Reviews

The Jekyll Revelation by Robert Masello

ameserole's review against another edition

Go to review page

2.0

The only thing I liked about this book... was that it was an audio and I could do other things while listening to it. THE ONLY THING. Oh, and the ending.

The Jekyll Revelation was not my cup of tea. No, it was really boring. Like... I actually wanted to do my work and go to meetings INSTEAD of listening to a book for fun. I really wanted to enjoy it .. but yeah I didn't.

Okay, so it's told in the past and present - which usually I like.. but yeah, not with this book for some odd reason. It could be because of the narrator.. but I honestly have no idea. Everything just kind of felt slow.. even when I was looking at the pages while the narrator was reading. I kind of wish everything was more fast paced.. or something! Maybe the narrator was bored while reading or maybe he just wasn’t the right guy to read this book. It could also be because of the writing. I don’t know, I feel like I’m in the minority for this book.

The only thing that I did like was when Jack the Ripper was mentioned. Which was probably about half way through the book. I do love any story he is in.. but then I quickly got bored again because Jack wasn't really in the picture anymore. I didn't really care for who "Hyde" was in this book either.

I did like the ending though, because it was over mostly, but it also tied everything together. Both sides came to an end which was kind of intriguing and interesting. Thus, the book was over and I was happy! Ecstatic people!

Overall, it was meh and boring. Will never reread it again in my life.

saki92's review against another edition

Go to review page

challenging dark mysterious tense medium-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? Character
  • Strong character development? It's complicated
  • Loveable characters? It's complicated
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

5.0

cathyatratedreads's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

I read this because I was reminded recently of how much I appreciated Masello’s Blood and Ice, a very good thriller that brought an old source of terror to a station at the South Pole when scientists find two bodies entombed in ice. I liked the combination of history, science, suspense, and some fantastical elements to craft a page-turning suspense story. This book uses the same devices: history, science, suspense, and a touch of fantasy to bring evil from the past to the current day. I found I preferred the first, however; I don’t think I quite got as caught up in the story and characters in this one. It was interesting to read a very different genre of book that’s about Robert Louis Stevenson, as I still remember much about him and his wife, Fanny, from a biographical novel called Under the Wide and Starry Sky. It was kind of fun to see the same people and their real experiences portrayed in a suspense book.
Read my full review, including a rating for content, at RatedReads.com: https://ratedreads.com/the-jekyll-revelation-thriller-suspense-book-review/

judascomplex's review

Go to review page

5.0

If one thing is evident about me and my literary affections (and there's a lot more than one thing, but let's just go with it here) it's that all you need to do is mention Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde to get my attention. I am a huge fan of the story, of all its various renditions, and how well any popular culture actually gets to portraying the proper Jekyll and Hyde that Robert Louis Stevenson created. (Hint: almost none.) So when this came across my feed in NetGalley, I jumped on the chance to read the ARC.

That being said, this review is coming out far later than it should have, and I went and borrowed the book from Amazon to finish it. But I'm especially grateful that I did.

The book has two timelines: a modern one, where we follow Rafael Salazar and the coyotes he's monitoring in Topanga Canyon, California, and the other beginning in 1881, following none other than Stevenson himself. It's nearly impossible to figure out why we're following both of them, and I found it difficult to invest myself in the book at first, because I couldn't figure out why I was supposed to care about Rafe. There wasn't anything wrong with him, I just didn't have a connection. I mean, I agree that coyotes are probably cool and a good thing to study, and environmental agents should have places in books too. But.

As time went on, it began to clear up. Stevenson was in a far away portion of Switzerland, hoping to find some cure for the health issues that had been plaguing him for far too long. During his time there, a wolf begins to play a very prominent role in the story--and just around then, Rafe starts noticing that there's something bigger than his coyotes wandering around the woods here. Now I'm getting interested.

We follow Stevenson, through journal entries, through his time in Davos (Switzerland) and the trials and tribulations he faced there--and here we begin to see where we may be going, with the introduction of a strange elixir that Dr. Rüedi gives to him, and the sudden surge of strength and indifference to danger that comes along with the taking of it. Sure enough, we follow into the time where Stevenson writes and publishes Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde, his own struggles with duality--and then, as it did in real life, the onset of Jack the Ripper and suspicions being leveled at Stevenson.

Meanwhile in California, Rafe has found a large steamer trunk in the middle of a lake and doesn't quite know what to do with it, though he knows he doesn't want the local riff-raff getting their hands on it. Once open, he finds antique clothes which have clearly seen better days, an assortment of other knick-knacks, a pocket watch with unfamiliar initials carved on it...and a strange journal, which seems to have tales of Switzerland in it. And as things start to get bizarre with the people around him, he starts to wonder what else he's unlocked with this trunk.

It's a truly fascinating look at the times; I had been unaware that Jekyll and Hyde and Jack the Ripper coincided in real life, and that apparently RLS had in fact been considered for one of the Ripper's possible identities. A quick glance through some basics of RLS's life shows that the basics--where he lived, when he was there, nicknames he's given--are all true. Of course, there are some liberties taken, and they're pretty easy to pick out. But all things considered, it's a wonderful piece of fiction.

I do think that the modern-day portions of the book are lacking. I don't really have much drive to care about Rafe, no matter how cool he seems, and there are a lot of characters who are introduced simply to be a plot point...and then vanish again. It's clear by the end that the author wants to bring the whole story around to meet back up with itself, but there's not a strong connection to hold onto. If that had been strengthened, I think it would have been better--but all things considered, even if they'd just been taken out entirely, the story would have been just as enjoyable. It feels like a missed opportunity.

However, as you can see from my rating, I haven't let that detract from my opinion overall. No matter how long it took me to get into it, once I was hooked I read the book in mere hours. The tone is perfect, the setting is good, the pacing is spaced without dragging. I enjoyed seeing Stevenson in his version of London, and the pieces of Jack the Ripper poking in. (I also noted some homages to real people in the names, though I don't know if they actually existed in that time and place, or not. It was still nice.)

In the end, a very enjoyable book, and certainly enough to make me interested in other things Masello has written. He's good with his words, and better with his research. Especially if you have a fondness for RLS, Jekyll and Hyde, or Jack the Ripper, I'd very much suggest picking up this book. It's well worth the read.

Rating: ***** (Highest Recommendation)

kaybttl's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

It took me quite a while to really become intrigued by this novel. While I can get into the concept & don't mind historical fiction the secondary story really didn't suck me in until the end. The final 1/3 of the book was very enjoyable.

vicrine's review against another edition

Go to review page

2.0

3/10 Wolves again. Fire in a canyon again. Three hooligans that blunder around and mess everything up again. Another priceless awesome historical thing that only one person gets to see...gone. Again. Thrilling as always but now I'm finding the stories are way too similar.

the_widow_roberts's review

Go to review page

5.0

Totally immersed

Sometimes when a story is told in two different timelines, you either prefer one or the other . Or the author spends too much time on one and not the other. This novel was a perfect combination of the timelines. I was totally immersed in the story.

jacks_library68's review against another edition

Go to review page

LOVED IT. Robert has a way of telling this story that made me want to keep reading. Never a dull moment. Looking forward to reading his other novels as well. A must read for fans of RLS and Jack the Ripper.

mcbeezie's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

This story held me the entire time. I like flipping between modern day and RLS's time. I wish it had ended differently for that section but I understand why Mr. Masello ended it the way he did. It was a bit ambiguous on the fate of Louis, but I liked that. A great read and highly recommended. Thanks to NetGalley for providing a copy in exchange for my review.

khyland's review

Go to review page

dark mysterious medium-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? Plot
  • Strong character development? No
  • Loveable characters? No
  • Diverse cast of characters? Yes
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? No

2.5