3.28 AVERAGE


Sweet story about a boy who gets his reluctant father to try fishing. Illustrations are very charming.

Just a boy and his dad in this story. But that's not the story. The boy loves fishing and the dad doesn't. Finally, the boy needs an adult family member to accompany him on an ice fishing trip. Dad goes...reluctantly. But after that trip, he's...(see title).

I can only hope that this story gets repeated in my household someday - my husband is emphatically not into sports, but there are enough athletic genes running through the family that our daughter will probably be pretty sporty. But I'm hoping that he'll discover the fun of being along for the ride!

I liked this particular story overall, but - as much as I like David McPhail's work - I worry that the old-fashioned illustrations will cause a lot of kids to skip this one.

A lovely family story, but also a great message about how even if we don't like the same things we can find something we like in interacting with others, lovely soft illustrations.

A young boy loves to spend his time fishing, but his father doesn’t want to join him in this picture book. Joe loves to fish, but his father just doesn’t understand the appeal and won’t participate. So Joe joins the local fishing club and they fish all over the area in different bodies of water. The in the winter, the club decides to do ice fishing and every kid will need an adult along. Joe is worried that his father will refuse again, but instead he agrees to do it just once. When the two of them get to the frozen lake, nothing much happens at first. Then they start to talk and talk together and suddenly Joe’s father understands.

This is a lovely quiet book, one that celebrates the silence and beauty of fishing and also the way that quiet hobbies can create opportunities for deep connection with others. Children not interested in fishing will still recognize the way that parents sometimes duck out of games and hobbies that they find unappealing. The illustrations are classic McPhail filled with luminous glowing light and a playful sense of storytelling. A great pick for fishing story times or for a quiet evening of stories together. Appropriate for ages 4-6.