Hate read the final book in this trilogy as I am a completionist. I did genuinely enjoy the magic system, world building and supporting characters, but Diana and Matthew are just simply not likeable for me. Everyone loves or is in love with Diana, who can do no wrong and is all powerful once she comes into her magic. Matthew remains possessive (under the guise of blood rage) and misogynistic (but this is how vampire families work).

The miracle babies are born and then largely ignored/papped off to family members.

Despite this, I likely will read the follow up, as I am a sucker for a time jump and would like to see how characters have developed 7 years in the future.

Content Warnings

zoenelson's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous challenging dark emotional tense medium-paced

Plot- or character-driven? A mix
Strong character development? Yes
Loveable characters? Yes
Diverse cast of characters? Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated

4.25

The trilogy, overall, was entertaining. The romance was convincing and thoughtful; the supporting cast was mostly wonderful and I enjoyed the character progression. I remain impressed by Harkness' ability to ground this fantasy in our historical and scientific knowledge.

This particular book did a few things well: it left enough open at the end for the reader to interpret as they please; it solidified Matthew and Diana's love story; and gave us more time with the supporting cast. I did not like that Harkness introduced

another existential conflict in the form of Benjamin raping witches to create a superior creature race. It's related to the main conflict but felt manufactured and was really dark without warning; it also distracted from the main conflict, so the resolution there felt unsatisfying even though it was desirable. I felt that the final battle scene was anticlimactic because there were no real trials or tribulations. Additionally, Matthew's refusal to form a scion was merely a plot tool and thus felt superficial and drew the story out. Speaking of which, this book, to me, felt very choppy trying to tie so many loose ends together which impacted the plot and pacing.

I wanted to rate this a 4.75 because I loved the first book and parts of the second, but choices to add so many elements in the second and third books diminished what the first book set up so well.

Content Warnings

gillian_aftanas's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous challenging dark emotional mysterious sad tense medium-paced

Strong character development? Yes
Loveable characters? Yes
Diverse cast of characters? Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

4.75

Content Warnings

aduqu's review against another edition

Go to review page

slow-paced

Plot- or character-driven? Character
Strong character development? Yes
Loveable characters? It's complicated
Diverse cast of characters? Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus? No

3.0

This book is a product of the early 2010's, when paranormal romances with chosen one heroines were a dime a dozen. Diana Bishop is not exactly a Mary Sue, but this book will beat you over the head with how special and chosen she is.

It's a fun read if you like paranormal romances and don't think about it to hard. I definitely rolled my eyes a LOT reading this, but it was always entertaining.

Content Warnings

heathenhousewife's review against another edition

Go to review page

challenging dark emotional mysterious sad tense slow-paced

Plot- or character-driven? Plot
Strong character development? Yes
Loveable characters? Yes
Diverse cast of characters? N/A
Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

4.5

Content Warnings

oksmithie's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous funny mysterious reflective medium-paced

Plot- or character-driven? A mix
Strong character development? Yes
Loveable characters? Yes
Diverse cast of characters? No
Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated

4.0

This was a final book of a trilogy that did not disappoint. There were some things that seemed over the top and unnecessary, but all-in-all, I was not mad at where the story/characters ended up (as is often the case for me with trilogies). This will be a trilogy that I will re-read… all 1500+ pages. The audiobook is also well done (for all three installments). I used a combo of paper and audiobook to read this trilogy. It was the only way I could get through it and still have a life! Well worth the commitment!

Content Warnings

reka111's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous dark emotional funny inspiring lighthearted relaxing tense medium-paced

Plot- or character-driven? Character
Strong character development? It's complicated
Loveable characters? It's complicated
Diverse cast of characters? Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated

4.0

I see you, even when you hide from the rest of the world. I hear you, even when you're silent

The review contains spoilers!!!

PRELIMINARY

OK, maybe too much time passed between writing my review and reading the book, but not everything can be perfect. I don't remember most of the book, or at least not quite, so I'm sure there will be parts I'll skip or jump over because of this. I really should quit this already, right?

Basically, I liked it more than the second book, somehow I always found it difficult – no matter how much I love it – to read historical fiction if it wasn't about a real person. Yes, come for me because of it. I think this book series has a worthy, albeit somewhat quick, end. I wouldn't call it memorable because it wasn't, but it was readable and perfect for one occasion.

──────────────────

DIANA

Diana has come an extremely long and difficult journey to this point, full of suffering and happiness, but I believe this was the first time she was able to really live, not survive, not exist, but live.

It's incredible that at the beginning of the series she abhorred her legacy so much and how insecure she was, but now she used and accepted it almost every day, not fighting it. It's been a massive growth that has taken place in her, and I think that's beautiful.

I was so happy that we got back the caring, compassionate, and devoted person we met in the first book, especially when she went back to her job, which was practically her life, so maybe that played a part.

She was honestly an incredibly strong character and something you could have fun with and learn from her at the same time. She deserved peace, a loving family, Rebeca and Philip, more than anything else.

MATTHEW

Matthew has an incredibly long history that has accompanied him throughout his life. He had bad choices, mistakes, and bad deeds, but despite everything, he never forgot what he had learned.

I understand him, but I don't. A brilliant scientist, a great protector, but also darkness itself—at least to his enemies, certainly. He had to fight an incredible number of battles throughout the story, as well as with others and himself, but eventually he managed to tip over to the side of the light.

I'm not saying I love him because his overprotective self is too much for me, but I can see him beneath so many shields, and no matter how much he denies them, his heart beats beneath them, full of good.

He's a soldier, but no one can ever fight forever, including him. He almost needed Phillip and Rebeca as much as Diana, if not more. Not only that, but he deserves peace and tranquillity, he does, more than anything.

THE OTHERS

Oh, my dear Ysabeau, I've missed you so much. It's unbelievable that she was left out of the second book, even though I would have been most curious to see how would she reacted to Diana. Basically, not much has changed about her, the same stalwart and persistent has become perhaps a slightly more human vampire. I owe her my soul for doing everything she could to get her family back on track.

Philippe, okay, he didn't get a real role in this book, but that letter. That letter broke me in so many ways I can't tell.

Gallowglass, he is the number one fan of the twins, for sure, and also the best “uncle” in the world. He is my heart and soul, he gives me pure golden retriever energy. I hope so much that he gets the ending you deserve, with a lovely partner by his side and surrounded by a big family because he deserves it.

Jack & Annie, my poor Annie, my poor little baby, she deserved a thousand times better. But Jack, he's still here, and ahh, I don't know how to feel about him. He was raised by a monster who ultimately has a heart, but somehow he was stuck in between. He lives lively and cheerful, but he has an incredible compulsion to conform and longs for Matthew & Diana's love. It hurts tremendously to know that he got his great-grandfather's illness (aka Matthew – don't want me to explain the family situation, it's complicated) and that he can't live life to the fullest, even if he wanted to. He deserves the whole world and all hope for a better future. Although he lived and did infinitely much—good and bad things — he will be forever my “innocent” little boy who wanted to rob Diana once.

Baldwin, all I can say about him is that I always knew he had a heart, even if his body was woven from the darkness itself. He went to war for Diana, even if it meant the world would collapse, but he did. It's not the best match—the two of them—but I'm sure deep down they respect each other, maybe they understand each other, but well, they won't get any closer than that haha.

Benjamin, I hated him so much that sometimes I couldn't even breathe. It's horrible what he did to those witches, horrible what he did to his family (if I can call it that). I'm so happy he's dead.

Sarah, my poor Sarah was so lost for a while without Emily, she fell into a dark place from which she could not come out on her own, which I understood, and I was unable to have either. Fernando gets my heart for taking care of her and doing everything he could to get her back to the light.

──────────────────

THE PLOT/THE PACE/ETC.

OK, the plot was understandable to me, but it was also a bit confusing, especially when it came to the Book of Life and the various DNA stuff. Basically, I think it was fine, but there were some weird things about it.

The pace was extremely slow, sometimes too much, could have been a little faster in my opinion.

The ending was nicely closed, albeit in a bit of a hurry, somehow I expected there to be a big BUM, but it didn't turn out, which I regret, and I'm a bit disappointed about that.

──────────────────

THE END

It's been an incredible journey, but really, from the very beginning to the end. I never thought a book could open so many worlds to me, it really did. It's terribly sad to say goodbye to them now, it feels so bad even though it's absolutely necessary.

Part of my heart will always stay with them, and one day I will come back here.

Content Warnings

More...