Reviews

The Living is Easy by Dorothy West

morgan__gayle's review against another edition

Go to review page

challenging reflective sad tense slow-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? A mix
  • Strong character development? Yes
  • Loveable characters? No
  • Diverse cast of characters? Yes
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

3.0

lolita's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous emotional funny fast-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? Character
  • Strong character development? It's complicated
  • Loveable characters? It's complicated
  • Diverse cast of characters? No
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

4.0

arisbookcorner's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Whereas The Wedding brings up many topics of discussion, the issues discussed in The Living Is Easy, are much more subtle. You have to read between the lines, look at the character's actions because their words are usually false. I have to admit, Cleo drove me nuts. She was so SELFISH. I can understand wanting your family to be near you since she hasn't seen them in many years, but the ways she goes about bringing her sisters to Boston is horrible. Cleo is manipulative, greedy, cruel and yet, she has her soft moments that hint at an inner kindess. The moments are rare and far between though. Worse than Cleo were her spineless sisters. Cleo really isn't that powerful, she is only able to manipulative those who are weaker than her, so she's not as impressive. She doesn't understand the concepts of saving money (thinking her husband's money will last forever) and she is stuck on color. Light color. Her dark daugther, Judy, is repulsive to her. Cleo herself is very light as is most of Boston's elite. Yet for all her faults, Cleo does have the right idea, she just goes about in a twisted way. She wants to teach her daughter and the children of her sisters to be proud Black children, they are second to no white people. "You're four little children. That's all you have to call yourselves. if you think you're different, you'll just act different, and people will treat you differently. Just remember that brains are the only thing that counts. And brains are not black or white. [...:] If she let her heart go, it would flood with pity because they were little colored children. And what would she use then to bolster their pride?" pg. 221-222

This novel provides a fascinating look at life in Boston for the Black elite. Some members tried to pass, they were usually successful because the rich Black Bostonian community would not tell their secret. It's infuriating but many of them looked down on Southern Black people. If you had no money and weren't a member of the Old Families of Boston, you were considered to be nothing. Issues of class and race intersect as does family. Cleo doesn't think she loves her husband, but she takes him for granted. I wish the novel had explored the relationships of Cleo's sisters better (especially Victor, Lily's husband. He seemed like a fine man until Cleo came along). The worst part is, Cleo ruins the lives of her sistes and her husband and daughter, but they don't blame her. The Living Is Easy quite clearly demonstrates that the living is not easy and it does so in a vivid, page turning way.

PS A sweet exchange between Serena and Robert as Serena prepares to leave her husband, Robert and the girls' father for Boston to visit Cleo. Robert: "'I can't read but a little bit. I never went to school.'
She said with tenderness, 'There'll be love in my letters, won't there? All you have to do is watch for it to spill out the envelope, and hold your heart ready to catch it.
'You won't go off and forget to come back?'
'When I forget God's in the sky, I'll forget to come back to you. And there's no way to live and breathe in this world without knowing God's on high.'" pg. 163

readincolour's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

My goodness, Cleo might be the most unlikable character I've ever read. She has absolutely no redeeming qualities.

jameseckman's review

Go to review page

4.0

I wasn't aware that there were black Boston Brahmins, but after reading this book it makes sense. Cleo is accepted into Boston's elite black society through her marriage to The Black Banana King. From the start the marriage is a rocky one, Cleo is not one to submit and her husband doesn't understand her need for wealth and its appearance. The setting takes place mostly in a house rented from a wealthy Bostonian who's moving out because of the arrival of undesirable neighbors, the Irish. Once the house is acquired, Cleo collects her sisters together and moves them in with her, which in most cases destroys the sister's family ties with their husbands and the sisters themselves. Cleo's need for control is also self-destructive, it poisons her relationships with almost everyone.

At the end all of Cleo's work is for naught, her family is growing increasingly poor and dysfunctional ending with her husband's business failure and his leaving for New York for a fresh start. An interesting bit of history wrapped up in a work of fiction.
More...