Scan barcode
mrsellygilbert's review against another edition
4.0
This book was a tough read- so much suffering- but very moving and well written. I wish the part set in Russia had lasted longer but I still enjoyed the book! Natalya was a brave and memorable heroine. Historical fiction buffs will love this!
flogigyahoo's review against another edition
1.0
A book I found boring despite its story of The White Rose, a group set up to fight against Hitler's Third Reich. V. S. Alexander has taken a incident during World War II in Germany and added a fictional story to it of young Natalya Petrovich who was born in Russia but moved to Germany before the outbreak of World War II with her family. Her father is arrested for "reading" certain books and she is persuaded that everything has to be done to fight the Nazis and the government. She becomes friendly with others that are involved in printing seditious literature and distributing them citywide. The leaders of The White Rose are caught and executed, but Natalya is imprisoned. In prison she puts on an act that she is mentally disturbed and is then sent to an asylum where she is sure she will be put to death. Her adventures until the end of the war make up the rest of this story.
There is something unbelievable about everything that Alexander writes. None of it seems real; her writing is stilted and childish. I did not like this novel at all.
There is something unbelievable about everything that Alexander writes. None of it seems real; her writing is stilted and childish. I did not like this novel at all.
caitcat's review against another edition
5.0
I received an advanced copy of this book from netgalley.com. All thoughts are my own.
V.S. Alexander charmed me with The Taster, so I was very excited to read The Traitor. I expected a stunning novel with difficult subject matter, characters brought to life, and a historical setting described so vividly and realistically that it made me feel like I was there. I was not disappointed.
The book follows Natalya Petrovich and is based on the true story of the White Rose. She is adamantly opposed to the Nazi regime, and does what she can to resist and fight back. She loses friends and lands in prison, but she never gives up.
The Traitor has stunning language. The characters are well-developed and easy to relate to. Everything is described vividly without going overboard. Time passes through the course of the book in a natural way; it doesn't feel like too much or too little is written for any given scene.
This was a hard read, but I enjoyed it. I would not recommend picking this up for a light read, but would absolutely recommend it to anyone looking for a WWII novel. The overarching theme of holding out hope even when things look hopeless is something that we all need sometimes.
V.S. Alexander charmed me with The Taster, so I was very excited to read The Traitor. I expected a stunning novel with difficult subject matter, characters brought to life, and a historical setting described so vividly and realistically that it made me feel like I was there. I was not disappointed.
The book follows Natalya Petrovich and is based on the true story of the White Rose. She is adamantly opposed to the Nazi regime, and does what she can to resist and fight back. She loses friends and lands in prison, but she never gives up.
The Traitor has stunning language. The characters are well-developed and easy to relate to. Everything is described vividly without going overboard. Time passes through the course of the book in a natural way; it doesn't feel like too much or too little is written for any given scene.
This was a hard read, but I enjoyed it. I would not recommend picking this up for a light read, but would absolutely recommend it to anyone looking for a WWII novel. The overarching theme of holding out hope even when things look hopeless is something that we all need sometimes.
dabutkus's review against another edition
5.0
I read this book in a few hours and I absolutely loved it. Natalya becomes a member of the underground resistance group, The White Rose and gets caught. But somehow luck is on her side and she defies expectations. The entire time I read this, I had a knot in my stomach. The author does a great job of keeping you guessing as you’re reading this book. I’d highly recommend it.
claudia's review
5.0
If you have been following my blog for a while (www.theloveofbooks.co.uk), then you know that historical fiction is one of my favourite genres. While I enjoy reading books about all time periods, I tend to favour books set during the Second World War. What can I say, I am fascinated by this period in history. When you read a lot of books that are set during the same time period, you start to notice similarities between the various books. In the case of books set during World War Two, you tend to see a lot of books set in Nazi-occupied France, concentration camps, or England during the war. There are also a great many books about spy organisations, or other organisations which helped those who were persecuted by the Nazi party. These are some of the more fascinating aspects of this period in history, so it makes sense that they are prevalent in books. By no means is this a bad thing, in fact some of my absolute favourite historical fiction novels fit into these categories. That being said, it is refreshing to find a historical fiction novel that teaches you something new about a period in history that interests you. That is the case with The Traitor by V.S. Alexander, and I think this is partially why I loved this book so much.
Considering how many books I have read which are set during the Second World War, I am surprised that I have never heard of the White Rose before picking up this book. The White Rose was a resistance group led by a group of students at the University of Munich during World War Two. The purpose of this group was to create active resistance against the Nazi regime through anonymous leaflets and graffiti. It was a non-violent group. In the authors note, V.S. Alexander says that he has "always found World War II a tragic, terrifying, and humbling subject," and that he was particularly fascinated by the White Rose movement. The White Rose has been extensively covered by academics, historians, and even filmmakers in the past, but I've never seen a fictional novel about this organisation. (I'm sure there are other ones, I am just not aware of them - if you know of any, please comment below and I will look them up!) I am actually surprised that I have not seen more about The White Rose in the past, because it is a fascinating subject.
While The Traitor is based around the White Rose, the plot and majority of the characters are entirely fictional. Hans and Sophie Scholl, as well as some other members of the White Rose, do make an appearance, but the protagonist Natalya and her activities within the novel are invented. The story of Natalya is a compelling one. The Traitor is really the story of one woman's determination to survive in Nazi Germany while sticking to her values and beliefs. It is a fascinating story; I did not want to put it down until the very end. I have a tendency to incessantly talk about books that I truly love, and that proved true when I finished this book. It has been added to my mental list of excellent historical fiction novels, and I know that I will be recommending it to people for years to come.
My only slight criticism of this book is that I would have liked to see a bit more about the White Rose movement. However, I also understand why the author chose to take the story in the direction that he did, and his decision does make sense for the plot as a whole. I am now even more fascinated by this point in history, and look forward to reading more about the White Rose in the future.
I would like to thank V.S. Alexander, One More Chapter, and NetGalley for providing me with an advance copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
Considering how many books I have read which are set during the Second World War, I am surprised that I have never heard of the White Rose before picking up this book. The White Rose was a resistance group led by a group of students at the University of Munich during World War Two. The purpose of this group was to create active resistance against the Nazi regime through anonymous leaflets and graffiti. It was a non-violent group. In the authors note, V.S. Alexander says that he has "always found World War II a tragic, terrifying, and humbling subject," and that he was particularly fascinated by the White Rose movement. The White Rose has been extensively covered by academics, historians, and even filmmakers in the past, but I've never seen a fictional novel about this organisation. (I'm sure there are other ones, I am just not aware of them - if you know of any, please comment below and I will look them up!) I am actually surprised that I have not seen more about The White Rose in the past, because it is a fascinating subject.
While The Traitor is based around the White Rose, the plot and majority of the characters are entirely fictional. Hans and Sophie Scholl, as well as some other members of the White Rose, do make an appearance, but the protagonist Natalya and her activities within the novel are invented. The story of Natalya is a compelling one. The Traitor is really the story of one woman's determination to survive in Nazi Germany while sticking to her values and beliefs. It is a fascinating story; I did not want to put it down until the very end. I have a tendency to incessantly talk about books that I truly love, and that proved true when I finished this book. It has been added to my mental list of excellent historical fiction novels, and I know that I will be recommending it to people for years to come.
My only slight criticism of this book is that I would have liked to see a bit more about the White Rose movement. However, I also understand why the author chose to take the story in the direction that he did, and his decision does make sense for the plot as a whole. I am now even more fascinated by this point in history, and look forward to reading more about the White Rose in the future.
I would like to thank V.S. Alexander, One More Chapter, and NetGalley for providing me with an advance copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
More...