3.87 AVERAGE


I thought this book was intriguing from the start. It started with a young girl named Truly who hates her new town Pumpkin Falls. She soon finds friends and finds a mystery to solve. I gave this book a 5 star because I think it's great for all ages.

A cute book with a gentle mystery, perfect for a book-lover's snowy day.

Recommended for 5th and 6th grade

Read this to my 10 yo daughter. So cute without being excessively childish. We loved it.
funny lighthearted mysterious relaxing medium-paced

3.5 stars ⭐️ charming small town story, really cosy.

4 stars
This was such a fun read. Maybe a little more...oh, what’s the word? Deep? Realness? Than the Vanderbeeker’s series with Truly’s military father losing an arm while deployed and all the teasing from siblings and schoolmates. But, I did really enjoy this story and all the bookstore parts. (I would say the Vanderbeeker’s series has more of a whimsical vibe than this story, though, this one is more realistic. I comment/compare the two because they are both Middle Grade books with large families and family dynamics.) I definitely am looking forward to reading the next book and hope to get this book for my own collection. Overall pretty clean with mentions of going to church.


Content:
Quite a bit of teasing over names and heights (but most of them are stopped by adults or other kids); Mentions of body noises; 3 dumbs, 3 hecks, 7 morons, 8 duhs, 8 shut ups, and 34 stupids.

As a middle schooler this book is truly stupid (No pun intended!). I don’t know any middle schoolers who would ever act like this. The characters have little depth. I read this for a middle school book club and every one thought it was silly and boring.

A MG mystery centered around an indie bookstore? Love! Review forthcoming

Loved this! This was amazing. I loved the voice of the main character. I loved the family. Every single character was so alive and well drawn. Just a beautiful book.

So heartfelt, loved it.