You need to sign in or sign up before continuing.

478 reviews for:

Jane

Maggie Nelson

4.33 AVERAGE


beautifully written. maggie nelson weaves an emotional look into her aunt jane's murder with her haunting poetry, jane's journal entries, and clippings of news articles revolving around said murder. the brief mention of the other rape-murders linked to jane's death is horrifying and sickening, reminding us just how fragile it is to live as a woman (a girl!) in this world. 

“Treating things lightly is indeed the answer to so much.”

subtle read about sisterhood, families, misogyny and men’s claim to women’s bodies. composed of news clippings, dreams, prose, poetry, and Jane’s own diary entries, reading this feels deeply personal and even invasive at times. this was both haunting and beautiful and feels like a true love letter even if the two had never met.  
fast-paced

Deeply affecting book. I liked it more than the argonauts, likely because I connected more personally to the subject matter.
dark emotional informative reflective medium-paced

How does one even write a book like this, so haunting and beautiful, full of love and grief? 
How does Maggie Nelson walk around with so much talent in her, without its sheer heaviness dragging her down?
Mother, the Christian hypocrite
and I, of her blood. Under
her influence — how much am I —
and I love her — at least
if I can love at all
I do.

(68)
For a book about a rape-murder within the family, it is not as dense as I expected and surprisingly easy to get through. It is not conventional poetry, more like a story written in verse.   

Expand filter menu Content Warnings
dark emotional hopeful mysterious reflective sad fast-paced

so brilliant, some of these pages will haunt me for a long time. such a unique way to pay tribute to a loved one that you never knew
dark emotional reflective fast-paced

 
i have no choice but to give this five stars because it was masterful. i'm convinced no one can put together a book like maggie nelson can. while i loved bluets more, i couldn't bring myself to give this lower than five. so smart how she combined jane's journal entries, her own poetry, and news articles about jane's murder together to create this book. there was such a similarity between jane's writing and maggie's, which was cool to see. this felt like a memoir that really honored who jane was; i was so fascinated by this person and also so angry that she only got to live twenty-three years. this was also such a good insight into how grief can span generations and impact family members years and years down the line. you could really feel how the loss of jane had impacted someone like maggie who never even got the chance to meet her.

once again on a mission to read everything maggie nelson has ever written!!



challenging dark emotional sad tense fast-paced
challenging dark emotional reflective sad fast-paced

oh how i’m a sucker for a story about family, the haunting of family, grief, and sisters. nelson paints a beautiful portrait of these experiences in this collection. particularly successful is how she can’t help but draw jane’s personality into herself. after my grandpa died, i found all i could do is think of the ways we were the same, how our habits compounded into each other. maybe that’s the easiest way to deal with loss, to fill it with ourselves.

reasoning for four stars: some of the poems and sections felt significantly weaker than others. nelson’s real strength is with her prose poems, in my opinion. my favorites were “lies” “sisters” and “ghosts.”

Expand filter menu Content Warnings