Scan barcode
xandra_lyn's review against another edition
emotional
hopeful
mysterious
reflective
sad
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
5.0
I had never read the secret garden before, but I absolutely loved it! The themes of people - and things - growing and blosso ing when shown a little bit of love are so appropriate for this day and age.
There are some inappropriate remarks about Indians (from India), and also a casual mention of a wife getting beaten. I hated to see those in an otherwise wonderful story. I know it was fine for the time, but it's hard to see thosw things thrown in so casually.
There are some inappropriate remarks about Indians (from India), and also a casual mention of a wife getting beaten. I hated to see those in an otherwise wonderful story. I know it was fine for the time, but it's hard to see thosw things thrown in so casually.
Content Warnings
Moderate: Racism and Child abuse
Minor: Domestic abuse
It's clear that both Mary and Colin were neglected emotionally which constitutes abuse in my mind. Domestic abuse: an older gardener mentions that a villager beat his wife, and nothing is said about this being wrong (in fact there is some victim blaming along with it) Racism: some derogatory things said about Indiansclavishorti's review against another edition
adventurous
challenging
dark
emotional
funny
hopeful
inspiring
mysterious
reflective
sad
slow-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.0
Nature's Wonders, A Deep Dive into "The Secret Garden"
In the heart of early 20th-century England, amid the windswept moors of Yorkshire, lies a tale of secrets, transformation, and the enduring magic of the natural world. Frances Hodgson Burnett's The Secret Garden beckons us into a realm where sorrow and mystery envelop the grandeur of Misselthwaite Manor. Here, the spoiled Mary Lennox takes center stage as she embarks on a journey of self-discovery amidst the gloom. Within the confines of this timeless classic, hidden gardens come to life, friendships blossom, and hearts find healing. As we unlock the door to this enchanting narrative—where faith and the power of nature intertwine to bring happiness to young Mary and her newfound companions—what secrets lie within this garden, waiting to be uncovered?
A. Exploring the Depths
The literary masterpiece crafted by Frances Hodgson Burnett, The Secret Garden, transcends the boundaries of mere storytelling. It is a work of art that beckons readers to embark on a profound journey into the human experience and the wonders of nature. With its captivating characters and enchanting landscapes, this timeless tale is not just a narrative; it is a tapestry intricately woven with themes that resonate with the depths of our souls. As we delve deeper into the pages of this beloved book, we will unravel these profound themes one by one, exploring the intricate connections between the human spirit, the power of healing, and the mystical bond between humanity and the natural world.
Theme 1: The Healing Power of Nature
At the core of the story lies the theme of nature's transformative and healing power. The neglected and overindulged characters, Mary Lennox and Colin Craven, find solace and renewal within the hidden garden. As they nurture the once-neglected flora, their own spirits flourish, symbolizing the idea that connecting with the natural world can mend not only bodies but also wounded souls.
Theme 2: Personal Growth and Transformation
The Secret Garden beautifully portrays the concept of personal growth. Mary Lennox's evolution from a spoiled and solitary child to a compassionate and empathetic girl is a testament to the potential for positive change in everyone. Likewise, Colin's journey from fear and arrogance to self-discovery and self-acceptance illustrates the transformative power of self-awareness.
Theme 3: The Impact of Social Hierarchies
The book subtly addresses the issue of social hierarchy and the practice of making judgments based on appearance. The initial portrayal of Mary Lennox as an unlikable child reflects the judgments society places on those who do not conform to conventional expectations. Through her journey, Mary challenges these expectations and defies the limitations imposed upon her.
Theme 4: Friendship and Connection
The theme of friendship and connection is woven throughout the narrative. The blossoming relationships between Mary, Colin, and their newfound friend, Dickon, emphasize the importance of human connection in personal growth and emotional healing. Their bonds serve as a testament to the idea that genuine friendships can bridge divides and lead to profound change.
Theme 5: The Magic of Hidden Worlds
Lastly, The Secret Garden invites readers to embrace the idea of hidden worlds and the magic they contain. Beyond the literal hidden garden, the story encourages us to explore the hidden depths of our own lives, discovering untapped potential and hidden joys.
In essence, The Secret Garden is a literary tapestry that weaves together these themes, inviting readers to explore the healing power of nature, the potential for personal growth, the impact of societal judgments, the significance of friendship, and the enchantment of hidden worlds. These themes, beautifully explored within the narrative, ensure that The Secret Garden remains a timeless and thought-provoking classic that continues to resonate with readers.
B. Stiring the Debate
The Secret Garden book, penned in 1911, belongs to a time when England held dominion over India - a period during which India was a British colony and an integral part of the British Empire. This literary work vividly mirrors the prevailing social and political conditions of its era, serving as a historical reflection that vividly portrays the cultural and social issues of that time.
Issue 1: Social Hierarchy and Outward Judgments
Two central issues are prominently explored in the book: the notion of social hierarchy and the practice of judging individuals based on their outward appearance. The presence of Indian servants in the story and their roles in serving Mary Lennox, the central character, serve as a reflection of societal hierarchy and the roles assigned to Indians during colonial rule. Initially, Mary Lennox, the central character, is depicted in an unfavorable light, often characterized as a spoiled and self-centered child. Her character consistently harbors a bitter and negative perspective, likely rooted in her parents' poor behavior and her own longstanding perception as an undesirable and unloved child. Her marginalized and scorned status further reinforces the development of these negative traits. The theme of social hierarchy is also exemplified through the character of Colin, who displays an arrogant and domineering attitude when interacting with the gardeners and servants.
Issue 2: Bullying
The issue of bullying also emerges prominently in the narrative, as Mary experiences mistreatment from Basil and his siblings due to her attitude and appearance. Regardless of the reasons behind such behavior, bullying remains unequivocally unacceptable.
Issue 3: Domestic Violence
Furthermore, the book delves into the sensitive topic of domestic violence. Characters within the story express troubling views regarding domestic relationships and violence, suggesting that a wife's positive demeanor can rectify her husband's abusive behavior. Such a perspective is deeply troubling, as it trivializes the gravity of domestic violence issues and wrongly places the burden of change on the victim. It is crucial for us to acknowledge that issues like domestic violence demand comprehensive support and solutions far more complex than merely advocating for a positive attitude. Critiques of such messages in the book underscore the importance of addressing social issues with greater wisdom and depth.
Issue 4: Racism
Another poignant issue addressed in the book is racism, which can manifest in various forms, including prejudice, racially charged language, indifference toward cultural and economic differences, institutional biases, and racial discrimination. Several scenes within the story illustrate racism, even containing instances of derogatory views or mistreatment based on race, ethnicity, or skin color.
In conclusion, The Secret Garden by Frances Hodgson Burnett, set against the backdrop of a bygone era, confronts a range of controversial social issues, from the complexities of social hierarchy and the impact of outward judgments to profound challenges such as bullying, domestic violence, and racism. This often sparks heated discussions about the book. While it doesn't explicitly take a moral stance, the book invites readers to engage thoughtfully with these issues, reminding us of the importance of understanding and addressing these issues in the real world.
C. Literary Odyssey
Shining Stars
Frances Hodgson Burnett's writing style in The Secret Garden is both descriptive and evocative. Through her rich prose, she paints detailed images of the garden, the moor, and the characters' emotions. This descriptive style captures the beauty and enchantment of nature, portraying it as a potent force for healing and transformation. The tone of the book is often contemplative and introspective, offering readers insights into the inner thoughts and transformations of the characters.
One of Burnett's notable narrative techniques is her use of third-person limited omniscient narration. This perspective allows readers to gain insights into the thoughts and feelings of specific characters, primarily Mary Lennox and later, Colin Craven. Through this narrative technique, readers witness the gradual evolution of these central characters, making their transformations all the more impactful.
The story's pacing in The Secret Garden is deliberate and measured. It unfolds gradually, allowing readers to become intimately acquainted with the characters and their surroundings. While this pacing may feel slower at times, it contributes to the overall sense of discovery and transformation. Despite this deliberate pacing, the book remains highly readable, with clear and accessible language that makes it suitable for both young and adult readers.
The plot structure adheres to a traditional narrative arc, with an introduction, rising action, climax, falling action, and resolution. This structure, combined with the deliberate pacing, creates a satisfying narrative rhythm. Plot twists in the story are not overtly dramatic but deeply satisfying. They include the mystery surrounding the locked garden, the gradual blossoming of Mary's and Colin's characters, and the profound healing power of nature. These twists are seamlessly woven into the narrative, enhancing the story's engagement and emotional resonance. The Secret Garden effectively maintains reader engagement through its well-organized storytelling. The author balances moments of reflection with moments of action and discovery, creating a dynamic narrative. Additionally, intermittent shifts between characters' perspectives provide depth and insight into their inner worlds, fostering a deeper connection between readers and the characters.
Shadowy Corners
While The Secret Garden boasts numerous strengths, it does have its share of shortcomings. These notable weaknesses encompass the absence of overt moral lessons and the inclusion of controversial elements, such as outdated views on domestic violence and the portrayal of Indian servants. These aspects are undeniably products of the era in which the book was written, and they may be unsettling and problematic for contemporary readers, sparking questions about their depiction and relevance in today's context.
Readers anticipating direct moral guidance from the narrative may find themselves somewhat disappointed. While Mary undergoes a transformative journey, learning about love, kindness, and the potential for personal change, the author refrains from overtly condemning wrongful behaviors, such as racism. This omission may be perceived as a limitation by some. It becomes apparent that the author intentionally presents the social and cultural issues of her time, urging readers to independently engage with the text and explore its underlying themes and insights.
When reading literary works that reflect the prevailing ideas of their era, which may differ significantly from contemporary viewpoints, such as those of Frances Hodgson Burnett or other classic authors containing controversial elements, it is crucial not to summarily dismiss them. A careful reading can provide opportunities for discussing and dissecting problematic elements like bullying or racism while still extracting valuable positive lessons. Engaging in discussions about the wrong behaviors and attitudes portrayed in literature does not imply condoning those behaviors in real life.
In summary, The Secret Garden is a masterfully crafted work of literature that enchants readers with its descriptive prose, introspective narrative style, and deliberate pacing. Its strengths in character development and the exploration of meaningful themes are enhanced by well-integrated plot twists. However, some readers may find its lack of overt morality, slow start, limited diversity, and inclusion of controversial elements impacting their perception of the book.
D. A Personal Voyage
Upon my contemplation of Frances Hodgson Burnett's timeless masterpiece, The Secret Garden, I am undeniably captivated by its narrative depth and literary artistry. This exquisite work of literature gracefully navigates a multifaceted tapestry of themes, albeit with a few disconcerting elements, including the presence of controversial aspects that occasionally veer towards discomfort. Despite these disquieting moments, my curiosity was piqued, compelling me to delve deeper into the narrative, seeking both elucidation and resolution.
The book's artful portrayal of the botanical world, replete with intricate descriptions of diverse floral specimens, not only sparked my intellectual curiosity but also kindled an enduring fascination for the captivating realm of botany, leaving me with a desire to explore the natural world even further.
Frances Hodgson Burnett's penmanship, akin to a masterful painter, breathes life into the story, seamlessly whisking me away into the very heart of the garden. Through her prose, I could almost feel the invigorating embrace of the moor's fresh, rejuvenating air, a testament to her remarkable ability to transport readers into the very fabric of her narrative canvas. The notion of a clandestine garden, with its tantalizing promise of tranquility amidst the company of endearing fauna and the harmonious symphony of avian melodies, awakened a profound yearning within me to possess a secret garden, an oasis of serenity in a bustling world.
In the spirit of Mary and Colin, I, too, succumbed to the enchanting allure of Dickon. His character exuded an ineffable magic, an enigmatic charisma that appeared to captivate the hearts of all who were fortunate enough to cross his path. Within the narrative, he emerged as a beacon of the purest connection with the natural world, inspiring not only the characters within the story but also a sense of wonder and admiration within me.
To encapsulate, The Secret Garden stands as an enthralling odyssey, a literary gem that beckons the reader to savor every word, every nuance, and every emotion. I wholeheartedly recommend it to the discerning reader, for it seamlessly weaves the enchantment of the natural world with the profound depths of the human spirit, offering a rich and rewarding literary voyage that lingers long after the final page is turned.
E. Charting the Course
The Secret Garden by Frances Hodgson Burnett is a timeless literary gem that explores themes of nature's transformative power, personal growth, and societal complexities. It excels in character development and storytelling, although it refrains from explicit moralizing. While it has a slow start and addresses controversial elements reflective of its era, the book invites readers to engage critically with its nuances and offers enduring inspiration.
Furthermore, this book may be better suited for adult readers due to the complexity of the issues it addresses. If you intend to introduce this book to children, it's advisable to read it alongside them and seize the opportunity to impart valuable life lessons and foster an understanding of unacceptable actions. It remains a captivating journey into the mysteries of life and renewal.
In the heart of early 20th-century England, amid the windswept moors of Yorkshire, lies a tale of secrets, transformation, and the enduring magic of the natural world. Frances Hodgson Burnett's The Secret Garden beckons us into a realm where sorrow and mystery envelop the grandeur of Misselthwaite Manor. Here, the spoiled Mary Lennox takes center stage as she embarks on a journey of self-discovery amidst the gloom. Within the confines of this timeless classic, hidden gardens come to life, friendships blossom, and hearts find healing. As we unlock the door to this enchanting narrative—where faith and the power of nature intertwine to bring happiness to young Mary and her newfound companions—what secrets lie within this garden, waiting to be uncovered?
A. Exploring the Depths
The literary masterpiece crafted by Frances Hodgson Burnett, The Secret Garden, transcends the boundaries of mere storytelling. It is a work of art that beckons readers to embark on a profound journey into the human experience and the wonders of nature. With its captivating characters and enchanting landscapes, this timeless tale is not just a narrative; it is a tapestry intricately woven with themes that resonate with the depths of our souls. As we delve deeper into the pages of this beloved book, we will unravel these profound themes one by one, exploring the intricate connections between the human spirit, the power of healing, and the mystical bond between humanity and the natural world.
Theme 1: The Healing Power of Nature
At the core of the story lies the theme of nature's transformative and healing power. The neglected and overindulged characters, Mary Lennox and Colin Craven, find solace and renewal within the hidden garden. As they nurture the once-neglected flora, their own spirits flourish, symbolizing the idea that connecting with the natural world can mend not only bodies but also wounded souls.
Theme 2: Personal Growth and Transformation
The Secret Garden beautifully portrays the concept of personal growth. Mary Lennox's evolution from a spoiled and solitary child to a compassionate and empathetic girl is a testament to the potential for positive change in everyone. Likewise, Colin's journey from fear and arrogance to self-discovery and self-acceptance illustrates the transformative power of self-awareness.
Theme 3: The Impact of Social Hierarchies
The book subtly addresses the issue of social hierarchy and the practice of making judgments based on appearance. The initial portrayal of Mary Lennox as an unlikable child reflects the judgments society places on those who do not conform to conventional expectations. Through her journey, Mary challenges these expectations and defies the limitations imposed upon her.
Theme 4: Friendship and Connection
The theme of friendship and connection is woven throughout the narrative. The blossoming relationships between Mary, Colin, and their newfound friend, Dickon, emphasize the importance of human connection in personal growth and emotional healing. Their bonds serve as a testament to the idea that genuine friendships can bridge divides and lead to profound change.
Theme 5: The Magic of Hidden Worlds
Lastly, The Secret Garden invites readers to embrace the idea of hidden worlds and the magic they contain. Beyond the literal hidden garden, the story encourages us to explore the hidden depths of our own lives, discovering untapped potential and hidden joys.
In essence, The Secret Garden is a literary tapestry that weaves together these themes, inviting readers to explore the healing power of nature, the potential for personal growth, the impact of societal judgments, the significance of friendship, and the enchantment of hidden worlds. These themes, beautifully explored within the narrative, ensure that The Secret Garden remains a timeless and thought-provoking classic that continues to resonate with readers.
B. Stiring the Debate
The Secret Garden book, penned in 1911, belongs to a time when England held dominion over India - a period during which India was a British colony and an integral part of the British Empire. This literary work vividly mirrors the prevailing social and political conditions of its era, serving as a historical reflection that vividly portrays the cultural and social issues of that time.
Issue 1: Social Hierarchy and Outward Judgments
Two central issues are prominently explored in the book: the notion of social hierarchy and the practice of judging individuals based on their outward appearance. The presence of Indian servants in the story and their roles in serving Mary Lennox, the central character, serve as a reflection of societal hierarchy and the roles assigned to Indians during colonial rule. Initially, Mary Lennox, the central character, is depicted in an unfavorable light, often characterized as a spoiled and self-centered child. Her character consistently harbors a bitter and negative perspective, likely rooted in her parents' poor behavior and her own longstanding perception as an undesirable and unloved child. Her marginalized and scorned status further reinforces the development of these negative traits. The theme of social hierarchy is also exemplified through the character of Colin, who displays an arrogant and domineering attitude when interacting with the gardeners and servants.
Issue 2: Bullying
The issue of bullying also emerges prominently in the narrative, as Mary experiences mistreatment from Basil and his siblings due to her attitude and appearance. Regardless of the reasons behind such behavior, bullying remains unequivocally unacceptable.
Issue 3: Domestic Violence
Furthermore, the book delves into the sensitive topic of domestic violence. Characters within the story express troubling views regarding domestic relationships and violence, suggesting that a wife's positive demeanor can rectify her husband's abusive behavior. Such a perspective is deeply troubling, as it trivializes the gravity of domestic violence issues and wrongly places the burden of change on the victim. It is crucial for us to acknowledge that issues like domestic violence demand comprehensive support and solutions far more complex than merely advocating for a positive attitude. Critiques of such messages in the book underscore the importance of addressing social issues with greater wisdom and depth.
Issue 4: Racism
Another poignant issue addressed in the book is racism, which can manifest in various forms, including prejudice, racially charged language, indifference toward cultural and economic differences, institutional biases, and racial discrimination. Several scenes within the story illustrate racism, even containing instances of derogatory views or mistreatment based on race, ethnicity, or skin color.
In conclusion, The Secret Garden by Frances Hodgson Burnett, set against the backdrop of a bygone era, confronts a range of controversial social issues, from the complexities of social hierarchy and the impact of outward judgments to profound challenges such as bullying, domestic violence, and racism. This often sparks heated discussions about the book. While it doesn't explicitly take a moral stance, the book invites readers to engage thoughtfully with these issues, reminding us of the importance of understanding and addressing these issues in the real world.
C. Literary Odyssey
Shining Stars
Frances Hodgson Burnett's writing style in The Secret Garden is both descriptive and evocative. Through her rich prose, she paints detailed images of the garden, the moor, and the characters' emotions. This descriptive style captures the beauty and enchantment of nature, portraying it as a potent force for healing and transformation. The tone of the book is often contemplative and introspective, offering readers insights into the inner thoughts and transformations of the characters.
One of Burnett's notable narrative techniques is her use of third-person limited omniscient narration. This perspective allows readers to gain insights into the thoughts and feelings of specific characters, primarily Mary Lennox and later, Colin Craven. Through this narrative technique, readers witness the gradual evolution of these central characters, making their transformations all the more impactful.
The story's pacing in The Secret Garden is deliberate and measured. It unfolds gradually, allowing readers to become intimately acquainted with the characters and their surroundings. While this pacing may feel slower at times, it contributes to the overall sense of discovery and transformation. Despite this deliberate pacing, the book remains highly readable, with clear and accessible language that makes it suitable for both young and adult readers.
The plot structure adheres to a traditional narrative arc, with an introduction, rising action, climax, falling action, and resolution. This structure, combined with the deliberate pacing, creates a satisfying narrative rhythm. Plot twists in the story are not overtly dramatic but deeply satisfying. They include the mystery surrounding the locked garden, the gradual blossoming of Mary's and Colin's characters, and the profound healing power of nature. These twists are seamlessly woven into the narrative, enhancing the story's engagement and emotional resonance. The Secret Garden effectively maintains reader engagement through its well-organized storytelling. The author balances moments of reflection with moments of action and discovery, creating a dynamic narrative. Additionally, intermittent shifts between characters' perspectives provide depth and insight into their inner worlds, fostering a deeper connection between readers and the characters.
Shadowy Corners
While The Secret Garden boasts numerous strengths, it does have its share of shortcomings. These notable weaknesses encompass the absence of overt moral lessons and the inclusion of controversial elements, such as outdated views on domestic violence and the portrayal of Indian servants. These aspects are undeniably products of the era in which the book was written, and they may be unsettling and problematic for contemporary readers, sparking questions about their depiction and relevance in today's context.
Readers anticipating direct moral guidance from the narrative may find themselves somewhat disappointed. While Mary undergoes a transformative journey, learning about love, kindness, and the potential for personal change, the author refrains from overtly condemning wrongful behaviors, such as racism. This omission may be perceived as a limitation by some. It becomes apparent that the author intentionally presents the social and cultural issues of her time, urging readers to independently engage with the text and explore its underlying themes and insights.
When reading literary works that reflect the prevailing ideas of their era, which may differ significantly from contemporary viewpoints, such as those of Frances Hodgson Burnett or other classic authors containing controversial elements, it is crucial not to summarily dismiss them. A careful reading can provide opportunities for discussing and dissecting problematic elements like bullying or racism while still extracting valuable positive lessons. Engaging in discussions about the wrong behaviors and attitudes portrayed in literature does not imply condoning those behaviors in real life.
In summary, The Secret Garden is a masterfully crafted work of literature that enchants readers with its descriptive prose, introspective narrative style, and deliberate pacing. Its strengths in character development and the exploration of meaningful themes are enhanced by well-integrated plot twists. However, some readers may find its lack of overt morality, slow start, limited diversity, and inclusion of controversial elements impacting their perception of the book.
D. A Personal Voyage
Upon my contemplation of Frances Hodgson Burnett's timeless masterpiece, The Secret Garden, I am undeniably captivated by its narrative depth and literary artistry. This exquisite work of literature gracefully navigates a multifaceted tapestry of themes, albeit with a few disconcerting elements, including the presence of controversial aspects that occasionally veer towards discomfort. Despite these disquieting moments, my curiosity was piqued, compelling me to delve deeper into the narrative, seeking both elucidation and resolution.
The book's artful portrayal of the botanical world, replete with intricate descriptions of diverse floral specimens, not only sparked my intellectual curiosity but also kindled an enduring fascination for the captivating realm of botany, leaving me with a desire to explore the natural world even further.
Frances Hodgson Burnett's penmanship, akin to a masterful painter, breathes life into the story, seamlessly whisking me away into the very heart of the garden. Through her prose, I could almost feel the invigorating embrace of the moor's fresh, rejuvenating air, a testament to her remarkable ability to transport readers into the very fabric of her narrative canvas. The notion of a clandestine garden, with its tantalizing promise of tranquility amidst the company of endearing fauna and the harmonious symphony of avian melodies, awakened a profound yearning within me to possess a secret garden, an oasis of serenity in a bustling world.
In the spirit of Mary and Colin, I, too, succumbed to the enchanting allure of Dickon. His character exuded an ineffable magic, an enigmatic charisma that appeared to captivate the hearts of all who were fortunate enough to cross his path. Within the narrative, he emerged as a beacon of the purest connection with the natural world, inspiring not only the characters within the story but also a sense of wonder and admiration within me.
To encapsulate, The Secret Garden stands as an enthralling odyssey, a literary gem that beckons the reader to savor every word, every nuance, and every emotion. I wholeheartedly recommend it to the discerning reader, for it seamlessly weaves the enchantment of the natural world with the profound depths of the human spirit, offering a rich and rewarding literary voyage that lingers long after the final page is turned.
E. Charting the Course
The Secret Garden by Frances Hodgson Burnett is a timeless literary gem that explores themes of nature's transformative power, personal growth, and societal complexities. It excels in character development and storytelling, although it refrains from explicit moralizing. While it has a slow start and addresses controversial elements reflective of its era, the book invites readers to engage critically with its nuances and offers enduring inspiration.
Furthermore, this book may be better suited for adult readers due to the complexity of the issues it addresses. If you intend to introduce this book to children, it's advisable to read it alongside them and seize the opportunity to impart valuable life lessons and foster an understanding of unacceptable actions. It remains a captivating journey into the mysteries of life and renewal.
"Aye," he answered, "that I do. It'll work same as th' seeds do when th' sun shines on 'em. It'll work for sure. Shall us begin it now?"
Content Warnings
Graphic: Ableism, Death of parent, Domestic abuse, Physical abuse, and Racism
momogajo's review against another edition
emotional
hopeful
lighthearted
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? It's complicated
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
5.0
Nostalgia is strong for me and this book. But it is a classic for a reason.
Content Warnings
Minor: Ableism, Domestic abuse, and Racism
It's not bad for a book written by a white woman in 1911. There is mention of the above, but is not shown.yrlaevelyn's review against another edition
adventurous
dark
funny
hopeful
lighthearted
mysterious
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.5
Content Warnings
Graphic: Panic attacks/disorders, Racial slurs, Ableism, Colonisation, and Racism
Moderate: Chronic illness, Abandonment, Body shaming, Medical content, Panic attacks/disorders, and Terminal illness
Minor: Animal death, Death, Domestic abuse, Grief, Death of parent, Emotional abuse, Medical content, Mental illness, Slavery, Body shaming, and Confinement
yggie's review against another edition
adventurous
emotional
funny
hopeful
inspiring
lighthearted
mysterious
reflective
relaxing
slow-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
5.0
Such a wholesome, lovely book. Great cast, great development. This book is one of the few I can reread every few years and it will always make me feel better.
That said, it's very much a product of its time, and the casual racism at the beginning is definitely not ok.
That said, it's very much a product of its time, and the casual racism at the beginning is definitely not ok.
Content Warnings
Graphic: Death of parent, Racism, and Colonisation
Minor: Alcoholism, Classism, Racial slurs, Ableism, Domestic abuse, and Grief
okthislooksbad's review against another edition
adventurous
lighthearted
slow-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? No
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
0.75
Content Warnings
Moderate: Racism
Minor: Domestic abuse
tea_on_books's review against another edition
medium-paced
2.0
I was really excited about this Clothbound Classic knowing it’s a really well known children’s classic. Imagine my disappointment coming across racist content right in the first few pages of the book. And if racist content wasn’t enough then you also got a paragraph towards the last few pages of the book in which the conversation between a 10 year old boy and and a senior gardener talks light on domestic violence.
And no the racist bits aren’t just a 10 year old spoilt child’s opinion that has been corrected over the course of the story. It’s never addressed at all. And now Imagine a child reading this book and looking up to the characters. How is this a children’s classic so widely distributed by Puffun Books without taking any accountability for the content that young readers are exposed to.
The copy I have is a republished 2019 version.
And if the excuse is ‘this was written at a time when the author didn’t know better, I don’t think thats enough. Like one reviewer said- you don’t have to be born at a particular period of human history to see others of different appearance as human. And I completely agree with this.
What’s absolutely strange is that when I checked the reviews on goodreads it’s so highly rated and majority of them don’t even address the problematic parts. It’s about time publishing houses took some responsibility for the content that is sold to children, especially being a publishing division specially catering to young readers. The least the publishing house can do is republish it omitting the racist content.
If you are looking to still read it, Amazon.com has a racism free version of the book in kindle format, which if I knew earlier, I probably would have gone for.
If you are looking to purchase a children’s classic, I am sure there are better options out there free of racist, problematic content.
And no the racist bits aren’t just a 10 year old spoilt child’s opinion that has been corrected over the course of the story. It’s never addressed at all. And now Imagine a child reading this book and looking up to the characters. How is this a children’s classic so widely distributed by Puffun Books without taking any accountability for the content that young readers are exposed to.
The copy I have is a republished 2019 version.
And if the excuse is ‘this was written at a time when the author didn’t know better, I don’t think thats enough. Like one reviewer said- you don’t have to be born at a particular period of human history to see others of different appearance as human. And I completely agree with this.
What’s absolutely strange is that when I checked the reviews on goodreads it’s so highly rated and majority of them don’t even address the problematic parts. It’s about time publishing houses took some responsibility for the content that is sold to children, especially being a publishing division specially catering to young readers. The least the publishing house can do is republish it omitting the racist content.
If you are looking to still read it, Amazon.com has a racism free version of the book in kindle format, which if I knew earlier, I probably would have gone for.
If you are looking to purchase a children’s classic, I am sure there are better options out there free of racist, problematic content.
Content Warnings
Graphic: Racism, Racial slurs, and Domestic abuse
More...