Scan barcode
verovivaldi9's review against another edition
adventurous
emotional
mysterious
reflective
sad
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.5
Content Warnings
Graphic: Abandonment
Moderate: Xenophobia and Racism
just_one_more_paige's review
adventurous
emotional
mysterious
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
4.0
Years ago, if you had asked me, I would have said that magical realism was my favorite genre. And, while I do still really enjoy it, I don’t read it – am not in the mood for it – quite as often. (Though, when they hit, they hit big. Notable recent-ish favs being: Eartheater, We Ride Upon Sticks, and Nothing to See Here.) Anyways, I was feeling something like it, with the onset of fall vibes and cooler weather, and this one has been sitting on my shelf waiting for exactly this timing…
This novel opens with Orquídea Divina dramatically inviting all her descendants back to her home to “receive their inheritance” on the occasion of her imminent death. When they all arrive, hoping to finally get answers to the magic and secrets that have long plagued their family, they instead find themselves just in time to watch Orquídea transform into a tree. From there, the story unfolds in two directions. First, we follow Orquídea’s life, learning about her mysterious past and the deal she made that brought her ever closer to the ending the novel opened with. Second, we follow three of Orquídea’s (great) grandchildren – Marimar, Rey and Rhiannon – in the years following her disappearance from their lives. When an unknown threat from Orquídea’s past threatens the safety of the family in the present, they travel together to her home country of Ecuador to find the answers she was never able to give them, and take back the power, the promise and the future of the family from the inherited forces that continue to terrorize it.
Ohhhhh the magical realism, in the grand tradition of Latinx authors, is spectacular here. Spectacular. (reference intended) With grandmother growing roots, crocodile-like River spirits, resurrected roosters that lay green-yolked eggs, letters that arrive at their destination magically without addressing, living stars that grant wishes, mysterious biblical plague illnesses, and more this novel has all the magic and wonder a story could hold, and more. Sometimes I find that magical realism can lean into the obscure and obtuse, but this was perfectly accessible. And I just loved that entire aspect of the book, from start to finish.
I did have a few questions about the plot. On the whole, it was interesting and well-paced. There was just enough tension to keep me kinda on the edge of my seat, but never so much that I was *too* stressed out (for me, the perfect amount). And if I just lean into the general story-telling and entertainment, it was really solid. However, there were a couple small things that I wasn’t sure about. For example, I feel like the Living Star really should have held a bigger grudge against Orquídea. And I guess that maybe he did, but by the time he comes back in the present he’d already (somehow, and I have some questions about how that happened as well, since then he was back in “custody” when we meet him in the present, but whatever) worked through some of that and had a new/different investment in the success of the family. (no spoilers) And maybe the relatively greater evil they were all afraid of can explain away that forgiveness too. But still. It felt a bit too easy. Also, there didn’t seem to be enough time/space for Rhiannon to mourn for all her losses. And she was young, and maybe the whole family being there for her to fill in is the bigger picture message. But again, it just seemed a little too easy, too flimsy.
However, to sandwich those plot detail questions with the great things about this book. I loved the themes it is centered around. The way the Montoya family, led by Marimar and Rey and Rhiannon, overcome the past and face the secrets of an old terror, together, in order to claim what is rightfully theirs and move together into a safer and happier future, was fantastic. There were so many secrets that Orquídea kept. And just…what a commentary on how openly talking about the past and lived traumas can help prevent that legacy from being passed on and instead promote healing from it. Lovely. And the three of them were able to both overcome and simultaneously have, and keep, flaws of their own, which I always respect for authenticity reasons. Plus, the way the magical realism details supported these themes in metaphoric and symbolic ways all the through was done so well.
So, if you, like me, are willing to overlook a few particulars in order to appreciate the greater story being told, the vibes being built and the messages being communicated, then get your hands on this book. You will fall right into it!
“Damn the stars and damn luck. Damn everyone and anything who thought her insignificant. Orquídea Montoya was going to rewrite her fate.”
“In the end, family wasn't about blood. [...] You could be born into a family, but you still had to choose them.”
“There is nothing brighter than a wish. It comes from true hope. Humanity is so full of that. Desperate hope. Joyous hope. Even those in anguish, especially those in anguish, I should say, have hope. The anticipation that tomorrow will be better than the next day.”
“After all, belief was like glass - once broken it could be pieced back together but the fissures would always be there.”
“Lies carve out holes until they make one big enough to escape through.”
“How do you fight a thing that believes it owns you? How do you fight the past? With gold leaves and salt? With silence? With new earth beneath your feet? With the bodies, the hearts of others? With hearts that are tender and bloodied but have thorns of their own. With the family that chooses you.”
Content Warnings
Graphic: Death, Infidelity, Death of parent, Pregnancy, Toxic relationship, Violence, and Child death
Moderate: Injury/Injury detail, Fire/Fire injury, and Terminal illness
Minor: Bullying, Racism, and Xenophobia
issamay's review
adventurous
emotional
hopeful
inspiring
mysterious
sad
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
5.0
Content Warnings
Graphic: Death, Child death, Stalking, Toxic relationship, Sexism, Death of parent, Body horror, Pregnancy, and Grief
Moderate: Bullying, Violence, Sexual content, and Xenophobia
briely's review
challenging
dark
emotional
mysterious
slow-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.25
Content Warnings
Graphic: Infidelity and Death of parent
Moderate: Sexual content and Fire/Fire injury
Minor: Xenophobia and Car accident
leannanecdote's review
adventurous
emotional
inspiring
mysterious
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.25
Content Warnings
Graphic: Abandonment, Child death, Classism, Death, Death of parent, Fire/Fire injury, Grief, Mental illness, Pregnancy, Sexual content, and Toxic relationship
Moderate: Stalking, Violence, Xenophobia, Suicidal thoughts, Sexism, Injury/Injury detail, Infidelity, Emotional abuse, Drug use, and Cursing
now_booking's review
adventurous
challenging
dark
emotional
hopeful
inspiring
mysterious
reflective
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.25
I absolutely adored this fantastic work of magical realism meets multigenerational family saga. I love the work of Isabelle Allende and how she captures the complexity of characters in a family where heroes and villains aren’t monolithic but rather are complex with complex motivations and experiences that make them the characters they are. This is one such book. This is very much like if Isabel Allende focused more on the technicalities of the magic in her books to the point of almost approaching the fantasy genre. I’m not a huge fan of fantasy so I’m amazed how much I loved this. Indeed, perhaps that is because this is not quite fantasy, it is indeed plausible in the way it acknowledges that a pragmatic understanding of the world might find the events in this book fantastical and unrealistic, but there are phenomena we can’t quite explain and things that can be believed to be true beyond what is empirical and explainable. In a sense, when Marimar, Rey, and Rhiannon go on an epic journey to discover the truth about the origins of their matriarch Orquídea Divinia and save the rest of the family from the curse she has brought on them, it is an attempt to explain the lifetime of magic and surrealism that has surrounded their family.
For me, what I liked most about this book were the themes around family and loss and support and complex relationships and the themes of home. I think what tipped this away from fantasy as a genre and more into literary fiction is that despite having adventurous elements, this is ultimately a story about love and family and fighting more than it is one about magic or one that is about another world. It is about the extent one goes through for family, the bad decisions that have awful consequences and the struggle and sacrifices we make to make everything okay again. It also doesn’t hurt that the writing and use of language is absolutely gorgeous and even lyrical in parts yet accessible and unpretentious. The characters and their flaws are relatable and kind evocative of people you may know and situations you may have witnessed. This was a very readable book even in the moments where it was devastating or shocking. The depiction of the close relationship between cousins Rey and Marimar and their intrepid sidekick Rhiannon (who’s actually the brains of the operation), and the complex toxicity of Orquídea’s relationship with everyone- from her own mother Isabel, to her first husband, Lazaro the shooting star, her children and grandchildren, was great and really interesting to unravel. As a protagonist, perhaps she is not the most likeable, but she is interesting and complicated and there’s a lot to her as a characteristic.
I think there is justified criticism that much of the action of this book is saved till the last third or so of this book. So yes, the book is slow-ish, that said, I did really enjoy the build up and the set up in the first two-thirds of the book and thought it was essential if a little unnecessarily long with a transition that ended up telling a bit instead of showing. And I think beyond that, the past and present formulation might be annoying to some as it delayed or slowed the action somewhat, but again I understood this formulation of telling the story and felt it made sense and was enjoyable to read even though typically I don’t like past-present storytelling formats as I tend to find it kills the plot momentum. Perhaps I wanted more about Marimar’s personal life and maybe to know her more as individual beyond her identity as constructed within her complex family dynamic. Perhaps I think if Marimar and Orquídea were the main characters of this book, Orquídea by far outshines and outpersonalities Marimar and so it is perhaps a little implausible that Marimar is the Montoya family heroine because she is so minimised character development-wise in the story. Indeed, if we consider that the modern generation of Montoyas are the current-day protagonists to Orquídea’s role as the “past” protagonist, even then they are unbalanced because Orquídea benefits from much more character development and a more cohesive and complete story, even though there are patches here and there and there were places I would have loved the author to rest and dwell in a bit more to more explicitly develop the characters.
That said, despite all this, I LOVED this book. I enjoyed reading it and listening to it in audio. Frankie Corzo, the narrator did a fabulous job with it and really captured the drama and emotion and adventure on this one. Highly highly recommend for fans of Isabel Allende and fans of family sagas who love magical realism or are not fantasy-sticklers.
For me, what I liked most about this book were the themes around family and loss and support and complex relationships and the themes of home. I think what tipped this away from fantasy as a genre and more into literary fiction is that despite having adventurous elements, this is ultimately a story about love and family and fighting more than it is one about magic or one that is about another world. It is about the extent one goes through for family, the bad decisions that have awful consequences and the struggle and sacrifices we make to make everything okay again. It also doesn’t hurt that the writing and use of language is absolutely gorgeous and even lyrical in parts yet accessible and unpretentious. The characters and their flaws are relatable and kind evocative of people you may know and situations you may have witnessed. This was a very readable book even in the moments where it was devastating or shocking. The depiction of the close relationship between cousins Rey and Marimar and their intrepid sidekick Rhiannon (who’s actually the brains of the operation), and the complex toxicity of Orquídea’s relationship with everyone- from her own mother Isabel, to her first husband, Lazaro the shooting star, her children and grandchildren, was great and really interesting to unravel. As a protagonist, perhaps she is not the most likeable, but she is interesting and complicated and there’s a lot to her as a characteristic.
I think there is justified criticism that much of the action of this book is saved till the last third or so of this book. So yes, the book is slow-ish, that said, I did really enjoy the build up and the set up in the first two-thirds of the book and thought it was essential if a little unnecessarily long with a transition that ended up telling a bit instead of showing. And I think beyond that, the past and present formulation might be annoying to some as it delayed or slowed the action somewhat, but again I understood this formulation of telling the story and felt it made sense and was enjoyable to read even though typically I don’t like past-present storytelling formats as I tend to find it kills the plot momentum. Perhaps I wanted more about Marimar’s personal life and maybe to know her more as individual beyond her identity as constructed within her complex family dynamic. Perhaps I think if Marimar and Orquídea were the main characters of this book, Orquídea by far outshines and outpersonalities Marimar and so it is perhaps a little implausible that Marimar is the Montoya family heroine because she is so minimised character development-wise in the story. Indeed, if we consider that the modern generation of Montoyas are the current-day protagonists to Orquídea’s role as the “past” protagonist, even then they are unbalanced because Orquídea benefits from much more character development and a more cohesive and complete story, even though there are patches here and there and there were places I would have loved the author to rest and dwell in a bit more to more explicitly develop the characters.
That said, despite all this, I LOVED this book. I enjoyed reading it and listening to it in audio. Frankie Corzo, the narrator did a fabulous job with it and really captured the drama and emotion and adventure on this one. Highly highly recommend for fans of Isabel Allende and fans of family sagas who love magical realism or are not fantasy-sticklers.
Content Warnings
Graphic: Abandonment, Death of parent, Grief, Gore, Toxic friendship, Toxic relationship, and Emotional abuse
Moderate: Panic attacks/disorders, Sexism, Homophobia, Torture, Xenophobia, Child abuse, Gaslighting, Physical abuse, and Racial slurs
Minor: Sexual harassment
stevie's review
emotional
mysterious
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.0
Content Warnings
Graphic: Abandonment, Blood, Child death, Death, Death of parent, Xenophobia, Violence, Toxic relationship, Sexual content, Sexism, Racism, Murder, Kidnapping, and Confinement
perpetualpages's review
adventurous
emotional
hopeful
mysterious
reflective
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
5.0
CWs: references to racism/xenophobia; mentions of anxiety attacks; death and death of a grandparent; estranged parents; brief references to past child abuse; infidelity; descriptions of disease; and some graphic sexual content
Zoraida Córdova is one of those authors who I feel like gets better and better with every book of hers that I read, and this, I think, is undoubtedly one of her best. This inter-generational saga is ambitious, magical, whimsical, thoughtful, and it just hits all the right notes to make an utterly unforgettable story.
I've said before that it feels like this book could be our generation’s The House of the Spirits, and I stand by that, because it embraces all the traditional hallmarks of Latine magical realism, but also creates something fresh and new by filtering the story through the lens of modern-day millennials. There's such a beautiful and effortless blend of the historical and the contemporary, that honors and almost replicates multigenerational family structures—especially those found in Latine communities—in a way that I find extremely compelling.
In some ways, one might think that "magical realism in the twenty-first century" is an oxymoron, but it actually really works because that unremarked magic mimics the way that the world itself is so strange, unknowable, malleable, and mysterious. The implementation of that genre in a modern-day setting also really speaks to the evolution of tradition, and how ideas can change over time without negating the roots of where they've come from. One of the really special things about magical realism is that it positions magic itself as expected and commonplace, and this story is no different in that respect. The magic in this story is so deeply tied to culture, family, and history, that it just makes sense. It feels deeply personal, and like a natural extension of the inexplicable ways the world works, in a way that's very satisfying to read.
And above everything else, it’s such a powerful exploration of family curses—not only the importance of recognizing and naming family curses for what they are, but also the importance of coming together to break those curses. I love how the story plays with the idea of inheritance, because we don’t just inherit the good things we want. We inherit trauma, we inherit family history, we inherit burdens, we inherit pain and loss. The story really understands that there is power and there is joy to be found in family, and how we can gain strength and grow from our connection to family, but also how there’s an equal chance we can be destroyed by it.
This is a story that shows how there is literal power in knowing where you come from, remembering where you come from, embracing where you come from, and also understanding how that power can be a strength just as easily as it can be a weakness. I think it’s also a great reflection on just how much you’d be willing to sacrifice in order to be free, and also how the impact of one person’s choices can still be felt throughout generations.
Ultimately this story is a quest where these modern-day characters are trying to excavate their grandmother’s secrets, to uncover firsthand all the things no one ever told them, so that they can create their own relationship with their history, and with that understanding hopefully break their curse. It’s a stunning story where the historical and present-day counterparts shine equally, and it imparts a strong message about the power of family and protecting your magic. This is far and away one of the best and most memorable stories I've read all year, and I cannot recommend it enough!
Zoraida Córdova is one of those authors who I feel like gets better and better with every book of hers that I read, and this, I think, is undoubtedly one of her best. This inter-generational saga is ambitious, magical, whimsical, thoughtful, and it just hits all the right notes to make an utterly unforgettable story.
I've said before that it feels like this book could be our generation’s The House of the Spirits, and I stand by that, because it embraces all the traditional hallmarks of Latine magical realism, but also creates something fresh and new by filtering the story through the lens of modern-day millennials. There's such a beautiful and effortless blend of the historical and the contemporary, that honors and almost replicates multigenerational family structures—especially those found in Latine communities—in a way that I find extremely compelling.
In some ways, one might think that "magical realism in the twenty-first century" is an oxymoron, but it actually really works because that unremarked magic mimics the way that the world itself is so strange, unknowable, malleable, and mysterious. The implementation of that genre in a modern-day setting also really speaks to the evolution of tradition, and how ideas can change over time without negating the roots of where they've come from. One of the really special things about magical realism is that it positions magic itself as expected and commonplace, and this story is no different in that respect. The magic in this story is so deeply tied to culture, family, and history, that it just makes sense. It feels deeply personal, and like a natural extension of the inexplicable ways the world works, in a way that's very satisfying to read.
And above everything else, it’s such a powerful exploration of family curses—not only the importance of recognizing and naming family curses for what they are, but also the importance of coming together to break those curses. I love how the story plays with the idea of inheritance, because we don’t just inherit the good things we want. We inherit trauma, we inherit family history, we inherit burdens, we inherit pain and loss. The story really understands that there is power and there is joy to be found in family, and how we can gain strength and grow from our connection to family, but also how there’s an equal chance we can be destroyed by it.
This is a story that shows how there is literal power in knowing where you come from, remembering where you come from, embracing where you come from, and also understanding how that power can be a strength just as easily as it can be a weakness. I think it’s also a great reflection on just how much you’d be willing to sacrifice in order to be free, and also how the impact of one person’s choices can still be felt throughout generations.
Ultimately this story is a quest where these modern-day characters are trying to excavate their grandmother’s secrets, to uncover firsthand all the things no one ever told them, so that they can create their own relationship with their history, and with that understanding hopefully break their curse. It’s a stunning story where the historical and present-day counterparts shine equally, and it imparts a strong message about the power of family and protecting your magic. This is far and away one of the best and most memorable stories I've read all year, and I cannot recommend it enough!
Content Warnings
Graphic: Death
Moderate: Infidelity, Racism, and Xenophobia
Minor: Child abuse and Sexual content
More...