Scan barcode
daumari's review against another edition
4.0
3.5/5, rounded up.
This was fun. As mentioned on another 2019 review, I adore historical fiction, though I also agree with the author's own assessment on the backflap that, "The Agency is a totally unrealistic, completely fictitious antidote to the fate that would otherwise swallow a girl like Mary Quinn." The other books seem to be checked out from my library at the moment but I kind of want to binge the rest of the books now.
The author did her PhD work on Victorian literature and culture, so the setting/worldbuilding is decent. I can see where other readers have quibbles that Mary is too modern, headstrong, but, if given the fantasy option of working for a spy agency I'm sure there'd be women in the era who'd be up for it.
I hadn't heard of the Lascars before, and I anticipate them being relevant in future books.
Even though I've read quite a bit of YA this year, I haven't developed more sophisticated thoughts on the tropes like a love interest, etc. I thought James Easton's character fit in well, but was startled when the perspective shifted to him early on.
This was fun. As mentioned on another 2019 review, I adore historical fiction, though I also agree with the author's own assessment on the backflap that, "The Agency is a totally unrealistic, completely fictitious antidote to the fate that would otherwise swallow a girl like Mary Quinn." The other books seem to be checked out from my library at the moment but I kind of want to binge the rest of the books now.
The author did her PhD work on Victorian literature and culture, so the setting/worldbuilding is decent. I can see where other readers have quibbles that Mary is too modern, headstrong, but, if given the fantasy option of working for a spy agency I'm sure there'd be women in the era who'd be up for it.
I hadn't heard of the Lascars before, and I anticipate them being relevant in future books.
Spoiler
I am also quite pleased to see a historical hapa lead character, though for assimilation/survivability she leans hard on being white-passing. Still, minority folks in historical gear I can cosplay as (but never will because costumes take an awful lot of planning) are always a good thing in my book.Even though I've read quite a bit of YA this year, I haven't developed more sophisticated thoughts on the tropes like a love interest, etc. I thought James Easton's character fit in well, but was startled when the perspective shifted to him early on.
commedesenfants's review against another edition
4.0
Posted: http://living-a-thousand-lives.tumblr.com/post/28832264183/a-spy-in-the-house-the-agency-1-by-y-s-lee
The Cover
I like the atmosphere of this cover and it has something to do with the book (Victorian setting) and and the model actually looks like how the main character is described in the book (half-Asian but looks more Western). Also the fond is very pretty but it’s not too much. I wouldn’t be embarrassed to be seen holding this book in public.
The Story
London, 1850s. Mary Quinn is an orphan and a thief but just before she’s executed she is saved and brought to a school for girls where she has the chance to get an education and to learn proper manners. However, there’s more to Ms. Scrimshaw’s Academy for Girls than meets the eye, it is also the head quarter of “The Agency” that consists of only female spies. After being recruited by the headmistress, Mary’s first assignment is disguising herself as a lady’s companion and infiltrating the house of a merchant who’s under suspicion of insurance fraud and it is Mary’s job to collect evidence.
The Protagonist
Mary is a brave, smart and independent young woman, which is a rarity in Victorian England. Because of her hard childhood, she’s resourceful and clever (like pretending to be a boy so she can walk the streets freely). Despite all that she’s still compassionate and likable. She could be unreasonably stubborn and made some wrong decisions which put herself in danger but she never made any rash decisions, she’s also not too proud to accept help when she realized that she can’t do something alone.
The Heart Rate
James Easton, what can I say? You stole my heart. The first time we meet James is at the house of the merchant Mary works for. He’s a lot like Mary in some ways. He’s also stubborn and brave and smart. He has very strong views about what’s socially acceptable but Mary totally shattered his world view. James is not one of those overly possessive alpha male types but he actually respects Mary’s decisions and treats her like an equal. He might not like it, but he trusts her enough to go along with her plans. Mary and James’ relationship develops slowly (their first meeting is very notable). It’s definitely not insta-love, the attraction is there from the beginning but it all started with a reluctant alliance to pool their information about the merchant. Because they are so alike, they often argue and banter which is funny to read but you can also definitely see the sexual tension underneath the witty remarks.
The Good
- The Victorian Setting really sets the mood. There is no romaticizing but the author describes London in the mid-19th century perfectly (in my opinion), I could basically smell the stink of the Thames.
- The main character is half-Chinese. YAY! There should be more diversity in YA fiction. Plus, it was interesting to see how Asians dealt with live in Victorian London.
- The women in this books are all strong in some way or another. Alone the fact that The Agency is all-female shows that no men are needed, they aren’t however man-haters either, one of the head of the agency even wants to recruit James. Not all girls are obviously fitting to be spys, those girls are prepared and educated in order to get jobs as governesses or teachers etc., i.e. they are taught the skills that will help them to support themselves so they don’t have to rely on a husband.
The Bad
It’s only a small thing (to me at least) but the mystery was a bit lacking. I suspected the culprit very early on. I was actually more interested to find out more about Mary’s past and the mystery surrounding her father’s disappearance at sea.
The Rating
4 Stars
This book was great, with likable characters and I was thankful that the second and third installation were already out, so I could read more about Mary and James’ adventures.
The Cover
I like the atmosphere of this cover and it has something to do with the book (Victorian setting) and and the model actually looks like how the main character is described in the book (half-Asian but looks more Western). Also the fond is very pretty but it’s not too much. I wouldn’t be embarrassed to be seen holding this book in public.
The Story
London, 1850s. Mary Quinn is an orphan and a thief but just before she’s executed she is saved and brought to a school for girls where she has the chance to get an education and to learn proper manners. However, there’s more to Ms. Scrimshaw’s Academy for Girls than meets the eye, it is also the head quarter of “The Agency” that consists of only female spies. After being recruited by the headmistress, Mary’s first assignment is disguising herself as a lady’s companion and infiltrating the house of a merchant who’s under suspicion of insurance fraud and it is Mary’s job to collect evidence.
The Protagonist
Mary is a brave, smart and independent young woman, which is a rarity in Victorian England. Because of her hard childhood, she’s resourceful and clever (like pretending to be a boy so she can walk the streets freely). Despite all that she’s still compassionate and likable. She could be unreasonably stubborn and made some wrong decisions which put herself in danger but she never made any rash decisions, she’s also not too proud to accept help when she realized that she can’t do something alone.
The Heart Rate
James Easton, what can I say? You stole my heart. The first time we meet James is at the house of the merchant Mary works for. He’s a lot like Mary in some ways. He’s also stubborn and brave and smart. He has very strong views about what’s socially acceptable but Mary totally shattered his world view. James is not one of those overly possessive alpha male types but he actually respects Mary’s decisions and treats her like an equal. He might not like it, but he trusts her enough to go along with her plans. Mary and James’ relationship develops slowly (their first meeting is very notable). It’s definitely not insta-love, the attraction is there from the beginning but it all started with a reluctant alliance to pool their information about the merchant. Because they are so alike, they often argue and banter which is funny to read but you can also definitely see the sexual tension underneath the witty remarks.
The Good
The Bad
It’s only a small thing (to me at least) but the mystery was a bit lacking. I suspected the culprit very early on. I was actually more interested to find out more about Mary’s past and the mystery surrounding her father’s disappearance at sea.
The Rating
4 Stars
This book was great, with likable characters and I was thankful that the second and third installation were already out, so I could read more about Mary and James’ adventures.
kspann's review against another edition
adventurous
mysterious
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? No
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
2.0
meghantrainer's review against another edition
adventurous
mysterious
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
3.0
fantasynovel's review against another edition
3.0
Really wanted to love this book. It was ok. Will read next in series.
vbenford's review against another edition
adventurous
mysterious
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
1.5
x_librarian's review against another edition
3.0
A fun Victorian era spy novel. I think there were perhaps a few too many threads of the story. I thought some of the connections were tennuous, but the story was still enjoyable and I look forward to the next in the series.
On a different note, something about the book reminded me of Ivy by Julie Hearn, although I couldn't say what, since the only thing the novels have in common is setting and protagonists with sad backgrounds.
On a different note, something about the book reminded me of Ivy by Julie Hearn, although I couldn't say what, since the only thing the novels have in common is setting and protagonists with sad backgrounds.
mickachoo's review against another edition
4.0
I enjoyed this book so much! The time it's set in, the main characters, the style of writing. I loved it all. Mary is a wonderful female MC and the way the author switches smoothly between the narration of her and James is sooo nice.
I would've enjoyed a bit more details and in depth tellings of the things that took place but nonethless, it was a nice, quick read.
I would've enjoyed a bit more details and in depth tellings of the things that took place but nonethless, it was a nice, quick read.
kebreads's review against another edition
4.0
I really liked this book and look forward to reading more in the series.