Scan barcode
clarkmj1's review
It may have a lot of academic validity but the author’s approach leaves a reader new to the subject piecing together a very disjointed narrative It became a real struggle for me.
imlfox's review
adventurous
informative
inspiring
slow-paced
3.5
Content Warnings
Graphic: Colonisation, Racism, and Slavery
Moderate: Violence
the_history_shelf's review against another edition
4.0
Check out my full-length written review at Open Letters Review here:
https://openlettersreview.com/posts/black-spartacus-by-sudhir-hazareesingh
https://openlettersreview.com/posts/black-spartacus-by-sudhir-hazareesingh
dansquire's review
4.0
I was excited to read this book as I knew nothing about the Haitian Revolution or War of Independence, and had heard the names of Toussaint Louverture and Jean-Jacques Dessalines without context, so I was keen to learn more.
It was really interesting and felt like a balanced, well-researched account. I'm glad I read it, and the book design is beautiful (I have it in hardback). However, having read a few world history books in the last couple of years I didn't think this was as accessible as it could be for people who don't already have some knowledge about the period. It assumes a level of understanding about the French Revolution, and it also frustratingly includes several direct quotations in French or Haitian Creole which aren't offered in translation. These are often presented as some of Toussaint's witticisms and favourite sayings - so the reader loses a lot of the best bits of his personality by not including the translations.
The early chapters jump around a bit in time between lots of sources, but without giving a clear chronological context. This makes them slightly hard to read - although this drastically improves from chapter 5, 'The Agent Is Unwell', onwards. I assume this is because of the paucity of historical records for Toussaint's early years while he was still a slave. If you're reading this book, I'd highly encourage you to persevere as far as this and into the second half of the book, because this is where things get much clearer and much more exciting!
All in all, I found the book informative and interesting - I'm really glad I read it. I don't think it's quite a non-fiction book for the cursory reader, but for anyone interested in history and willing to pay attention, it's definitely worth picking up.
It was really interesting and felt like a balanced, well-researched account. I'm glad I read it, and the book design is beautiful (I have it in hardback). However, having read a few world history books in the last couple of years I didn't think this was as accessible as it could be for people who don't already have some knowledge about the period. It assumes a level of understanding about the French Revolution, and it also frustratingly includes several direct quotations in French or Haitian Creole which aren't offered in translation. These are often presented as some of Toussaint's witticisms and favourite sayings - so the reader loses a lot of the best bits of his personality by not including the translations.
The early chapters jump around a bit in time between lots of sources, but without giving a clear chronological context. This makes them slightly hard to read - although this drastically improves from chapter 5, 'The Agent Is Unwell', onwards. I assume this is because of the paucity of historical records for Toussaint's early years while he was still a slave. If you're reading this book, I'd highly encourage you to persevere as far as this and into the second half of the book, because this is where things get much clearer and much more exciting!
All in all, I found the book informative and interesting - I'm really glad I read it. I don't think it's quite a non-fiction book for the cursory reader, but for anyone interested in history and willing to pay attention, it's definitely worth picking up.
ketevanreads's review
3.0
This is a fascinating subject and it is meticulously written. But I’m just not a big fan of history as a discipline and this was not written for the casual reader, so it is often bogged down with details and analysis that detracted from the larger narrative.
mwwils17's review against another edition
emotional
informative
reflective
slow-paced
3.0
this is the second longest book of all time
dylansr42's review against another edition
4.0
Extremely well written book about a much neglected part of global history: the time when slaves violently freed himself. This biography focused mainly on one of the most important leaders, Toussaint L’ouverture.. While I enjoyed reading this book and learned a lot, my God, it’s so biased despite a few instances where the author acknowledges Toussaint’s more… problematic aspects. Regardless, this is still one of the best and most recent resources on him and the Haitian Revolution.
ladyvictoriadiana's review against another edition
informative
fast-paced
3.5
The format made this kind of hard to read