Reviews with content warning for Suicidal thoughts - The Paris Library

Oof. Would not have finished were it not our book club pick this month.
Historical fiction but with no authentic sense of place. There were brief moments where the book was good, and the premise was a great story starting point! But overall the execution was trite and unlikable and a waste of a good idea. The worst part was reading the author’s notes at the end, and seeing how much potential this topic had in the hands of a more adept writer or with a better developmental editor that could help create actual character arcs that are satisfying.

My main issues:
- flowery writing stuffed with so many similes and metaphors that you’re often tripping over five in one paragraph. It makes the writing feel so trite and amateur, like reading a middle school age book report.

- I am biased against first person POV generally, but I especially hated that the two leads, Odile and Lily, were written with the same voice and immaturity. They both behaved and thought like a bratty teenager, which made sense for Lily, but Odile was purportedly a college grad and a woman so independently minded that she sought a career when it was unusual to do so. But other than that one act, she is a naïve idiot for the rest of the book. She is constantly cruel and judgmental to her “closest friends,” a thoughtless gossip, and does some truly heinous things throughout the book.

- She has moments of reflection (which oddly are written like they are reflections from the future and she’s telling the story of the past, but then the next line the verbs are present tense again? ) but she doesn’t actually learn from any of her choices until she runs away to Montana and takes no accountability with those she harms.

- “Do as I say, not as I did….” Is not a character arc.

- She claims innocence about the apartment trysts, but even if she had no idea the real reason why the apartments were empty… what possible explanation would have made her behavior ok? There was no excuse regardless of the real explanation?

- The world building lacked an authentic sense of place. Descriptions were glutted with unimportant factual details that didn’t create an emotional response, like an AP Euro history paper stuffed with rote memorizarion in an attempt to earn extra credit from the teacher. Yeah, you did the research — but fact-stuffing like that doesn’t evoke a sense of place and time.

- Overall, the character arcs were so messy and all over the place, so you were left with no one worth rooting for, except Mary Louise and maybe Lily. And Odile wasn’t worth loving to hate either. Just a frustrating trudge through a book that attempts to tell a story about a time of great complexity and conflict, but gives us the POV of a simpleton with no nuance or understanding of the world around her. She bumbles through the story, and the reader does too. She faces no consequences for her actions, and just runs away. It is the most uneventful non-development of a character arc.

- And seriously, I cannot overstate how many cheesy similes and metaphors were packed into this book. It was astonishing. If this hadn’t already been such a disappointing waste of time, I’d go back through and keep a tally.

Overall, deeply “meh” that veered into “ugh” territory regularly.

Content Warnings

eesti23's review

Go to review page

emotional hopeful inspiring reflective medium-paced

Plot- or character-driven? A mix
Strong character development? Yes
Loveable characters? It's complicated
Diverse cast of characters? Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

4.0

"A bookmark—a bright ribbon, really—beckoned from each, inviting the Directress to return."

“Life’s a brawl. You must fight for what you want.”

"I had learned that love was not patient, love was not kind. Love was conditional. The people closest to you could turn their backs on you, saying goodbye for something that seemed like nothing. You could only depend on yourself."

"Yet there was solace: in reading other people’s stories, I knew that I wasn’t alone."

"It was why I read—to glimpse other lives."

“Two feed your stomach, the rest your soul. We’ll find another way to soothe your heart.”

"GRIEF IS A sea made of your own tears. Salty swells cover the dark depths you must swim at your own pace. It takes time to build stamina. Some days, my arms sliced through the water, and I felt things would be okay, the shore wasn’t so far off. Then one memory, one moment would nearly drown me, and I’d be back to the beginning, fighting to stay above the waves, exhausted, sinking in my own sorrow."

"The Library is a bridge of books between cultures.”

"She wished she could make them understand that Paris was home. She’d made her life’s work, her life here."

"You’re nothing without principles. Nowhere without ideals. No one without courage."

"Love is accepting someone, all parts of them, even the ones you don’t like or understand."

"‘Accept people for who they are, not for who you want them to be.’”

Judging by the number of highlighted quotes I had, The Paris Library provided plenty food for thought. This was a really interesting angle on WWII history in France. There were great characters, both in the past and present storylines. I gasped out loud at the

timeline twist at the end where Odile almost ended her life.

An enjoyable read.

This was my pick for The StoryGraph's Onboarding Reading Challenge 2022, prompt three, ...head to your Up Next Suggestions (Home > To-Read Pile > Search and Filter > Suggestions) and read the book from your Random Pick prompt....

Content Warnings

bookishaddictions's review against another edition

Go to review page

challenging dark emotional hopeful informative inspiring reflective sad tense fast-paced

Plot- or character-driven? A mix
Strong character development? Yes
Loveable characters? It's complicated
Diverse cast of characters? No
Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated

4.0

I love good historical fiction novels, especially the ones that are based around true events. While The Paris Library isn’t exactly how the events happened, Charles definitely got the overall basis of it across. I found that the characters each faced so many relatable challenges, as well as scenarios I could never imagine being in myself. Odile and Lily take readers on adventures that show both the best and the worst of humanity. If you enjoyed The Paris Architect, you’ll likely enjoy this one 🇫🇷

I will say, The Paris Library has reminded me that I could never learn the Dewey Decimal System 🤣🤷🏼‍♀️

Content Warnings

kelly_e's review against another edition

Go to review page

emotional informative slow-paced

Plot- or character-driven? A mix
Strong character development? Yes
Loveable characters? Yes
Diverse cast of characters? No
Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

3.5

Title: The Paris Library
Author: Janet Skeslien Charles
Genre: Historical Fiction
Rating: 3.5
Pub Date: February 2, 2021

Thank you to Atria Books for providing an e-ARC via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

T H R E E • W O R D S

Enchanting • Unforgettable • Literary

📖 S Y N O P S I S

Paris, 1939: Odile, seems to have it all; a handsome boyfriend, an English best friend, a beloved twin, and her dream job as a librarian at the American library in Paris. And when war is declared, Odile joins the Resistance with the best weapon she has - books.

Montana 1983: Widowed and alone, Odile is suffering from loneliness. Lily, a lonely teenager, soon takes a keen interest of her recluse, French neighbour. What develops is a unlikely friendship.

A story of love and friendship, of family and sacrifice, of grief and betrayal, of self-discovery and the power of literature.

💭 T H O U G H T S

Based on the true WWII story of the heroic American librarian, Miss Reeder, who created the Soldiers' Service in order to deliver books to servicemen and to Jewish readers after they were banned from entering the library, The Paris Library is a reminder of why I love historical fiction so much. It brought to life a part of history I knew nothing about, and is an ode to the essential nature of books and libraries.

The library atmosphere, the description of books, and the cast of incredible characters really immersed me into the story. The sense of 'found family' among the secondary characters was an additional bonus. It demonstrated how the library staff risked their lives to provide a small piece of normalcy to patrons, all while exploring the consequences of their choices. This novel was well researched, and the dual timeline worked, but I continually was drawn back to Paris and Odile's trials. At times there were parts of Lily's story that felt unnecessary. I also found it odd how there were only a small numbers of chapters from the perspective of secondary characters, to me this detracted from the story and felt inconsistent. And yet it was the ending which felt rushed, that left me feeling disappointed, although I adored the story as a whole.

📚 R E C O M M E N D • T O
• book lovers
• readers of historical fiction (particularly WWII)
• fans of Lilac Girls and/or The Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Pie Society

🔖 F A V O U R I T E • Q U O T E S

"Breathing in the best smell in the world - a mélange of the mossy scent of musty books and crisp newspaper pages - I felt as if I'd come home."

"I wished I could go back to that last moment. I would say, 'You were the best mom in the world. I need you. We need you. I loved the way we watched robins and hoped for hummingbirds. I wished we had one more morning. One more hug. One more change to say I love you."

"Grief is a sea made of your own tears. Salty swells cover the dark depths you must swim at your own pace. It takes time to build stamina. Some days, my arms sliced through the water, and I felt things would be okay, the shore wasn't so far off. Then one memory, one moment would nearly drown me, and I'd be back to the beginning fighting to stay above the waves, exhausted, sinking in my own sorrow."

Content Warnings

house_of_hannah's review against another edition

Go to review page

emotional hopeful informative reflective sad medium-paced

Plot- or character-driven? A mix
Strong character development? Yes
Loveable characters? Yes
Diverse cast of characters? No
Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

4.0

I've been wanting to read this book since I first heard about it, and I am ecstatic that I was able to get a signed copy ! I live in Paris, and I get all my library books from The American Library in Paris, so purchasing this book in a local shop and reading about such familiar places just comforted my soul.

I've known that the ALP has a deep WWII history since I first started going there, and it felt fantastic to learn more. I was pleasantly surprised to find out at the end of the book that most of the characters were real people. I expected the names to be made up, but this was not the case. It really helps to make this book feel even more real.

I have an...interesting relationship with the Historical Fiction genre, as I've disliked most of the books I've read. Going into this one I was a little scared of how I would feel about it, especially after reading the first few chapters, and just feeling "meh" about it. Luckily that quickly changed, and I really enjoyed the main story of Odile.

You can feel the tension and anxiety in the first half of the book as the war begins, and fear of the Germans closing in on the city heightens. The portrayal of people's changing lives, feelings, and thoughts was done quite well. I liked that it was reiterated multiple times that people act rashly, especially under such stressful circumstances, and that no one is perfect.

One thing I could have done without is the multiple timeline/perspectives. I really did not care about Lily in the 1980s timeline, and it didn't feel like it added too much to the story. I though there might be some reveals using her, but there really wasn't. There were also times where I could go 100 pages with only 1 Lily chapter, so it would feel like such an abrupt change, and take me out of the story. There were also several times were we got a chapter from another character's perspective, which most of the time didn't feel needed either. It seemed like the author was trying to give us all of the information, when hearing the story from Odile's perspective was perfectly fine.

I knew going into this that there would be French words peppered throughout, as that always seems to be the case with a book taking place in a non-english speaking country. However, it is done extremely often, and even after living in France for 3 years I had to ask my husband how to pronounce some words and what their definitions were. So if you're going into this with no knowledge of French, prepare to Google some words !

I loved reading all the street names and places that I am familiar with. I felt invested in the story and fell in love with the characters. The ending of Odile's story felt strange and sudden, so the last few chapters of the book were a bit odd for me. As someone who lives in the area and frequents the library this is written about, I definitely think I have a bit of a bias towards liking this book, so those who are not as familiar with the setting might not find as much enjoyment as I did.

Content Warnings

raeannht's review

Go to review page

emotional reflective sad medium-paced

Plot- or character-driven? A mix
Strong character development? Yes
Loveable characters? Yes
Diverse cast of characters? Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

4.0

I usually don't like stories that jump from the past to the modern day, but this one worked for me. It was an enjoyable read with sad, grim moments that left me thinking about friendships and how we treat each other.

Content Warnings

spalmon's review

Go to review page

emotional sad tense medium-paced

Plot- or character-driven? Plot
Strong character development? No
Loveable characters? Yes
Diverse cast of characters? No

3.5

Content Warnings

More...