Scan barcode
calistareads's review against another edition
2.0
The artwork had an antique style to it. It reminded me of books from the 50s and 60s or publications from Sunday School as a kid.
The story was predictable. I didn't feel much reading it. The kids enjoyed Marley and I still couldn't bring myself to giving it 3 stars. Marley couldn't save this one for me.
The family is trying to get their pumpkin to the fair, it's a big pumpkin. Guess who ruins that? Yes Marley. I give it 2.5 stars.
The story was predictable. I didn't feel much reading it. The kids enjoyed Marley and I still couldn't bring myself to giving it 3 stars. Marley couldn't save this one for me.
The family is trying to get their pumpkin to the fair, it's a big pumpkin. Guess who ruins that? Yes Marley. I give it 2.5 stars.
soulwinds's review against another edition
4.0
Unlike some, I enjoyed the old fashioned art work and of COURSE Marley is the one who let the pumpkin lose. It's always Marley. That's why its his name on the cover and he has non-fiction book AND a movie.
Super cute, but I question showing the little girl feeding Marley pieces of pumpkin pile at the ending. Let's not give the kiddos ideas about feeding dogs pie.
Super cute, but I question showing the little girl feeding Marley pieces of pumpkin pile at the ending. Let's not give the kiddos ideas about feeding dogs pie.
More...