Scan barcode
kcdcwrites's review
5.0
I've never been able to refer to another book as "delicious" before, but this one definitely matches that description. Many books I enjoy just for the story...This one had an intrigueing story, *and* the writing was absolutely fabulous in its visceral descriptions. Highly recommended by the me, and most especially to any and all POTO fans.
hufflepuffbiologybuff's review
5.0
I absolutely loved this rendition of Phantom of the Opera! It gave so much history as to why Erik (the Phantom) was the way he was.
This has to be one of my favorite books!
I think I might read it again soon =)
This has to be one of my favorite books!
I think I might read it again soon =)
klara_hansen's review
dark
mysterious
sad
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.75
Loved this book a lot more when I was younger
ifyouhappentoremember's review
4.0
Susan Kay's Phantom might be one of the most influential piece of work in the Phandom. Personally, I think everyone who loves The Phantom of the Opera should read it.
The main consensus in the Phandom (which I wholeheartedly agree with) is when Susan Kay moves the narrative to Christine Daae's point of view the whole story strays from Leroux narrative and jumps off a cliff. The earlier portions of the book are so incredibly detailed and well researched that I'm half inclined to recommend readers to stop at Christine's section (it's not going to happen because you as the reader pray that the final section blows away the previous section - keep deluding your self because it doesn't happen).
In all, you should read it for the angst.
The main consensus in the Phandom (which I wholeheartedly agree with) is when Susan Kay moves the narrative to Christine Daae's point of view the whole story strays from Leroux narrative and jumps off a cliff. The earlier portions of the book are so incredibly detailed and well researched that I'm half inclined to recommend readers to stop at Christine's section (it's not going to happen because you as the reader pray that the final section blows away the previous section - keep deluding your self because it doesn't happen).
In all, you should read it for the angst.
sarahreffstrup's review
1.0
JEG GIVER OP! Jeg kan simpelthen ikke mere. Den bog er så kedelig og forudsigelig. Jeg ville så gerne kunne lide den, for jeg elsker "Phantom of the Opera" musicalen, men livet er for kort til dårlige bøger, som man siger. Så nu kaster jeg håndklædet i ringen og dropper mit selvbebrejdende guilttrip over ikke at færdiglæse så dyr en bog. Fuck it.
betwixt_the_pages's review
5.0
"The Opera House dwindles in the distance until it seems no bigger than a doll's house in the shadows...a diminutive lost kingdom shrouded by the thick Parisian mist.
Seventeen years, Erik--too long for bitterness, too long for hate. Your genius was not wiped from this earth without trace, and I have brought him here tonight, like a young pilgrim to a shrine, in final payment of a long-outstanding debt.
I, who shared so unwillingly in your tragedy, now find myself, by some ironic twist of fate, left alone to glory in your triumph. This brilliant, loving boy, who calls me father in his innocence, has taught me so many things I might never have grasped about love. I see the world through his eyes now, I glimpse my appointed place in the grand order of things. Like a weary sparrow I can look with fond pride on the giant I have raised as my own. My feathers have grown sparse and shabby in a difficult quest, but I am warmed and comforted by his presence now. I dread the day when I must lose him to the fame and glory that unquestionably await.
His sons will continue the proud Chagny line and I shall take my secret with me to the grave without resentment...almost without regret.
The cuckoo, you see...
The cuckoo is a beautiful bird!"
--
I will never again be able to watch The Phantom of the Opera in the same way. This book--with its lilting, gorgeous prose and the demanding, incessant character growth--brought the Phantom to life for me. Before, I regarded this character as he is portrayed in the movie--a madman, a sad story of a man with a terrible (though mostly mysterious) past. Due to the beautiful, narrowed focus of this book, Susan Kay managed to make me feel something for a villain that I didn't realize I needed before--a love I don't think I've ever felt for another "bad guy" in my life.
This book needs to be read more often, by people who enjoyed The Phantom of the Opera and wish to know more about the ghost himself. This book will make you reconsider everything you thought you knew of this character.....and make you realize you never knew nearly as much as you thought.
I highly recommend reading this!
Seventeen years, Erik--too long for bitterness, too long for hate. Your genius was not wiped from this earth without trace, and I have brought him here tonight, like a young pilgrim to a shrine, in final payment of a long-outstanding debt.
I, who shared so unwillingly in your tragedy, now find myself, by some ironic twist of fate, left alone to glory in your triumph. This brilliant, loving boy, who calls me father in his innocence, has taught me so many things I might never have grasped about love. I see the world through his eyes now, I glimpse my appointed place in the grand order of things. Like a weary sparrow I can look with fond pride on the giant I have raised as my own. My feathers have grown sparse and shabby in a difficult quest, but I am warmed and comforted by his presence now. I dread the day when I must lose him to the fame and glory that unquestionably await.
His sons will continue the proud Chagny line and I shall take my secret with me to the grave without resentment...almost without regret.
The cuckoo, you see...
The cuckoo is a beautiful bird!"
--
I will never again be able to watch The Phantom of the Opera in the same way. This book--with its lilting, gorgeous prose and the demanding, incessant character growth--brought the Phantom to life for me. Before, I regarded this character as he is portrayed in the movie--a madman, a sad story of a man with a terrible (though mostly mysterious) past. Due to the beautiful, narrowed focus of this book, Susan Kay managed to make me feel something for a villain that I didn't realize I needed before--a love I don't think I've ever felt for another "bad guy" in my life.
This book needs to be read more often, by people who enjoyed The Phantom of the Opera and wish to know more about the ghost himself. This book will make you reconsider everything you thought you knew of this character.....and make you realize you never knew nearly as much as you thought.
I highly recommend reading this!
mlcutter's review
5.0
Amazing book for anyone who wants to know the origins of the Phantom of the Opera. A must read!