Reviews

The Quality of Madness: A Life of Marcelo Bielsa by Tim Rich

wilsoninho1's review

Go to review page

5.0

A fascinating delve into the history of the great man, going way back to his youth in Argentina, helping the reader understand what shaped Bielsa and what made him the man he is today. A good read for any fan of Bielsa, one of the teams he coached or even just football itself. If anything, it has given me an even greater love of Marcelo Bielsa, than I had before.

readernath's review

Go to review page

informative inspiring medium-paced

5.0

sfian's review

Go to review page

4.0

As a Leeds season ticket holder, it was practically the law that I read this book. Unfortunately, I don't read that much about football, especially non-English football, so two thirds of the book, as player after player, team after team, situation after situation were name-checked, I struggled. It was all jyst a bit too dry.

Don't get me wrong, the history of Argentina, the Bielsa family history and the scene-setting were all interesting. Some points had me chuckling, others reading out loud to my (non-football fan) wife.

It's the final third that interested me most, though, even though there's less of that scene-setting, a sudden propensity for strange pop culture references and some stories that I had heard - and which underline Bielsa's character - missing. (For example, the players being made to litter pick so they got an inkling of how much their fans had to work to be able to watch football.)

The book was also probably written too soon. Bielsa's second season at Leeds is covered, but only almost in passing. Delaying publication and updating the text just a few months later would result in a much happier ending.
More...