Take a photo of a barcode or cover
3.61 AVERAGE
3.61 AVERAGE
Beautiful imagery and a great walk through a different culture. Despite this, the plot line is too weak for me. I enjoyed seeing the world through Aref's eyes but I felt like it could have been shortened a good 100 pages to keep the pace.
emotional
hopeful
medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
Character
Strong character development:
Yes
Loveable characters:
Yes
Diverse cast of characters:
Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Yes
Horn Book described this book as "quiet and exhilarating". The "quiet" comes from a young boy, Aref, (7 or 8) resisting his family's move to the US. He doesn't want to leave Oman - where everything is familiar - to move to Michigan where both parents will be attending grad school. He never actually says "No. I'm not packing," he just occasionally places an item or two in the suitcase. He collects stones and while his main collection will stay home packed away in his closet, a few special ones will make the trip with him as memory keepers. Over the course of a week, his grandfather, Sidi, is instrumental in helping him say good-bye to home. They go camping one night in the desert, and visit the famous turtle hatchery beach on the way home. He spends another couple of nights at Sidi's house and they go on a boat ride. All of these things help anchor Aref. The "exhilaration" comes from the slowly advancing departure date and Aref's gradual acceptance of his departure. I was giving this book a solid 3 stars until I read a lovely bit where Sidi explains what makes a house happy: "What makes a house smile is - people. When they come in and out. When people talk and laugh together, the house is having a good dream." I may be increasing my rating because I have wonderful memories of my home in WV, but I liked the sentiment. I read this for my 2016 Reading Challenge "read a book set in the Middle East" (Read Harder).
hopeful
lighthearted
Plot or Character Driven:
Character
Strong character development:
Complicated
Loveable characters:
Yes
Diverse cast of characters:
No
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Yes
emotional
hopeful
informative
lighthearted
reflective
slow-paced
Strong character development:
Yes
Loveable characters:
Yes
Diverse cast of characters:
Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Yes
This book wasn't what I expected it to be, and that's okay! I was expecting a story about a boy leaving Oman for Michigan, and for the book's setting to actually change as well. Instead, this is a story about a boy accepting his temporary move to Michigan. It's a lovely quiet story about Aref, his love of turtles, and his grandfather, Sidi. Lovely.
A great book about change and how sometimes you're stuck doing things you don't want. Great for kids experiencing some change or anyone interested in Oman or how to be happy. I felt the book was a little short on plot and mostly took us on a tour of Aref's favorite activities with his grandfather and his state of mind. There are worse issues to have.
Gorgeously deep novel for children set in Oman. Wistful, detailed and concerned with the natural world, ideas of home and belonging. Conveys Muscat, Oman in detailed childlike innocence.
This was my latest book from my Bethany Beach Box, which despite mostly 3/5 reads, I have been enjoying. I actually really like children's fiction, and it's been interesting to see what books are considered worth promoting this way. Turtle was another 3/5 read, honestly mostly because it was quite boring. As an adult, it was rather obvious that Nye's entire goal was to write a book that showed a Muslim family in a Muslim country in a positive light. There is nothing wrong with that, but considering how people complain about books written in the 1950's and how they're "too sweet" and not at all "realistic", it seems a little strange to turn around and praise a book that is basically sugar.
Aref and his parents are moving from Oman, a country in the Middle East, to Michigan, so that his parents can complete their doctorate degrees. Aref isn't happy about leaving, and most of the book are little adventures that he has with his grandpa as they visit all of their favorite places together. I honestly ended the book feeling quite aggravated with Aref's parents, who seemed to feel that their education and life was more important than Aref being close to his grandpa.
But what really bogged this book down were the lists. We're told at the beginning that Aref and his family love learning new things, and then writing down what they have learned that day. So throughout the book, whenever Nye wants her readers to learn something, we have to suffer through a list, in Aref's handwriting, telling us about the habits of turtles or how awesome it is to live in Oman under the rule of a sultan, which really added to the boring factor in this tale.
I realize that I am not the target audience for this book, but even at the age of ten I don't think that I would have enjoyed reading a bunch of lists. All in all, this book came across as a book that practically screamed USE ME FOR A UNIT STUDY IN YOUR SECOND GRADE CLASSROOM, but in my mind didn't have a lot to offer just simply as a story.
Aref and his parents are moving from Oman, a country in the Middle East, to Michigan, so that his parents can complete their doctorate degrees. Aref isn't happy about leaving, and most of the book are little adventures that he has with his grandpa as they visit all of their favorite places together. I honestly ended the book feeling quite aggravated with Aref's parents, who seemed to feel that their education and life was more important than Aref being close to his grandpa.
But what really bogged this book down were the lists. We're told at the beginning that Aref and his family love learning new things, and then writing down what they have learned that day. So throughout the book, whenever Nye wants her readers to learn something, we have to suffer through a list, in Aref's handwriting, telling us about the habits of turtles or how awesome it is to live in Oman under the rule of a sultan, which really added to the boring factor in this tale.
I realize that I am not the target audience for this book, but even at the age of ten I don't think that I would have enjoyed reading a bunch of lists. All in all, this book came across as a book that practically screamed USE ME FOR A UNIT STUDY IN YOUR SECOND GRADE CLASSROOM, but in my mind didn't have a lot to offer just simply as a story.
Aref is not looking forward to an impending move from Muscat to Michigan so his parents can attend graduate school. After spending time with his beloved grandfather and having some adventures with him Aref begins to adjust to the move and even look forward to it. I liked the way this book showed different parts of Oman as well as food, language, customs, animals, clothing etc. I liked Aref and felt Western children would be able to relate to him despite their superficial differences. I also liked the warm family relationships, especially between Aref and Siddi, but I wished the adults had acknowledged and validated his negative feelings about the move, rather than simply trying to talk him around.