Scan barcode
leafblade's review against another edition
4.0
This was a long ass introduction to a new trilogy???? series???? duology?????? that I'll DEFINITELY keep reading.
I CAN'T WAIT FOR THE FOUND FAMILY TROPE TO KICK IN
Anyway I loved the setting and the characters and the creatures and the vibes and Lee and the fact that there was a dog WHO DOESN'T DIE. Amazing.
I still think there's LOTS of worldbuilding to do, though. I hope we'll see more in the next book!
I CAN'T WAIT FOR THE FOUND FAMILY TROPE TO KICK IN
Anyway I loved the setting and the characters and the creatures and the vibes and Lee and the fact that there was a dog WHO DOESN'T DIE. Amazing.
I still think there's LOTS of worldbuilding to do, though. I hope we'll see more in the next book!
mllejoyeuxnoel's review against another edition
3.0
Roux's writing is a delightful Victorian throwback. I didn't find this book particularly scary, nor was I very much attached to any of the characters. The Devil... well, he wasn't very devilish. Still, this was beautifully written, and that alone has earned my rating here.
hannahhbic's review against another edition
3.0
Definitely not bad by any means. It just didn't grab my interest enough to finish it.
kaeliwolf's review against another edition
5.0
I'm still kinda confused and I feel like i read this in a fever dream but I really enjoyed it..?
shtarzz's review against another edition
4.0
⭐️4.0
Estuvo muy interesante, al principio me costo un poco pero conforme iba avanzando todo mejoró.
Me gustó el hecho de que algunos capítulos iniciaran con fragmentos sobre las criaturas.
Como soy una romántica, me faltó ese detalle, estoy interesada en la relación de Louisa y Morningside, que, pese a no tener muchas implicaciones que podrían dar a pensar en un futuro romance, no puedo evitar hacer mis teorías. Sobre Lee no sentí mucha química, tal vez sí en un sentido amistoso, pero no en uno romántico, supongo que se debe a que no confié demasiado en él durante el libro.
Espero que en los próximos libros se ahonde más en las habilidades y origen de Louisa, además de que se explique las historias de los otros personajes.
Estuvo muy interesante, al principio me costo un poco pero conforme iba avanzando todo mejoró.
Me gustó el hecho de que algunos capítulos iniciaran con fragmentos sobre las criaturas.
Como soy una romántica, me faltó ese detalle, estoy interesada en la relación de Louisa y Morningside, que, pese a no tener muchas implicaciones que podrían dar a pensar en un futuro romance, no puedo evitar hacer mis teorías. Sobre Lee no sentí mucha química, tal vez sí en un sentido amistoso, pero no en uno romántico, supongo que se debe a que no confié demasiado en él durante el libro.
Espero que en los próximos libros se ahonde más en las habilidades y origen de Louisa, además de que se explique las historias de los otros personajes.
caitybell's review against another edition
3.0
This book was one of the rare times I totally judged a book by its cover. Its gorgeous, and haunting, and dark looking. So, I purchased it. Also, Furies? I love Furies in mythology, so yeah, I didn’t even read the back before I handed over my card.
The quick rundown of the story is as such: Louisa is a runaway, trying to escape her neglected life at a horrid boarding school. While on the streets, performing small fortune tricks to get enough pennies to eat, she is approached by a crone who–through a series of sporadic events–convinces her to come to Coldthistle House. Louisa is given a job, working at the boarding house, but she soon discovers there is something dark and foreboding living in and surrounding Coldthistle, and the house’s owner and workers are enacting their own version of judge-jury-and executioner.
Let me first start by saying the atmosphere that Madeleine Roux writes, and the overall aesthetic of the book (including its gorgeous design) is wonderful. Dark and ominous, Coldthistle is a mystery wrapped in shadows and secrets. But beyond that, I was severely disappointed all around.
Louisa is utterly bland and most of the time annoying in her prudish and bleak ways. Her thought process is lengthily written out, in fact most of the book is just Lousia telling us how she feels. And feels. And feels. So many pages dedicated to her explaining herself (instead of just showing us) that I usually dozed off as I was reading and couldn’t remember what I had just read. Nor did I particularly care enough to go back and re-read parts like that. She constantly contradicts herself, and honestly, if you took her out of the story, everything probably would have happened without her the same way.
Roux cooks up a whimsical and ominous atmosphere, there’s no doubt, but she never goes beyond that–feeling. There are plenty of times where something was building in the story, something dark was coming and then we would reach the pinnacle of the moment aaaannndddd … it would fall short and Roux would back track. This happened again and again and by doing this the whole book gives off the same feeling while reading it the entire time. What I mean to say is, the stakes throughout the book were always just so–never did I feel scared, worried, saddened by anything because Roux held back so much, constantly pulled back, that all scenes felt the same. Whether it was Louisa talking to someone about the weather, or her facing down the deadly creatures that live within the house–there was no emotional change. This book is over 400 pages, and the only time Roux doesn’t pull back from a powerful moment, is the last thirty pages. But by that time so much suddenly explodes it seemed rushed and confusing, cheaply written.
Also, if you are like me and need romance within the story, consider yourself warned. There is zero romance. Friendship and acceptance are the main plot advances here, but even then, its weakly done.
So I have all of these negative opinions on the book, you may be asking why I gave it 3 stars? Well, though the books pace was terrible, the characters surface level and weakly developed, the book itself is well written. If that makes any sense. Madeleine Roux is a talented and clear writer, just for a book that was character driven, it fell short on giving me driven characters.
FOLLOW ME FOR MORE BOOKISH THINGS AND REVIEWS!
tumblr: bah-ram-ewe
instagram: brutal.reads
The quick rundown of the story is as such: Louisa is a runaway, trying to escape her neglected life at a horrid boarding school. While on the streets, performing small fortune tricks to get enough pennies to eat, she is approached by a crone who–through a series of sporadic events–convinces her to come to Coldthistle House. Louisa is given a job, working at the boarding house, but she soon discovers there is something dark and foreboding living in and surrounding Coldthistle, and the house’s owner and workers are enacting their own version of judge-jury-and executioner.
Let me first start by saying the atmosphere that Madeleine Roux writes, and the overall aesthetic of the book (including its gorgeous design) is wonderful. Dark and ominous, Coldthistle is a mystery wrapped in shadows and secrets. But beyond that, I was severely disappointed all around.
Louisa is utterly bland and most of the time annoying in her prudish and bleak ways. Her thought process is lengthily written out, in fact most of the book is just Lousia telling us how she feels. And feels. And feels. So many pages dedicated to her explaining herself (instead of just showing us) that I usually dozed off as I was reading and couldn’t remember what I had just read. Nor did I particularly care enough to go back and re-read parts like that. She constantly contradicts herself, and honestly, if you took her out of the story, everything probably would have happened without her the same way.
Roux cooks up a whimsical and ominous atmosphere, there’s no doubt, but she never goes beyond that–feeling. There are plenty of times where something was building in the story, something dark was coming and then we would reach the pinnacle of the moment aaaannndddd … it would fall short and Roux would back track. This happened again and again and by doing this the whole book gives off the same feeling while reading it the entire time. What I mean to say is, the stakes throughout the book were always just so–never did I feel scared, worried, saddened by anything because Roux held back so much, constantly pulled back, that all scenes felt the same. Whether it was Louisa talking to someone about the weather, or her facing down the deadly creatures that live within the house–there was no emotional change. This book is over 400 pages, and the only time Roux doesn’t pull back from a powerful moment, is the last thirty pages. But by that time so much suddenly explodes it seemed rushed and confusing, cheaply written.
Also, if you are like me and need romance within the story, consider yourself warned. There is zero romance. Friendship and acceptance are the main plot advances here, but even then, its weakly done.
So I have all of these negative opinions on the book, you may be asking why I gave it 3 stars? Well, though the books pace was terrible, the characters surface level and weakly developed, the book itself is well written. If that makes any sense. Madeleine Roux is a talented and clear writer, just for a book that was character driven, it fell short on giving me driven characters.
FOLLOW ME FOR MORE BOOKISH THINGS AND REVIEWS!
tumblr: bah-ram-ewe
instagram: brutal.reads
foxgloveblue's review
dark
mysterious
tense
slow-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.25