Scan barcode
cookiecat73's review
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
4.0
Content Warnings
Moderate: Blood
Minor: Animal death, Confinement, and Death of parent
piperbunny's review against another edition
4.0
Such a beautiful story of rewilding, adventure and friends. With elements of Holes.
fant_ine's review
adventurous
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? N/A
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
2.0
bluewithstars's review against another edition
5.0
My first read of 2020. What a wonderful start to the year with a story of fear, hope and a family. This was excellent and I cannot wait to rea more by this author.
uma_booksbagsburgers's review against another edition
3.0
A huge thanks to Hachette India for a physical review copy of this book.
Actual Rating - 3.5
Where the River Runs Gold is a passionate book about the need to protect nature and save the environment, lest we fall into a state of dystopia like the characters in the book.
- Shifa and Themba are raised by their father Nabil as twins but Shifa is constantly watching out for Themba who is the more trusting and gentler of the two. Themba although never explicitly mentioned, is coded as autistic and the author beautifully depicts him as a boy who simply sees things in a different way. He is a wonderful artist and constantly takes to drawing and painting when he feels stressed. I particularly loved how he came up with rhymes to help himself remember more information. His utter innocence and ability to forgive people who have hurt him just tugged at my heart. PROTECT THIS CINNAMON ROLL.
- The bond between the brother and sister is just wonderful and I loved that even after Shifa finds out they're not related by blood, her feelings towards Themba never changes. (This is not a spoiler. It's mentioned in the first few pages). She is decidedly angry at Nabil for lying to her but she never once takes out her anger on Themba. It was beautiful how even when she got into trouble because of her brother, she wasn't mad at him. THE PURE SIBLING LOVE WAS JUST PRECIOUS.
- This dystopian world is one where the bees are dead. Where the only way of facilitating pollination of plants is by hand. And what better than little, delicate children's hands to do the job. The government paints quite a wonderful image to the public, of life on these "Freedom Fields" where children work and study but the truth is far from rosy. Within a few days of the duo's arrival at the Fields, Shifa realizes that the Fields are nothing short of a prison or labour camp.
- My biggest issue with the book was the number of unanswered questions about the world building. How did the so called caste system of Paragons, Freedoms and Foragers come to be? Why at the Freedom Fields there's no mention of food crops but rather of pretty flowering plants? (Considering the Freedom Fields were established to provide food to the people) And also the latter world building. The jump between the final chapter and the epilogue was so immense and we see there have been changes with the world but have no idea of how.
- Among the thing I liked is the author's descriptive prowess. The descriptions of places are so beautiful and vivid that I had an image of every scene in my head as I was reading. Another thing I really liked was how the author dealt with human nature. Generally in many middle grade books, the world seems to be in black and white but here there are morally grey characters. There are characters you think you will hate but then realize that they're nothing but victims of circumstance and I really appreciate how the authors portrays people.
Where the River Runs Gold is a beautiful book with important lessons on nature, love and family and would have been an exceptional read with more detail when it came to the world building.
Actual Rating - 3.5
Where the River Runs Gold is a passionate book about the need to protect nature and save the environment, lest we fall into a state of dystopia like the characters in the book.
- Shifa and Themba are raised by their father Nabil as twins but Shifa is constantly watching out for Themba who is the more trusting and gentler of the two. Themba although never explicitly mentioned, is coded as autistic and the author beautifully depicts him as a boy who simply sees things in a different way. He is a wonderful artist and constantly takes to drawing and painting when he feels stressed. I particularly loved how he came up with rhymes to help himself remember more information. His utter innocence and ability to forgive people who have hurt him just tugged at my heart. PROTECT THIS CINNAMON ROLL.
- The bond between the brother and sister is just wonderful and I loved that even after Shifa finds out they're not related by blood, her feelings towards Themba never changes. (This is not a spoiler. It's mentioned in the first few pages). She is decidedly angry at Nabil for lying to her but she never once takes out her anger on Themba. It was beautiful how even when she got into trouble because of her brother, she wasn't mad at him. THE PURE SIBLING LOVE WAS JUST PRECIOUS.
- This dystopian world is one where the bees are dead. Where the only way of facilitating pollination of plants is by hand. And what better than little, delicate children's hands to do the job. The government paints quite a wonderful image to the public, of life on these "Freedom Fields" where children work and study but the truth is far from rosy. Within a few days of the duo's arrival at the Fields, Shifa realizes that the Fields are nothing short of a prison or labour camp.
- My biggest issue with the book was the number of unanswered questions about the world building. How did the so called caste system of Paragons, Freedoms and Foragers come to be? Why at the Freedom Fields there's no mention of food crops but rather of pretty flowering plants? (Considering the Freedom Fields were established to provide food to the people) And also the latter world building. The jump between the final chapter and the epilogue was so immense and we see there have been changes with the world but have no idea of how.
- Among the thing I liked is the author's descriptive prowess. The descriptions of places are so beautiful and vivid that I had an image of every scene in my head as I was reading. Another thing I really liked was how the author dealt with human nature. Generally in many middle grade books, the world seems to be in black and white but here there are morally grey characters. There are characters you think you will hate but then realize that they're nothing but victims of circumstance and I really appreciate how the authors portrays people.
Where the River Runs Gold is a beautiful book with important lessons on nature, love and family and would have been an exceptional read with more detail when it came to the world building.
anyaisdumb's review against another edition
5.0
I ABSOLUTELY ADORED THIS BOOK!!!! One of my absolute favorites.The plot was amazing and the description the author gave on things is great! I hope to find something as good as this book and I hardly recommended for middle grade readers!!
raven_pine's review
3.0
I didn’t hate this book but I sadly didn’t exactly love it either.
I’m starting to feel that after the hunger games the dystopian trope became too frequently used and whilst I knew that this world was post-apocalyptic, I was hoping to avoid it feeling to samesy.
Sadly I got quite strong WICKED vibes from this book and was able to predict the ending within the first few pages.
I did enjoy the love for nature that this book had but sadly it just wasn’t for me but I am sure those who have yet to get fed up with dystopian will love this.
I’m starting to feel that after the hunger games the dystopian trope became too frequently used and whilst I knew that this world was post-apocalyptic, I was hoping to avoid it feeling to samesy.
Sadly I got quite strong WICKED vibes from this book and was able to predict the ending within the first few pages.
I did enjoy the love for nature that this book had but sadly it just wasn’t for me but I am sure those who have yet to get fed up with dystopian will love this.
darbs's review against another edition
3.0
A wonderful concept with great characters but I found the writing/storyline very jumpy with bizarre gaps. Ends of chapters don’t marry up with the beginnings of next chapters and entire events are skipped leaving you to wonder ‘what happened?’ I found this frustrating especially as this is a MG book. I know most of the 8-10 year olds I teach would not have been able to follow this story. As I said - it’s a shame because it’s a brilliant concept.
nicola_tyrrell32's review against another edition
adventurous
emotional
slow-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? No
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
3.0
adventuresinabookshop's review
5.0
This incredible story revolves around themes of dystopia, climate chaos and class divide which are more relevant today than ever. The importance of family and friendship and how if we work together we can bring about great changes are uplifting messages that ultimately leave you inspired. A wonderful book I couldn’t put down.
Waterstones Childrens’ Book of the Month for July is a gripping adventure suitable for readers 9 and above and something I would definitely recommend to adults too.
I was sent a review copy by the publisher.
Waterstones Childrens’ Book of the Month for July is a gripping adventure suitable for readers 9 and above and something I would definitely recommend to adults too.
I was sent a review copy by the publisher.