Reviews

As Dust Dances by Samantha Young

carolina_dreamer's review against another edition

Go to review page

medium-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? A mix
  • Strong character development? Yes
  • Loveable characters? No
  • Diverse cast of characters? No
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

2.0

codewoo10's review

Go to review page

5.0

As dust dances

I enjoyed reading As dust dances. I liked that I could feel Skylar’s emotions and understood how hard she was fighting for her peace and happiness. I didn’t like that the story was told only from Skylar’s point of view. I wanted to hear from Killian. It was a good book.

vicariousbookstagram's review

Go to review page

4.0

This book is pretty good. I enjoyed it and was able to blow through it pretty quickly. There were a few things about the characters that irked me but that’s just a personal preference sort of thing. I would have liked to get to know O’dea a little better. Overall I enjoyed this story and would recommend it.

sophilozophy's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

emotional, real, quintessential samantha young

cassire's review

Go to review page

5.0

I slowly savored As Dust Dances. It wasn’t necessarily voluntarily. Life has been extra busy and my relaxing, reading time has been limited. I’m kind of glad it worked out that way. Sneaking in a page or two here and an hour there made my giddiness and enjoyment last.


Killian gave me major Braden vibes. I freaking loved him. Skylar was an amazing, kicka$$ heroine. I think we all need a friend like Autumn in our lives. I was more than happy that it was hinted that we might get a story about her.


When I first heard the synopsis of this book, it sounded very strange to me. Samantha Young is one of my top favs so I was like sign me up. I’m glad I’ve read it. I loved it. It’s a unique story that was so refreshing to read.







I voluntarily read an early copy.

bookwormbetty's review

Go to review page

5.0

What a beautiful story. This story is a story of redemption, self worth, joy, love, and fear. This seems like too simple of terms to put to this book. The feels were all over the place, and I will for sure still be thinking of this book LONG after I have finished it. The connection and love that Killian and Skylar share is something to take notice of, it's beautiful, and poignant. Samantha Young weaves a tale that is not simple put into one box, but many. This is told in Skylar's pov.

My_GRsiggy

monty27's review against another edition

Go to review page

2.0

Unfortunately, this book by Samantha Young didn't catch me. I really like the basic story, but if wasn't written well.
Especially the sudden love between Kilian and Skylar wasn't convincing.
Sideline stories such as her history with one of her band collegues were not written to their full potential.

mrose21's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Loved this.

I found it interesting why she runs away and why she is who she is.

I wish we saw more singing and I sort of wished we saw the finishing of the Album.

Again a great read from Samantha Young

ja123's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

Wow, this book is perfect! As much as I love other books from S. Young, this book is really extraordinary in and out. So far the best one I read from her!

Thank you, Miss Young for the amazing story!

bookladysreviews's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

*I received this book for free, in exchange for an honest review. All thoughts and opinions are my own! *

I'm getting quite repetitive when it comes to Samantha Young's novels but, whatever she writes, I'll gladly read without second thought! I jumped at the chance to read and review As Dust Dances, even though I haven't read Play On yet! I absolutely loved it, let's start with that!

I'm not going to talk about the plot in depth because I feel like this is one of those books you have to read in order to actually get the meaning of but, we're obviously going to discuss everything else! First of all, the premise was quite intriguing and authentic, which you don't usually expect from New Adult/Romance novels! Not saying that to sound negative but, I personally haven't come across such a unique Romance novel in a while and it wa such a breath of fresh air that I felt my faith in the world restored after finishing it. Yes, that might sound a bit dramatic but, you can either take it or leave it! The main character has a very well thought out background that is revealed through flashbacks, which has become one of my favorite techniques when it comes to novels in general, especially Contemporary of any sort! They just become so much more relatable that way and they're proof that the characters had a past, which makes their stories even more reliable and easier to connect to. Skylar's past ewas mainly what the book itself was base doff of but, it wasn't brushed aside nor ignored in favour of other, more mainstream topics that readers would swoon over. It was addressed in the best way possible and handled in a way that shows the author's ability to write fiction while describing reality, something that's evident in every single one of her novels that I've read this far! She has the impressive ability of making you experience every single thing the characters she so masterfully creates are experiencing and that's not something a lot of authors can easily achieve nowadays! I've also come to realise that Scotland is a recurring setting and I'm actually desperate to visit every single place she vividly describes, novel after novel! I should've probably made a list because that would've definitely made things easier for me!

Back to Skylar, whose story was written in the most powerful way possible! It was raw, poignant and absolutely heartbreaking! A story worth writing, reading, feeling with every fiber of your being and going back to when you need something that feels true to ground you, while giving you hope.
Skylar was such a tortured soul and while reading about everything she went through, you become a bit more humble and realize that fame is not what's cracked up to be! I really admire the way it was put in perspective in the novel and how she managed to distance herself from it in the end, while finding true happiness. That's the most important thing any of us can do, right?

Moving on to the love interest, Killian. He was such a forced to be reckoned with and I lost count of how many times I swooned throughout the novel. He came off as being so cold and controlling but, the moment that control of his broke was probably one of my favorites. It was so vividly raw that it felt real, let me tell you. I loved how their relationship started out as business and even though the sexual tension between them was more than obvious, I didn't feel like it overshadowed the importance of everything else that was going on. I do think that things worked out for Skylar, better than they would've worked out for someone else in the sense that, there are so many people who don't have the opportunity to help themselves out there or be discovered and saved from a life in the streets like she was but, the author did a great job of bringing more awareness to that fact since I'm here, writing about it! Their relationship was such a roller coaster of emotions and I loved being part of it. Skylar's development as a character and a human being was quite amazing and even though the healing process drained the life out of her, it was worth it in the end. Seeing her make peace with her past and come to terms with what happened was more than I could've asked for and yes, Samantha Young delivered!

Moreover, I immensely enjoyed reading about the secondary characters in the novel! Autumn was a breath of something new and I cannot wait for her story! Skylar's former bandmates were also quite supportive of her and her decisions. They were there for her and truly cared, even when she didn't want them to. That is the meaning of friendship after all!

The writing was, once again, phenomenal and I'll probably never stop admiring the author's ability to make me feel things like I'm experiencing them myself! She's one of the only authors that has manage to do that for me, both as a reader and as a person, throughout the years!

Overall, As Dust Dances was a masterpiece and I fell in love with it as soon as I started reading it! I cannot recommend it enough guys! It was real, heartbreaking and I devoured it in a matter of hours!