Reviews with content warning for Death of parent - The Darkening

After many failed attempts at picking up any YA book and enjoying them (I guess YA is just not the IT genre for me anymore), I am happy to say that I actually enjoyed The Darkening by Sunya Mara. It was unique enough to capture my attention, and that was a good thing.

I loved the idea of a storm eating everything in its path and slowly consuming the city year by year. I especially loved the backstory to the story about a Great Queen fleeing from her husband and creating a storm in her wake. It was a unique concept and was done fairly well.

I also found the magic system to be interesting, the ikonomancy. It sort of reminded me of how runes work in the Shadowhunter universe; granted, I know little of those runes, but the concept was fairly the same. It seemed that drawing ikons were an important part of the magic system. Then there was the Wardana, the guardians of the city, that protect them against the monsters that come out of the storm. I can't wait to see more of the magic system developed in the next book.

Finally, applause to the rich and diverse characters and settings. I could imagine many of the settings in this book, the shadows from the dark storm encroaching the streets, the colors and brightness of the higher parts of the city. It was breathtaking in its telling. Also, chef's kiss to the side characters Cas and Izamal. The dynamic and banter between the three Wardana is perfecto!

I did enjoy the main character Vesper. While her naiveness got her into a lot of trouble and she could annoying at times, she was trying to save a father that she loved despite his disappointment in her. She just didn't always think her actions through.

What could have been better/expectations for the next book:

More worldbuilding - While I understand this YA and I can't expect the intensity of worldbuilding like that in high fantasy, I am hoping for more explanation behind the Great King and Queen as well as how Ikonomancy came to be.

Dual POV - I believe that The Darkening would have benefitted from dual POV over the singular POV of Vesper that we get the entirety of this book. I think it would have helped with some of the explanations of what was going on.

Lackluster romance - Okay, so this isn't something I am necessarily upset about. Romance in books isn't my biggest focus anymore. I am glad romance wasn't the focus here; however, it was inserted and was weird at times However, I can see more potential for expanding on this in the next book. I am just glad the MC didn't have an instant-love situation and even acknowledged to herself that while she has growing feelings, her main concern is the storm and her father.

Whelp, that's it! I kinda look forward to the next book.

Content Warnings

hannianne17's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous challenging dark emotional hopeful inspiring mysterious reflective sad tense fast-paced

Plot- or character-driven? Character
Strong character development? Yes
Loveable characters? Yes
Diverse cast of characters? Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

5.0

For anyone that needs them:
Trigger Warnings: death of parent, bereaved child, child death, minor instance of animal cruelty (animal doesn't die), classism, sexism, suicide, grief, violence, death by fire, themes of terminal/chronic illness, generational trauma, natural disaster, injury.

Representation: Characters are described as having brown skin and South Asian influences in reference to world building.

I am genuinely blown away by how amazing this book was. I couldn't believe this was Sunya Mara's debut. It was poetic and beautiful in the best of ways.

Overview
Vesper Vale is thrown into a life that she didn't choose. Her father and her are on the run from the Regia and the Wardana in their kingdom. This is because her father and her mother were labeled as traitors by the Regia due to the rebellion they organized and led in an attempt to get justice for the lower rings (kind of like cities). Her mother was sentenced to death for her actions.

The kingdom is surrounded by a storm with no end. As it encroaches on the fifth ring (Vesper's home), the threat of it overtaking everything becomes real. Vesper almost gets killed by a storm beast (creatures that live in the storm), but her father saves her by using an ikon (the world's unique magic system). There's one problem....that ikon is one only her father knows because he invented it. Now, they must flee the fifth ring before he's caught.

This book will have your heart racing from the beginning. I was instantly hooked. Vesper is motivated for her own selfish reasons - to save her father. Vesper is clever and quick on her feet, though a little impulsive. I enjoyed watching her character growth as she grapples with complex issues. She's one of my favorite heroines by far.

Dalca, the prince, is just as clever and complex. Vesper and Dalca fight feelings for one another as they navigate the world that was left behind for them. Both of them destined to fulfill roles neither wanted.

The 'found family' includes Dalca's trusted Wardana members, Cas and Iz. All of them come from different backgrounds. Cas is from a privileged family in the upper rings and has a pretty classist mindset. Iz comes from the same ring as Vesper and is battling with his morality as he's torn between two worlds.

Their goal is the same - to stop the storm. All of them motivated by their own selfish reasons.
They're desperate enough to stop it by actually going into the storm where they must face their 'shadow selves' - all in different forms. Vesper's is a literal shadow. Dalca's is his inner child. Iz's is a monstrous cat. And Cas' is his alter ego of who his father wants him to be. The "perfect" son.

I loved loved loved this aspect to this book. It's a story about healing childhood and generational trauma and finding your identity. There were moments I got emotional because of just how raw and brilliant it was written. Especially when Vesper was forced to break herself apart in the storm and swallow every piece of herself. Even the ones she didn't like. As someone working through generational trauma, Sunya Mara put feelings I've experienced into tangible words. This will definitely be on the top of my favorites list.

Not to mention, the magic system is brilliant!

Let these quotes be an example of how beautiful the author's writing is:

"There is no turning back. The storm is within you now; where you go, it will follow. The only way out is to go further into the storm, further into you. Down and down you must go, until you descend into the dark heart of the storm, into the darkest pits of your soul. You must not turn your back on anything that you find. Face it all. Accept it all. Only then may you find what you seek."

"I become whole. I become me: light and dark and mystery between."

"The business of changing things. It's always worth being the enemy of a diseased state. I had forgotten that."

"The storm is one roiling mass of lightning and shifting beasts. Worse than ever before. Have I brought this upon all of us? Am I following in Ma's footsteps - dreaming big, leaving more pain in my wake? No. I won't let this happen."

Content Warnings

starrysteph's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous dark emotional hopeful mysterious tense fast-paced

Plot- or character-driven? Plot
Strong character development? Yes
Loveable characters? Yes
Diverse cast of characters? Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

4.75

The Darkening lives up to its captivating cover art. It’s got a great cast of characters, a clever magic system, and a uniquely terrifying layer of chaos within a living storm.

Our story takes place in a world divided into rings, with the poorest on the outskirts. A living, magical Storm that curses any who touch it threatens the land and has overtaken several of the rings already. We follow teenage Vesper, the daughter of failed revolutionaries who has a strong spirit and desire to save her community. When her father is discovered + captured for his past crimes, Vesper embarks on a journey to infiltrate the royal ring and find a way to save her city.

I found the prose very digestible - I would have absolutely devoured this as a young teenager. It’s simple enough for a young audience to understand, but still incredibly vivid.

The magic of this world is comprised of written ikons; symbols that can be combined and embellished and created by those with a deep knowledge of their building blocks. The integration of magic into the world was so creative and playful; I loved discovering all the nifty ways ikons could be used, whether you’re desperately scratching a symbol into the dirt to save your life or using an incomplete ikon to hide a secret passage or adding a sense of wonder to pastries by using ikons to charm candied decorations to life.

The living Storm was fascinating … a representation of pain and grief and fear, and what happens when you retract into yourself and let rage take over as protection. Everyone who touches or is touched by an element of the Storm is forever changed (cursed) in a way unique to their flaws or secrets.

This is a world of gods, but the only god exacting his power via the current rulers is a dangerous representation of aggressive, toxic masculinity that leaves no room for adaptation.

I found our main character Vesper very likable. She certainly has her flaws, and has a big coming-of-age arc, but she’s determined and witty and clever. I was rooting for her with all my heart & loved her journey of self-discovery and discovering her confidence and power. I also appreciated the complexity of the side characters; they were all so charming in their own ways.

I also enjoyed the elements of political intrigue: what does it mean to be a good ruler (is there such a thing)? We’re witnessing two different perspectives here (Vesper, who lives on the outskirts of society, and the prince in line to become Regia) and they grapple to determine which approach will best serve the needs of their city.

Finally, it’s tough to talk about this without giving too much away, but the backstory of the Storm was delightful. I’m truly looking forward to the sequel (and a bit nervous!).

(And yeah yeah, there’s the start of an enemies to lovers arc if that tickles your fancy.)

CW: death, child death, death of a parent, animal cruelty, classism, confinement, chronic illness, terminal illness, injury, possession, fire/death by fire, suicide, sexism, misogyny, grief

Content Warnings

idealpages's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous dark mysterious tense fast-paced

Plot- or character-driven? A mix
Strong character development? It's complicated
Loveable characters? Yes
Diverse cast of characters? No
Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

3.75

Content Warnings

bookwormbullet's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous challenging dark emotional mysterious sad tense medium-paced

Plot- or character-driven? A mix
Strong character development? It's complicated
Loveable characters? Yes
Diverse cast of characters? Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

3.75

Content Warnings

More...