Reviews

Dying in the First Person by Nike Sulway

abbeydehnert's review

Go to review page

dark hopeful mysterious reflective sad tense medium-paced

2.75

Very wordy, but Sulway has a gift for using beautiful words that create the portraits of a scene. The revelation about Ana was surprising and I thought the novel created believable characters even if some of the features are unbelievable  

Expand filter menu Content Warnings

dominique_wilson's review

Go to review page

5.0

In sensuous, evocative language, Sulway's Dying in the First Person tells the story of twin brothers – Morgan and Samuel – who, as children, developed both the language of Nahum and its accompanying imaginary world. As adults, Morgan wanders the world, and his only communication with Samuel is the stories he sends, and which Samuel then translates into English for publication. When Morgan dies unexpectedly, Ana – a woman who may or may not have been his lover – brings his body, and the last Nahum story, back to Australia.

Although this is a realist novel, still there is an element of magic realism to Sulway's prose, reminiscent of García Márquez's writing. It is a multifaceted book in which Sulway unmasks, with delicate nuance, the complex relationships and contradictory feelings we experience through loss, love and hate – the way we see ourselves and the way we interpret our relationships, the way one truth can have multiple versions of meaning, how silences are in fact anything but silent, and how we are inescapable connected to landscape. It is both a meditation on grief, and an exploration of identity – on our sense of self and on how and where we belong.

Nike Sulway's Dying in the First Person is not a book you just read – it is one that you experience, one exquisite sentence at the time.


wtb_michael's review

Go to review page

4.0

A beautiful, haunting book that's packed with original ideas, wonderful sentences and surprising moments. There's a lot going on below the surface here - big themes of identity, language, grief and love are tackled artfully and there's a richness to the language that repays close reading. The pace dragged a little for me in the middle section, but the ending is wonderful.
More...