Scan barcode
rosiereading's review against another edition
funny
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
5.0
ellytheskelly's review against another edition
1.0
I've really enjoyed everything else I've read from Mariko Tamaki, so I had high hopes after picking this one up. Obviously, I was left very disappointed.
First off, I'm not a huge comics person. However, I will always make space to read comics with cool female leads, and I was absolutely willing to add Harley Quinn to my short list of comics I read and enjoy.
I am not big into DC or Batman, but I still felt really insulted by the way that Harley is molded into a manic pixie dream girl, thinking of things in absolutes, not caring at all about school, her studies, or even learning anything at all. She also sits on her hands and doesn't care when her friend is clearly being disrespected just because she is black. ( and that thread never gets addressed again? why? why include it at that point?) I've always had a lingering curiosity about Harley because she was known as super smart and intelligent, and just as powerful as the men surrounding her. But here, she just seems really ditzy? I don't see what it does for her story to make her so oblivious and uncaring about some things but when it comes to gentrification, that's when she cares all of a sudden, for real?
This is an easy skip, if you want to read Mariko Tamaki's work read Laura Dean Keeps Breaking Up With Me or This One Summer.
First off, I'm not a huge comics person. However, I will always make space to read comics with cool female leads, and I was absolutely willing to add Harley Quinn to my short list of comics I read and enjoy.
I am not big into DC or Batman, but I still felt really insulted by the way that Harley is molded into a manic pixie dream girl, thinking of things in absolutes, not caring at all about school, her studies, or even learning anything at all. She also sits on her hands and doesn't care when her friend is clearly being disrespected just because she is black. ( and that thread never gets addressed again? why? why include it at that point?) I've always had a lingering curiosity about Harley because she was known as super smart and intelligent, and just as powerful as the men surrounding her. But here, she just seems really ditzy? I don't see what it does for her story to make her so oblivious and uncaring about some things but when it comes to gentrification, that's when she cares all of a sudden, for real?
This is an easy skip, if you want to read Mariko Tamaki's work read Laura Dean Keeps Breaking Up With Me or This One Summer.
celtic_oracle's review against another edition
4.0
The characterizations were true, and oh, the art! Recommended.
historybowler's review against another edition
3.0
Probably closer to 3 1/2 stars. The art is so striking.
kathran's review
adventurous
funny
inspiring
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.0
Fun fun fun perfect comic awesomeness!
labunnywtf's review against another edition
3.0
Received via Netgalley in exchange for a fair and unbiased review
Man, this seemed like such a good idea.
Take Harley Quinn, everyone's favorite lovable psychopath, and send her back to her high school days. There, she meets Ivy, a vegetarian fighting for human rights, and John Kane, a rich asshole who desperately needs a mallet to the face. Harley lives with drag queens and eats nothing but chocolate and peanut butter bars. She's the perfect YA unvillain.
As the book spells out for you, this is basically a fairy tale retelling, without the fairy tale part.
This seems like SUCH a good idea. But there's a problem.
Harley's brand of psychotic is not meant for YA. She's utterly and completely damaged, and while in her solo comics she's lovably so, that doesn't work in this arena.
Props to Tamaki for not making the relationship between Harley and the Joker into a romance, but we were tilting towards that direction before she self corrected, and I'll take it.
I don't know if this is going to be a one off, but I really hope so. Leave Harley to the adults. Let kids find it on their own, without dumbing it down. Even if it is done with beautiful art.
Man, this seemed like such a good idea.
Take Harley Quinn, everyone's favorite lovable psychopath, and send her back to her high school days. There, she meets Ivy, a vegetarian fighting for human rights, and John Kane, a rich asshole who desperately needs a mallet to the face. Harley lives with drag queens and eats nothing but chocolate and peanut butter bars. She's the perfect YA unvillain.
As the book spells out for you, this is basically a fairy tale retelling, without the fairy tale part.
This seems like SUCH a good idea. But there's a problem.
Harley's brand of psychotic is not meant for YA. She's utterly and completely damaged, and while in her solo comics she's lovably so, that doesn't work in this arena.
Props to Tamaki for not making the relationship between Harley and the Joker into a romance, but we were tilting towards that direction before she self corrected, and I'll take it.
I don't know if this is going to be a one off, but I really hope so. Leave Harley to the adults. Let kids find it on their own, without dumbing it down. Even if it is done with beautiful art.
geekwayne's review against another edition
5.0
'Harley Quinn: Breaking Glass' by Mariko Tamaki with art by Steve Pugh is part of the DC Ink line of reimagined graphic novels for young adults. This is the best of the series so far in content and scope.
Harleen Quinn's mother sends her off to her grandmother's house to live when she gets a new job. Harleen has $5 in her pocket and discovers that her grandmother has been deceased for quite a few months. She is taken in by Queen, a large cross-dresser. Harleen starts school and makes friends with Ivy, a girl who likes plants. Harleen finds out that a program of gentrification is happening in the neighborhood and her friends' lives may be forced to change.
I really loved this story and art. The character feels like the one I know. There are some other characters in different forms in this. I loved this version of Harley more than others I've read. The art by Steve Pugh is so good. I kept just looking at the way he composed pages.
I received a review copy of this graphic novel from DC Ink and NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. Thank you for allowing me to review this graphic novel.
Harleen Quinn's mother sends her off to her grandmother's house to live when she gets a new job. Harleen has $5 in her pocket and discovers that her grandmother has been deceased for quite a few months. She is taken in by Queen, a large cross-dresser. Harleen starts school and makes friends with Ivy, a girl who likes plants. Harleen finds out that a program of gentrification is happening in the neighborhood and her friends' lives may be forced to change.
I really loved this story and art. The character feels like the one I know. There are some other characters in different forms in this. I loved this version of Harley more than others I've read. The art by Steve Pugh is so good. I kept just looking at the way he composed pages.
I received a review copy of this graphic novel from DC Ink and NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. Thank you for allowing me to review this graphic novel.
mayazinhaa's review against another edition
3.0
Achei o plot meio previsivel mas é bom para descontrair e não é nada muito denso para se ficar a pensar tanto quanto
É um solido 3.7 acho eu
É um solido 3.7 acho eu
tawfek's review against another edition
4.0
This was a buddy read with the Poetic Jayson and the Beautiful Whitney and the Kawaii Jenny
Canada has a winner and her name is Mariko Tamaki.
This is a tale of Little Brave Girls and Fairies fighting to stop puttholes and boogers.
I like this version of harley and i even like this version of young joker.
Mariko here reimagining the days of early Gotham, and a few of its residents like Harley, joker, Ivy, she gave them all background to what we know they will eventually become, that gradual progression is way more believable than joker who went crazy after falling in chemicals, or ivy suddenly becoming a nature person after her accident when she never gave a fuck, or Harley going from psychiatrist with a degree in curing mental disorders , to a stone cold killer just because she was manipulated by joker, a normal person with an education would most likely hand themselves over to the authorities, manipulation or not, but when you give her a record of not respecting authority, of being able to harm others and burn their things and tendency to taking matters into her own hands, now you are closer to a realistic switch to villainy.
Mariko is delivering a whole new modern origin story of Gotham, its inhabitants, their struggles, inserting modern feminism, LGBT rights, with a gentrification based plot, into her beautiful creation.
The only unrealistic thing in this novel, is Harley's fighting abilities, when Harley knocks out two grown men who work as guards, who are triple her weight, that's just ridiculous, specially when you ignore giving her a background in martial arts.
I thought joker's hair was way to pretty, that he must be a wealthy kid, but i guessed Bruce ! not the kane's kid, in hindsight Bruce being joker is too big a plot twist for a YA novel, that is followed by other novels featuring young bruce as a good guy.
The art i am not sure if it was intentional as a graphic novel about a harlequin and a joker, but those creepy ass smiles on everyone's face really made me not appreciate the art enough, even though its high level and really realistic, with a different coloring oh boy it would go up against sejic himself.
Now i like Harleen by sejic as much as the next guy, but just for the art, i think sejic failed to deliver a unique writing style, he failed to reimagine any of the famous stories that he wrote about, he used the exact same old stories and added nothing but pretty pictures and smutty romance.
Breaking Glass gets from me 4.5 Stars writing and 3 stars for art.
Harleen gets from me 5 star art and 2.5 star writing.
Canada has a winner and her name is Mariko Tamaki.
This is a tale of Little Brave Girls and Fairies fighting to stop puttholes and boogers.
I like this version of harley and i even like this version of young joker.
Mariko here reimagining the days of early Gotham, and a few of its residents like Harley, joker, Ivy, she gave them all background to what we know they will eventually become, that gradual progression is way more believable than joker who went crazy after falling in chemicals, or ivy suddenly becoming a nature person after her accident when she never gave a fuck, or Harley going from psychiatrist with a degree in curing mental disorders , to a stone cold killer just because she was manipulated by joker, a normal person with an education would most likely hand themselves over to the authorities, manipulation or not, but when you give her a record of not respecting authority, of being able to harm others and burn their things and tendency to taking matters into her own hands, now you are closer to a realistic switch to villainy.
Mariko is delivering a whole new modern origin story of Gotham, its inhabitants, their struggles, inserting modern feminism, LGBT rights, with a gentrification based plot, into her beautiful creation.
The only unrealistic thing in this novel, is Harley's fighting abilities, when Harley knocks out two grown men who work as guards, who are triple her weight, that's just ridiculous, specially when you ignore giving her a background in martial arts.
I thought joker's hair was way to pretty, that he must be a wealthy kid, but i guessed Bruce ! not the kane's kid, in hindsight Bruce being joker is too big a plot twist for a YA novel, that is followed by other novels featuring young bruce as a good guy.
The art i am not sure if it was intentional as a graphic novel about a harlequin and a joker, but those creepy ass smiles on everyone's face really made me not appreciate the art enough, even though its high level and really realistic, with a different coloring oh boy it would go up against sejic himself.
Now i like Harleen by sejic as much as the next guy, but just for the art, i think sejic failed to deliver a unique writing style, he failed to reimagine any of the famous stories that he wrote about, he used the exact same old stories and added nothing but pretty pictures and smutty romance.
Breaking Glass gets from me 4.5 Stars writing and 3 stars for art.
Harleen gets from me 5 star art and 2.5 star writing.
breakfastgrey's review against another edition
5.0
DC Ink is on a bit of a hot streak. Straight to graphic novel stuff from the Big 2 makes me nervous, but Raven had some buzz so I picked it up. It was fantastic. Harley Quinn is no different. This book even comes with an established powerhouse creative team. Definitely a great re-envisioning of the material. Highly recommended.