Reviews with content warning for Domestic abuse - The Pull of the Stars

Emma Donoghue wrecked me yet again. The way I begged her to not show those nasty birthing procedures on page... Thank fuck she didn't.
She doesn't have any clever tricks, just simple prose and powerful characters. And in the afterword she tells you how the story is based on real events and people.
Her depiction of the profession of nursing is so charming. Both in this and in The Wonder her nurse characters are competent, discip ined, and endlessly compassionate. I admire them so much.

Content Warnings

writingcaia's review against another edition

Go to review page

emotional informative sad tense slow-paced

Plot- or character-driven? A mix
Loveable characters? Yes
Diverse cast of characters? Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus? No

5.0

Beautiful, beautiful. Took me way too long to get to this one. What a shame. And, what a shame that in the beginning I wasn’t feeling it would be such a heartbreaking, heartwarming, informative and beautiful book.
A maternity nurse sees herself in a position of more power managing a ward for pregnant women suspected of having the grippe — what they initially called the Spanish Influenza.
The whole story takes place in 3 days but however slow and dark the start much happens after, and in a way showcases a lot of the spirit and morale of Dublin in 1918 with the WWI and the division between the Irish that supported the King and Country, and those who did not, who felt they should care for their own and not be taken as cattle to a war they had no part in. There are also the losses, people dying in the streets, families being found all dead at home — a disease that was unseen and affected mostly the poor who shared small quarters and were forced to work to feed their numerous families. Last, the cruelty of the church is in much focus as well. The indentured children and young women, the abuse and cruelty, the disregard for life, the false morality.
And, of course, our nurse! Oh, what a character! What surprises she unveils about herself. What insight in her caring for her muted-by-shell-shock in the war brother, in her relationship with an orphan, kin to learn, bright and older than her years girl that comes to help the ward, and with the orderlies and the female doctor (a real life personality), a rebel and a progressive.
Also, pregnancy! The horror and the miracle. Death, a curse and a final rest.
What a book!
Don’t hesitate if you like historical novels with focus on character.

‼️And, with the added - SPOILER ALERT ‼️

LGBTQIA+ representation

Content Warnings

swhitzel's review against another edition

Go to review page

emotional hopeful reflective fast-paced

Strong character development? It's complicated

2.5

I have so many thoughts, all of them conflicting.

Generally, this was a beautiful story, but it also seemed quite abrupt (in its ending) and felt as though it had little resolution. Based on the synopsis, I expected more of a relationship to develop between the three main women, and yet the connections felt superficial and forced. They go nowhere, but they also had so much potential!

Also, the depictions of birth and the medical situations were quite graphic. I often found myself sick to my stomach at some of the descriptions, especially early on.

Now that I'm writing this, I think I enjoyed the potential of this story more than the actual story itself.

Content Warnings