Reviews with content warning for War - This Rebel Heart

#TransRightsReadathon book 2! This Rebel Heart is a queer, Jewish, magical realist retelling of the student-led Hungarian Revolution of 1956 and a rumination on complicity, activism, and love of country, with golems, magic rivers, and polyamory with the Angel of Death. There were some pacing issues for me, but I’m glad this unlikely book exists and that I got to learn, in such an immersive way, about an important historical event I hadn’t heard of before.

Content Warnings

beautifulpaxielreads's review against another edition

Go to review page

challenging dark reflective slow-paced

Plot- or character-driven? A mix
Strong character development? No
Loveable characters? No
Diverse cast of characters? It's complicated
Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated

3.0

I had a very mixed experience reading Katherine Locke's This Rebel Heart, set in the city of Budapest before, during, and after the Hungarian Revolution of 1956.

For me, the strength of the novel was in its depiction of the historical context surrounding this event - incorporating the then very recent history of the Holocaust, which decimated Budapest's Jewish population. Locke - who is Jewish but not Hungarian - handles this history with care and sensitivity, and there are some great lines that resonated with me at the time I read them. The historical context was a big reason why I continued reading this.

But in my opinion, there were two ways in which This Rebel Heart fell short - characterisation, and magical realism (which is a genre I've had a lot of difficulty with in the past, but that's beside the point).

I'll talk about the characterisation issue first. For me, good characterisation is essential to my enjoyment of a fiction book- because if the author doesn't make you care about the characters, why should you care about what happens to them? And that was the problem here. The three central characters - Csilla first and foremost, but Tamás, and Azriel too - did not feel like real people. The way they spoke, both to others and among themselves, felt too formal, and often the phrases they used felt like philosophical musings than natural conversation. In Azriel's case, this is excusable given he is

literally the angel of death

, but to me, this excessive formality kept them at a distance. I also felt that the

polyamorous relationship that developed between Csilla, Tamás, and Azriel, while important for the sake of representation, lacked chemistry

.

Now we come to the magical realism aspects. I know there are some people who love this genre - but, as I mentioned above, I am not one of them. I do, however, enjoy fantasy, and I feel that the difference between that and magical realism is that fantasy doesn't pretend to be anything other than what it is, and the rules are clearly established from the outset. With magical realism, it seems to me the rules are that there are no rules, and that's my issue. With This Rebel Heart, I suspect Locke intended the magical realist aspects -

the city of Budapest is literally coloured black and white, the Danube River, the golem, and probably other aspects that I don't remember

- to be metaphors and symbols, representative of other things, but for me, they just didn't make any sense. I thought that the

river metaphors

were overdone, and I didn't always know how to make sense of them. Maybe my brain is too literal, who knows?

Katherine Locke deserves a great deal of credit for writing about a part of history that doesn't get the attention it should, but for me, This Rebel Heart did not work.

Content Warnings

pheereadsbooks's review

Go to review page

sad tense medium-paced

Plot- or character-driven? A mix
Strong character development? Yes
Loveable characters? It's complicated
Diverse cast of characters? Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated

3.75

I bought this book thinking it was about Hungary in post Second World War Europe. And it was! However, it also featured a fantastical element to it that surprised me. It wasn't bad, but definitely was something I was not expecting. I think I personally would have liked it more without the fantasy element, but I can definitely appreciate it for the creativity and extra level of complexity it brings to the table.

Content Warnings