Scan barcode
mind_of_kaykay's review against another edition
adventurous
mysterious
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? No
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
2.25
aminakara's review against another edition
adventurous
challenging
dark
mysterious
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
5.0
speesh's review
4.0
If you’ve been with Robert Fabbri’s story of Vespasian from the start *raises hand* then you’ll know what you’re getting with each book. Great writing, a flexible approach to weaving the story in and out of the historical timeline, facts, speculation, and a superb story. Every time. That’s not to say they’re predictable, this is Rome we’re talking about, and at one of its most tumultuous periods (weren’t they all?) at that. And, it’s a 'real' historical character, Vespasian, trying to steer his family’s ship safely through dangerous and largely uncharted waters. If you’ve anything about you, you’ll know how it all ends, the trick Robert Fabbri has to do - and is doing it magnificently so far - is keep us on the edges of our seats, trying to figure out what could possibly happen next, how and if Vesp will survive...
Book IV, was incredible. One of my most favouritest books of last year. This one carries on where that left off. In that Vespasian and the Roman Army are still in the process of subduing the Britons. Or the Celts. Mostly, the Druids, who don’t want to see common sense, and who believe they are custodians of an even older legacy. That of the peoples and their beliefs, who were in Britannia before the Celts. The Roman’s idea that Britain is a strange, mysterious, dismal, unfriendly island, is communicated very well and Vespasian sees and hears about things that must have had the average Legionary quaking in his sodden sandals before, during and after his time in the gods-forsdaken isle.
It is largely the druids, their power over the local population and the power they claim that is behind them, that fills the first third to a half and which, for me, continues the superb form from 'Rome’s Fallen Eagle.' To be honest, I’m not entirely sure what to make of the passages involving the druids and their summoning of their god(s). As Arthur C Clark pointed out, if your civilisation’s technology can’t explain why something happens as it does, then it is magic. Because I’m reading this now, and know that things don’t happen like they’re being described here, either now or back then, then we’re deep into fantasy territory. That is then taking us away from the reality of the rest of the story and I'm asking, how much of the rest can I believe? I didn’t catch Vespasian or another character coming up with a practical explanation, so I read it as fantasy. Which I then have trouble marrying to the realistic, factual nature of the rest. Problematical. It’s one thing believing tales of people swearing they know of someone who swears they saw this happen, it’s another to describe it happening in front of the otherwise perfectly sane Vespasian.
The battle planning, is where it would seem Vespasian’s strength lies. His tactics, even during the fighting, where they have to be adjusted and changed, are calm, confident, largely faultless, or lucky. Which of course, gives up good reason to believe how he managed to weave his way through the politics back in Rome.
Whilst I would have liked Vespasian to stay in Britain for longer, unfortunately, history says otherwise. So, it is when Vespasian returns to Rome, that moves us into a whole different kind of story. Instead of not being able to believe their eyes, they know they can’t always believe their ears and the words, of their fellow Romans. I will admit to dropping off a couple of times during the early stages of this section. I don’t do Roman politics and too much examining of the ins and outs of this person doing this and that person maybe not doing that, and then that will happen…with names you’re not really sure who they are…However (hoorah!) it all gets pulled around in the second half of the back in Rome section and finishes with mental high-fives, as assorted characters you really didn’t like, get what’s coming.
Vespasian has been, for me, over the last two books at least, something of an innocent at large. He is now old enough to realise he has to take his situation and responsibilities more seriously and being sent to reclaim the Eagle last time out and subdue the druids in this, have clearly opened his eyes more than somewhat. Through the course of this book, he slowly changes, or alters character. Not dramatically, just there’s a hardening of determination, he can see things more clearly - even on the higher plain back in Rome. He becomes more worldly wise and this shows in his actions at the end, where in previous books, you feel he would have been out of his depth.
All in all, a worthy successor to #4 and a nice set up to #6. The Vespasian series has been an absolute and intriguing joy to read, and will continue to be so for many volumes to come.
More world-class reviews on Speesh Reads
Book IV, was incredible. One of my most favouritest books of last year. This one carries on where that left off. In that Vespasian and the Roman Army are still in the process of subduing the Britons. Or the Celts. Mostly, the Druids, who don’t want to see common sense, and who believe they are custodians of an even older legacy. That of the peoples and their beliefs, who were in Britannia before the Celts. The Roman’s idea that Britain is a strange, mysterious, dismal, unfriendly island, is communicated very well and Vespasian sees and hears about things that must have had the average Legionary quaking in his sodden sandals before, during and after his time in the gods-forsdaken isle.
It is largely the druids, their power over the local population and the power they claim that is behind them, that fills the first third to a half and which, for me, continues the superb form from 'Rome’s Fallen Eagle.' To be honest, I’m not entirely sure what to make of the passages involving the druids and their summoning of their god(s). As Arthur C Clark pointed out, if your civilisation’s technology can’t explain why something happens as it does, then it is magic. Because I’m reading this now, and know that things don’t happen like they’re being described here, either now or back then, then we’re deep into fantasy territory. That is then taking us away from the reality of the rest of the story and I'm asking, how much of the rest can I believe? I didn’t catch Vespasian or another character coming up with a practical explanation, so I read it as fantasy. Which I then have trouble marrying to the realistic, factual nature of the rest. Problematical. It’s one thing believing tales of people swearing they know of someone who swears they saw this happen, it’s another to describe it happening in front of the otherwise perfectly sane Vespasian.
The battle planning, is where it would seem Vespasian’s strength lies. His tactics, even during the fighting, where they have to be adjusted and changed, are calm, confident, largely faultless, or lucky. Which of course, gives up good reason to believe how he managed to weave his way through the politics back in Rome.
Whilst I would have liked Vespasian to stay in Britain for longer, unfortunately, history says otherwise. So, it is when Vespasian returns to Rome, that moves us into a whole different kind of story. Instead of not being able to believe their eyes, they know they can’t always believe their ears and the words, of their fellow Romans. I will admit to dropping off a couple of times during the early stages of this section. I don’t do Roman politics and too much examining of the ins and outs of this person doing this and that person maybe not doing that, and then that will happen…with names you’re not really sure who they are…However (hoorah!) it all gets pulled around in the second half of the back in Rome section and finishes with mental high-fives, as assorted characters you really didn’t like, get what’s coming.
Vespasian has been, for me, over the last two books at least, something of an innocent at large. He is now old enough to realise he has to take his situation and responsibilities more seriously and being sent to reclaim the Eagle last time out and subdue the druids in this, have clearly opened his eyes more than somewhat. Through the course of this book, he slowly changes, or alters character. Not dramatically, just there’s a hardening of determination, he can see things more clearly - even on the higher plain back in Rome. He becomes more worldly wise and this shows in his actions at the end, where in previous books, you feel he would have been out of his depth.
All in all, a worthy successor to #4 and a nice set up to #6. The Vespasian series has been an absolute and intriguing joy to read, and will continue to be so for many volumes to come.
More world-class reviews on Speesh Reads
mw2k's review
4.0
More of a 3.75 than a 4.
I'm not as keen on this installment as I was the previous four due to the inclusion of some (unnecessary, to me) supernatural elements. Also, like the book before it, it's a work of two very distinct parts that don't join together at the seams as well as they should.
Apart from that, what more do we know about the life of Vespasian? That he lives in some very interesting and challenging times - at least for someone of his standing. It's a dangerous and precipitous world he lives in, and it's only becoming more so due to the expansionist actions of the Romans.
The ongoing "colonisation" (there's a euphemism for you) of Britannia is painted in the most cynical and questioning of terms, and rightly so. The place was invaded for no other reason than for personal prestige of the Roman Emperor. No other compelling reason. All very telling and ironic considering what the British themselves did 1700-1800 years later.
Anyhow, this is as good as the other four apart from the supernatural stuff.
I'm not as keen on this installment as I was the previous four due to the inclusion of some (unnecessary, to me) supernatural elements. Also, like the book before it, it's a work of two very distinct parts that don't join together at the seams as well as they should.
Apart from that, what more do we know about the life of Vespasian? That he lives in some very interesting and challenging times - at least for someone of his standing. It's a dangerous and precipitous world he lives in, and it's only becoming more so due to the expansionist actions of the Romans.
The ongoing "colonisation" (there's a euphemism for you) of Britannia is painted in the most cynical and questioning of terms, and rightly so. The place was invaded for no other reason than for personal prestige of the Roman Emperor. No other compelling reason. All very telling and ironic considering what the British themselves did 1700-1800 years later.
Anyhow, this is as good as the other four apart from the supernatural stuff.
traveller1's review against another edition
3.0
The continuing story of the future emperor Vespasian. The novel falls into two parts, both set in the latter years of Claudius. First, Vespasian is a legionary commander in Britain, charged with crushing resistance to the Roman occupation. He proves himself to be a competent military commander, who is not afraid of putting himself in danger. His battles lead him into conflict with the Druids of Britain, and a daring rescue of his brother, captured by the same.
The second part of the novel centres around the dangerous world of Roman politics. After completing his military service Vespasian returns to Rome, and finds himself immediately immersed in plots against the emperor's wife, Messalina. After betraying a friend to his death, Vespasian assists with the downfall of Messalina.
I enjoyed the novel, but, maybe I am getting old, the continual military battles, ably told though they were, I found a little wearying. Can't we all just get along? The politics of Rome, again, makes me long for the grand old days of the Republic!
Fabbri has promised at least one more novel in the series. This will see Seneca returned to Rome. Interesting to see how he is dealt with.
The second part of the novel centres around the dangerous world of Roman politics. After completing his military service Vespasian returns to Rome, and finds himself immediately immersed in plots against the emperor's wife, Messalina. After betraying a friend to his death, Vespasian assists with the downfall of Messalina.
I enjoyed the novel, but, maybe I am getting old, the continual military battles, ably told though they were, I found a little wearying. Can't we all just get along? The politics of Rome, again, makes me long for the grand old days of the Republic!
Fabbri has promised at least one more novel in the series. This will see Seneca returned to Rome. Interesting to see how he is dealt with.
More...