Scan barcode
thriller_chick's review against another edition
5.0
I was excited that Linwood Barclay was starting a series that would be available close together. I had no doubt that it would be anything less than awesome. I had a hard time putting Broken Promise down and I look forward to the next book. I love Linwood Barclay! keep up the great work. :)
novelesque_life's review against another edition
3.0
BROKEN PROMISE (PROMISE FALLS: #1)
Written by Linwood Barclay
2015; Doubleday Canada (484 Pages)
Genre: series, fiction, mystery, suspense
2.5 STARS
Ah, it is that lovely time of the week where we discuss mysteries! Today's review is of a suspense thriller, The Broken Promise by Linwood Barclay. Let me first preface this review with the disclaimer that "I received this ARC from Netgalley in exchange for an honest review"; and also, that this book is actually the first in a new series by Barclay (a novella in this series will be out in the new year, Final Assignment). Barclay has written another series called Zack Walker, which was his debut book - Bad Move. He has also written a novella that he later extended into a full-length novel and two books that also connected - No Time For Goodbye and No Safe Houses. I have read 5 novels and one novella by Barclay and am a fan of his suspense thrillers.
I enjoy the fast action and the intense suspense of his mysteries. He writes a story of an "every day person" who finds themselves in a bad situation with even worse options to try and get out of it. It is a throwback to the mysteries of 30s and 40s (think James M, Cain novels) but with more suspense chills. I would put him in the same category as my go to suspense/thriller/mystery master, Harlan Coben as they have a similar writing style.
I was very excited to be approved for an ARC of this newest suspense novel. It is a longer book with almost 500 pages so I knew I would need a good chunk of time before I started it. (I am not sure if this length is usual for Barclay but I really noticed how many pages there were in this one). Barclay is usually a guaranteed "stay-up-till-the-end" kind of author so I was surprised at how long it took me to finish this novel. The signature suspense, plot and talent are definitely still evident, but oh my gosh, does this book drag with over descriptions. There were points I wanted to skim past some stuff and found myself shouting "what is going on now" and just doing other things than reading. Here's the thing...Barclay is going into this series knowing that it is a trilogy and while there are three different "cases" there will also be one overall story arc. Not that there is anything wrong with that approach, but I felt like he was trying to get too much into this book, to explain everything and anything, that the actual story gets lost sometimes and that is what makes the story drag.
David Harwood (Yikes, I already forgot his name and had to look it up) has lost his wife and his job as a journalist and is now living with his young son at his parents home. While searching for work he does his mother a favour and delivers some food to his cousin, Marla (I remembered her name!). When he enters her home he finds her with a baby boy that is not hers...she lost her own daughter in childbirth and has already tried to kidnap another infant. To solve the situation he takes her to the home where the baby belongs, but finds the mother deceased, the nanny missing and his cousin, charged with murder. Out of guilt and because his mother asked, David now uses his journalist experience to uncover the truth. Okay so that is the main story in the book...but there are other shifty things happening with almost everyone introduced in this book. To list them would probably drag this blog.
HOWEVER, I am trusting Mr. Barclay with my time and patience and will be continuing the series. I have already invested a lot in book one to just abandon ship, and am honestly curious enough to want to know where this is all going. After reading reviews for Bad Move this just might be his way of starting series - looooooong descriptions with too much going on but not fast enough. I am taking one for the team- rest of the team being you all- and will keep you posted with this series. I am hoping that book 2 will have a higher rating than this one (★★1/2).
In the meantime I recommend his standalone novels:
No Time for Goodbye
Too Close to Home
Never Look Away
Fear the Worst
The Accident
My Novelesque Blog
Written by Linwood Barclay
2015; Doubleday Canada (484 Pages)
Genre: series, fiction, mystery, suspense
2.5 STARS
Ah, it is that lovely time of the week where we discuss mysteries! Today's review is of a suspense thriller, The Broken Promise by Linwood Barclay. Let me first preface this review with the disclaimer that "I received this ARC from Netgalley in exchange for an honest review"; and also, that this book is actually the first in a new series by Barclay (a novella in this series will be out in the new year, Final Assignment). Barclay has written another series called Zack Walker, which was his debut book - Bad Move. He has also written a novella that he later extended into a full-length novel and two books that also connected - No Time For Goodbye and No Safe Houses. I have read 5 novels and one novella by Barclay and am a fan of his suspense thrillers.
I enjoy the fast action and the intense suspense of his mysteries. He writes a story of an "every day person" who finds themselves in a bad situation with even worse options to try and get out of it. It is a throwback to the mysteries of 30s and 40s (think James M, Cain novels) but with more suspense chills. I would put him in the same category as my go to suspense/thriller/mystery master, Harlan Coben as they have a similar writing style.
I was very excited to be approved for an ARC of this newest suspense novel. It is a longer book with almost 500 pages so I knew I would need a good chunk of time before I started it. (I am not sure if this length is usual for Barclay but I really noticed how many pages there were in this one). Barclay is usually a guaranteed "stay-up-till-the-end" kind of author so I was surprised at how long it took me to finish this novel. The signature suspense, plot and talent are definitely still evident, but oh my gosh, does this book drag with over descriptions. There were points I wanted to skim past some stuff and found myself shouting "what is going on now" and just doing other things than reading. Here's the thing...Barclay is going into this series knowing that it is a trilogy and while there are three different "cases" there will also be one overall story arc. Not that there is anything wrong with that approach, but I felt like he was trying to get too much into this book, to explain everything and anything, that the actual story gets lost sometimes and that is what makes the story drag.
David Harwood (Yikes, I already forgot his name and had to look it up) has lost his wife and his job as a journalist and is now living with his young son at his parents home. While searching for work he does his mother a favour and delivers some food to his cousin, Marla (I remembered her name!). When he enters her home he finds her with a baby boy that is not hers...she lost her own daughter in childbirth and has already tried to kidnap another infant. To solve the situation he takes her to the home where the baby belongs, but finds the mother deceased, the nanny missing and his cousin, charged with murder. Out of guilt and because his mother asked, David now uses his journalist experience to uncover the truth. Okay so that is the main story in the book...but there are other shifty things happening with almost everyone introduced in this book. To list them would probably drag this blog.
HOWEVER, I am trusting Mr. Barclay with my time and patience and will be continuing the series. I have already invested a lot in book one to just abandon ship, and am honestly curious enough to want to know where this is all going. After reading reviews for Bad Move this just might be his way of starting series - looooooong descriptions with too much going on but not fast enough. I am taking one for the team- rest of the team being you all- and will keep you posted with this series. I am hoping that book 2 will have a higher rating than this one (★★1/2).
In the meantime I recommend his standalone novels:
No Time for Goodbye
Too Close to Home
Never Look Away
Fear the Worst
The Accident
My Novelesque Blog
smores11's review against another edition
5.0
What a ride from start to finish!!!! Honestly not much else to say, Barclay always delivers.
nzlisam's review against another edition
dark
emotional
informative
mysterious
sad
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
5.0
scrollsofdragons's review against another edition
5.0
Aha I loved it and what a cliffhanger. One plot is cleared up but another is left wide open for what is going to be a promising amazing series. I just love Barclay's books for the thrills, the family relationships, the ordinary man stumbling into something dangerous and this was another stunning novel of his.
lindajo's review against another edition
emotional
mysterious
tense
slow-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.0
I almost stopped reading this book but somewhere around the middle it picked up and was better.
nikkihrose's review against another edition
4.0
Barclay manages to write a detailed sequence of various scenes, as he jumps from case to case. Promise Falls, a small town, is made smaller when complicated and unexpected relationships are discovered – almost too late. David, a former reporter, decides to take the investigation into his own hands in order to help out his family, but what he discovers is not what he’s expecting. A few loose ends are left so Barclay can continue this series – hopefully soon! Definitely worth reading. Keeps you on your toes, or on the edge of your seat!
voraciousreader10's review against another edition
adventurous
mysterious
sad
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? It's complicated
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.75
Content Warnings
Moderate: Self harm
Minor: Adult/minor relationship, Death, Fire/Fire injury, Mental illness, Animal cruelty, Cancer, Child death, Gaslighting, Infertility, Murder, Rape, Suicide, Grief, Abortion, Animal death, Infidelity, and Suicide attempt
bibliophile24's review against another edition
5.0
Amazing trilogy! I read all three in about 12 days, reading during every spare moment of my crazy schedule. That makes six Linwood Barclay in less than two months. He's new that me, and now on my list of favorites.