time to do so. I would love to read more Irish literature and see how it compares.
The novel’s basic premise is that the dead can speak to each other in the graveyard. With each new burial there is new gossip, new feuds, and new huge personalities. It begins with Caitriona’s death, and follows her into the grave. Everything she knows – her horrible “pussface” of a sister, her weakling of a daughter-in-law – is eventually called into question by the other inhabitants of the graveyard…
‘Graveyard Clay’ is made up almost entirely of dialogue, with no indication as to who is speaking. Some characters are very easy to pick out, as they have their individual phrases and ways of speaking, but others are not. This is quite interesting, as it definitely made me think about the anonymity of the dead (especially when they don’t have a cross, a huge point of conversation in the novel). In the beginning it works very well, especially as we are introduced to Caitriona and her loud personality. However, it does get a little annoying as well, especially when voices less interesting than Caitriona’s begin to dominate. I was very grateful for the small prose sections that divide the novel.
There are many references to Irish history and mythology. This isn’t a problem because there are succinct footnotes that explain them, which was very helpful. There was also the interesting decision to italicise all the words that were originally in English, which I found absolutely fascinating.
It is a long novel, I’m not going to lie. It could be a hundred pages shorter and still get its message across. However, I found it unlike anything I have ever read, and I’m glad that I took the time to do so. I would love to read more Irish literature and see how it compares.
garleighc's review
2.0
The plot of this book is supposed to take place in graveyards, in "all time," which didn't set me up for a good first impression; I like definitive plot, maybe not linear plot, but something that CAN be plotted against time. This was not that. This book was also translated from Irish into English, and at times the translation was messy and nonsensical, which did lend itself to the whimsical cynicism of the book and of the modern/postmodern Irish canon; it still rubbed me the wrong way. Whoops.
sionnac's review
challenging
dark
funny
sad
slow-paced
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.0
Irish.
More...