Reviews

Based on a True Story: Fact and Fantasy in 100 Favorite Movies by Jonathan Vankin

labunnywtf's review

Go to review page

3.0

Very interesting. And I have a whole bunch of new movies to watch.

neckspike's review

Go to review page

3.0

A few entries were pretty weak (A fantasy movie about King Arthur, really?) but overall it was very interesting.

meags's review

Go to review page

4.0

I really enjoyed this book, not because I'd seen every movie, but because it's interesting to think about the real life stories that we think we know are really changed in the telling. I never really considered that a lot of things in movies based on a true story are full of fiction. Several characters are smushed into one composite, random "inciting incidents" or motivations are given that never really happened, and timelines are completely switched around. Fascinating! The best part about this book for a busy mom of a toddler is that the chapters are only a couple of pages and it was easy to read one or two in between building with Legos and reading books. I definitely recommend for bibliophiles.

eyelit's review

Go to review page

3.0

I would have liked this a lot more had the authors treated the subject in a less judgmental manner. It was sometimes hard to glean fact from the incessantly derisive commentary (the subject pretty much speaks for itself and is interesting enough without the unnecessary commentary that tended to be far too mean-spirited). I was expecting a "here's what really happened" and I got "here's why producers/directors/writers/actors are asshats when it comes to adapting true accounts to film" which, fair enough, is often the case... but still... more fact and less judgment would have made the book more enjoyable to me.
More...