Reviews with content warning for Slavery - Hall of Smoke

Reviews tagging 'Slavery'

Hall of Smoke by H.M. Long

14 reviews

maggiemillar's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous dark mysterious tense medium-paced

Plot- or character-driven? Plot
Strong character development? Yes
Loveable characters? Yes
Diverse cast of characters? No
Flaws of characters a main focus? No

4.5

Content Warnings

samusc's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous dark emotional mysterious medium-paced

Plot- or character-driven? A mix
Strong character development? Yes
Loveable characters? Yes
Diverse cast of characters? Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

5.0

This is fantasy at its absolute best.

H. M. Long, in her debut, has perfected the balance between writing intense battle scenes and tender human moments (braiding hair).

The scene at Oulden’s feet was phenomenal and the moment that solidified this as a 5 star read to me.

Long has created distinct pantheons of Gods that are warring with each other, while the people that worship them are also in combat. The magic system is unique and immersive. The Gods are all intimidating, and Hessa’s interactions with them kept me reading on into the night.

Throughout Hessa’s journey, she encountered many friends and foes, while navigating a brutal natural environment, as well as the trauma of losing most of her kin. These characters are multifaceted, and Ogam has one of the best character arcs I’ve seen in recent fantasy.

The conclusion is incredibly satisfying, and not rushed, the last act taking up I think 80/400 pages.

I love the tagline of Hall of Smoke, To Err is Divine, and how this epic is built upon the impact of the decisions we make.

I’d recommend this to longtime fans and newcomers of fantasy alike, and especially fellow AC: Valhalla players.

Content Warnings

onceuponabookcase's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous dark mysterious tense fast-paced

Plot- or character-driven? Character
Strong character development? Yes
Loveable characters? It's complicated
Diverse cast of characters? Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus? No

3.5

I received this eProof for free from Titan Books via NetGalley for the purposes of providing an honest review.

Hall of Smoke by H. M. Long sounded right up my street when I first heard about it. A war between old gods and new gods? Sign me right up! But while I was gripped while reading, I finished with mixed feelings.

I found Hall of Smoke a little hard going at first. It starts off where Hessa has already failed to kill the traveller she was ordered to by her goddess, Eang. She's at her shrine up on the mountainside, several hours walk from her town, attempting to atone for failing her. And within a matter of pages, her town is attacked, but Hessa is too far away to make any difference. When she finally gets there, she finds her people have been massacred. We're thrown right into the deep end from the very beginning. There's no time for us to get emotionally involved, to feel attached to any of the characters. That's it, done, they're dead.

But at the same time, because it starts right away, we're not really given the opportunity to learn about the people of this world, who they are, what the politics is. We know the Agatti live north on the Eangen, they've never got on, and the Agatti raid Eangen towns a couple of times a year, but nothing ever like this. But we know nothing more at that point. We do get flashback chapters where Hessa thinks back to when she was younger, which gives us some context as to who the Eangen and Eangi are, but it just felt disjointed. And with other groups of people, we find out about them as we go, and it can get confusing when you don't yet understand yet why Hessa is reacting to them the way she is. I feel like there should have been a prologue or something, or the story should have started earlier, to give us some background as to who all the players are and what their politics is, who they worship, the various alliances and enmity between the gods, and the general history of the world as the Eangen people know it. I just had so many questions for the first quarter of the book, and really considered just putting it down. I was confused, and I didn't have time to get emotionally involved, so I also didn't care. The only thing that kept me reading was the fact that the story does move very quickly.

At first, this added to the confusion; between one page and the next, Hessa is on the other side of the world. Granted, she's unconcious for most of the journey, but it was startling. She was just in one situation, and now she's in a completely different situation. But this actually worked in the book's favour. After that first quarter, I had a fair handle on who all the different countries were peopled by and what their poltics was and who they worshipped. Otherwise, we just as much in the dark as Hessa. Hessa is struggling to reach her goddess, who is normally pretty responsive, other gods are in hiding, and other creatures are awakening, and Hessa doesn't have a clue what's happening. She's just lost her people, and is railing through grief, but she doesn't have time to deal with what she is feeling. She has to try and find the traveller and kill him to atone and to earn back her place in the High Halls after she dies, but the world is in chaos at the same time. While it isn't always action, action, action, something is always happening, and it's very fast paced. I still wasn't emotionally involved, and I hadn't connected to Hessa, but the mystery was intriguing. At every turn, you're never sure who Hessa should trust, what the truth is, or what's actually happening, and with Eang becoming more and more difficult to get ahold of, Hessa is lost at sea. It became really gripping, the more questions that crop up, the few answers we get.

I have to say I loved the worldbuilding. It's a very intriguing world, with gods that are very much a part of their worshipers' lives, and I was reminded of Greek mythology, as the ew gods had defeated the old gods, and were now in power, much like the Greek gods fighting the Titans. But there are secrets and lies and things kept hidden, and not everything is as it seems. There are so many layers, and they unfold layer by layer as the story progresses. I was desperate to know what the truth was of this world, of the people, and it's history.

So for the most part, I enjoyed Hall of Smoke. I was intrigued and gripped, and loved how quickly it moved, never letting the story lull. But I never really cared about any of the characters. While this book has a conclusion, and we get all the answers, there is meant to be a sequel, and I'd definitely be up for reading it, so that shows you how my feelings changed towards the book. But I definitely feel like the beginning could use some work, and give the reader some time to get emotionally involved, because I still never really cared about the characters. Hall of Smoke is overall enjoyable, but it could definitely have been better.

Content Warnings

readingbetweenthenotes's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous challenging tense medium-paced

Strong character development? Yes
Loveable characters? It's complicated
Diverse cast of characters? Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

4.0

Hall of Smoke is a really solid debut fantasy novel! It centres on Hessa, a warrior-priestess with the power to destroy her enemies with 'Fire'. Hessa has been tasked by her goddess with an important mission and the story's focus is on her attempts to carry this out.

I must admit, it took me a little while to get into this one. There are a lot of character and place names to get your head around, some of which sound quite similar, so it took me quite a bit of concentration at first. However, it's certainly not as difficult as some high fantasy novels so it might act as a good gateway into that genre if it's something you're interested in pursuing? Also, the book does contain a very handy glossary.

After the first 100 pages or so, I got really into this one. I loved following Hessa on her journey. She is a brave heroine and her grief over an early event in the novel is explored sensitively. I also loved seeing all the gods that featured throughout the book! It reminded me a bit of The Bear and the Nightingale by Katherine Arden and American Gods by Neil Gaiman. I love books that feature mythology and this one seemed to take a really unique slant.

Finally, I love that this is a standalone! So many books now are part of a series and sometimes it's good to just be able to enjoy a story for what it is and not worry about where it will go next or how long it will take to get answers. The author has said that there will be another book set in the same world but this will be a standalone too.

Overall, I'd recommend this one if you're looking for a strong fantasy featuring a gutsy heroine and plenty of twists and turns!

[I received my copy for free from Titan Books. This does not affect my review in any way.]

Content Warnings

More...