478 reviews for:

Jane

Maggie Nelson

4.33 AVERAGE

challenging dark informative reflective sad fast-paced
challenging dark emotional reflective sad medium-paced

Even though I couldn't get into Argonauts, this and Bluets have made me want to read everything Nelson has written. Few others could tell such a sad story of loss in such a deeply intimate, relatable way. Some favorite lines:

"Her youth an aura like a
new haircut—just blatant,
raw, crushing. A headband
keeps her brown hair back;
her lips are parted slightly.
How she wants. How she
penetrates, her eyes set back
in her brow like my mother's,
like their father's: dark
obedient, devouring."

"Tomorrow: holds France, perhaps.
Pittsburgh, of course.
Loneliness, so what."

"The whole photo
is dreamy, as if washed
in milk, Jane's skin
a pale apricot and
glowing. And I love it,
this lush, fuzzy sliver
in which two people
once spread out
on damp sand
and loved one another."

"They knew how to mourn
with dignity
,
my mother says.
It's the Calvinist way.
As if keening on your knees
were somehow obscene
As if there were a control
so marvelous
you could teach it
to eat pain."

"The skull
may flatten
the metal, but
the metal
will win. It
wedges in-
to the seat of
thought, uses
the pink tissue
as its envelope.
Two bullets:
one in front,
one in back
quickly speak.
They tell the heart
No more beats.

"The world is ours, but we walk in it
noticed."
dark sad medium-paced

An interesting approach to telling this tragic story. I think I did get a little lost with the format sometimes but overall was a good read.

Maggie Nelson is one of my favorite authors for a reason. Sure, there are some stumbling blocks in Jane-- some "what??" moments where I'm unsure what Nelson is trying to get at-- but all in all, this is a thrillingly quick and poignant read, and I am enamored with the almost spectral quality of its construction-- as if, at any moment, the small scraps of Jane's words could be lost to the oblivion of violent mystery burning a hole through Nelson's family's history. I can't wait to read the sequel-- The Red Parts. 7/10

Another book I devoured in one sitting. I guess being on break and quarantined leads to some great reading. I’ve always loved Maggie Nelson and her collections of poetry and essays. But this one is different! This is a story that is so obviously close to her heart and must’ve been such a difficult yet highly rewarding project for her and her family. I could feel that through the pages. The poetry was incredible, the clips from old newspapers made my stomach churn, and Jane’s diary entries made me tear up. I can just tell that Jane burned so brightly…I could feel her warmth through these pages.
janalinski's profile picture

janalinski's review

4.5
dark emotional informative reflective sad tense medium-paced

This book was so sad and heartbreaking! Although I will say, despite the tagline being "A Murder," it moreso tells the story of a life, several lives, and how they intertwine. It is a collage of lives, and quotes and diary entries, and poems, and it all comes together seamlessly.

Nelson is fr my favorite author glad I am alive and have eyes to read her writing. thankful
dark emotional mysterious reflective sad tense fast-paced

Expand filter menu Content Warnings