Reviews

Wanting: Women Writing About Desire by Margot Kahn, Kelly McMasters

luiseh's review

Go to review page

3.0

standouts
- sex in the suburbs
- pleasure archive
- see what you do to me
- desire in the city of subdued excitement
- the thief
- from woe to wonder

???
- how i got over: now why would anyone write a detailed biographical account of a man’s life to answer a prompt asking about women’s relationship to desire…
- on not getting what i wanted: obnoxious narrative voice and painfully millenial
- notes toward a history of desire: ms merritt tierce you don’t have to live like this pls seek therapy or have one conversation with a queer woman
coming to be: unhinged

jgold's review

Go to review page

emotional informative inspiring reflective

4.0

bridnich's review

Go to review page

challenging emotional funny reflective sad medium-paced

3.25

adelaidelivia's review

Go to review page

5.0

4,5 stars actually 一 ANYWAYS!!

This book is raw. Women’s desires written as they are. Some stories make me ache, some make me feel validated and seen, all of them make me feel like I am finally understandable.

Motherhood, sexuality, sexual desires (even in adulthood—which is something not often discussed in my environment), addiction, parenting, racism, socioeconomic, etc.

I need to take a break from some of them that include SA一my prayers go with them and I hope they’re at peace now, with both of their circumstances and their bodies.

Not sure if I will reread this but I am so blessed that I have ever read this.

rjphilander's review

Go to review page

challenging emotional hopeful inspiring reflective medium-paced

3.0

gxcons's review

Go to review page

emotional reflective medium-paced

3.75

Was really excited to get my hands on this collection! I appreciate the vulnerability these writers show in writing about very intimate subjects. There is also diversity in writer perspectives and how each interpreted the larger theme of "desire." As with any essay collection, there were some hits and some that didn't resonate. I don't think there is any one essay that will stick with me for an extended amount of time, but these were my standouts:

-When I Imagine the Life I Want, Larissa Pham
-Being a Dad Means Respecting the Yard, Kristen Arnett
-See What You Do to Me, Tarashea Nesbit
-The Good Girl, Sonora Jha
-There Is a Name for This, Joanna Rakoff
-The Broken Country, Molly McNully Brown
-Notes Toward a History of Desire, Merritt Tierce

Expand filter menu Content Warnings

bookslut89's review

Go to review page

emotional lighthearted slow-paced

3.75

kate_t's review

Go to review page

emotional funny hopeful inspiring reflective relaxing sad

5.0

kojali's review

Go to review page

adventurous dark reflective fast-paced

5.0

I’m in the midst of writing a thesis on Early Modern European women, and picked this up seeking to understand more about myself and our sex as a whole. Although not directly related to my research, this book could not have come into my life at a better time. 

Initially, I was reading this volume cover to cover. At some point I picked up some other books and returned to this whenever I had the immediate desire. I think this collection should be read in fragments, allowing yourself to dive into these stories one at a time, so you can reflect on the pieces in their own right. 

As with any other collection of stories or essays, there are some in here that resonated with me more than others. Despite this, all of the essays were unique and contributed something to the collection that its neighbors didn’t. My favorite pieces are the following:  “Pleasure Archive: Notes on Polyamory, History, and Desire” by Dr. Keyanah B. Nurse; “Desire in the City of Subdued Excitement” by Rena Priest; “How I Got Over” by Amanda Petrusich; “There is a Name for This” by Joanna Rakoff; “Halls of Air” by Laura Joyce-Hubbard; “Leaving the Palace” by Ann Tashi Slater; “Notes Toward a History of Desire” by Merritt Tierce;  and “Coming to Be” by Sonia Maria David. I will certainly be reading more from these authors, as well as the others within these pages. 

All of the essays listed above, along with the rest of those in this volume, were composed by such a beautiful range of diverse authors - the most varied I’ve ever seen. All of these women wrote with an unmatched vulnerability and honesty, with several of these essays being their first public declaration of the stories and emotions within their pages. I commend each of these women. 

This volume grounded me, took me below the surface and shot me into space. Even as a longtime feminist, I feel more compassion and empathy for my fellow women than ever before. The conversations in these pages are imperative to be had, among children, women, men, everyone. This is a strikingly important book, and I would recommend this to anyone wanting to feel less alone, anyone who needs a laugh and/or a cry, and anyone who wants to feel more connected to our nuanced, disorienting world. 

thecolorsofhelen's review

Go to review page

hopeful reflective medium-paced

3.75