Reviews

El Zorro: Comienza la leyenda by Isabel Allende

amb3rlina's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Wonderful! The adventures were different and fresher than I expected. I loved the language and the characters. Great read.

jennifermreads's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

The library where I work selected this title for its first Citywide Read, Livermore Reads Together. Allende focuses on Zorro's youth/creation as a legend and it was an intriguing angle. I'm not sure what I was expecting. But this was a book that I appreciated more AFTER I finished it and had slept on it for a few days.

All-in-all: A must for Zorro fans.

whatyouegg's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

First I will say that I loved this book for the things that Allende always does so well - adventure, rich and meticulous plotlines, creative incorporations of history, alluring characters. However I felt that the character development was a bit lacking and I wish that the narrator's character had a larger role. That being said, it was overall a really exciting and immersive read.

hey_evelina's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous lighthearted slow-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? A mix
  • Strong character development? No
  • Loveable characters? Yes
  • Diverse cast of characters? Yes
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

2.0

idicalini's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Unexpectedly enjoyed this book quite a lot. I know absolutely nothing about Zorro, but I enjoyed reading about his origin story. The wide scenery (from California to Panama to Spain and back) was described quite evocatively (although, at times, a bit weirdly, such as when they are in A Coruña and then decide to go to Santiago de Compostela, which, considering the topography, they would have already passed on the way to A Coruña...). The characters are sometimes a bit one-dimensional and lack depth, but at the same time I really loved the way they were written, which made up for it. Zorro (or Diego) is of course a bit of a larger-than-life character, but reading about his growing up mitigated that effect somewhat. I think this is the first Isabel Allende book I've read, but I'm ready for more now!

lobo1tomia's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

Eredetileg: http://olvasonaplo.net/olvasonaplo/2008/05/22/isabel_allende_zorro/

Annak idején a [b:Kísértetház|15804991|Kísértetház|Isabel Allende|https://d.gr-assets.com/books/1430380359s/15804991.jpg|3374404] nagyon belopta magát a szívembe, valahogy mégse olvastam több könyvet Isabel Allendétől, pedig már akkor is megállapítottam, hogy Dél Amerikában biztos van valami a levegőben amiből lélegezve olyan nagyszerű mesélők cseperednek fel, mint Garcia Marquez meg ő például. De most valahogy kedvem támadt megnézni, mi változott azóta az írónőnél. S szerencsére, bár mondhatni kommersz a téma, a stílus és a mesélőkedv, az atmoszférateremtés, a történelmi környezet hiteles ábrázolása semmit se.
Persze mindenki hallott Zorróról, látott 1001 tévéfilmet, de ha mást nem sátoros ünnepeken és sorozatszegény nyarakon valamelyik kereskedelmi adón tuti belefut az álarcos Banderasba meg a tüzes tekintetű Catherine Zeta Jonesba. Csakhogy Allende Zorrója pont nem ezek a történetek, hanem a hős ifjú koráról szól. Arról, hogyan lett belőle az, akinek legendájával megismerkedett a világ. Diego De la Vega egy kaliforniai nemes és egy félig indián lány szerelméből, házasságából születik. Rögtön ott van vele indián tejtestvére, Bernardo akivel szinte két test, egy lélek a két fiú, s mindenen osztoznak, közösek a csínyeik, az elképzeléseik, a vágyaik, még ha hatalmas társadalmi szakadék is van közöttük. Ami addig igazából nem is annyira kényelmetlen, meg feltűnő, amíg gyerekként tiniként együtt lógnak a félig még indiánok lakta, bár már erősen visszaszorulóban lévő Kaliforniában. Aztán Diegot apja Barcelonába küldi tanulni, s engedi, hogy magával vigye Bernardot, mint a szolgáját. A napoleoni időkben Spanyolország elég érdekes hely volt. A feudalista magatartásból hirtelen felvilágosodott nézetek közé került nemzetet megosztva találják a fiúk. Barcelonában nő fel tehát Zorrová Diego de la Vega, ismerkedik meg az első nagy szerelemmel, sőt örök ellenfelével is, találkozik cigányokkal, titkos társaság tagja lesz, sok tudást szed össze nem csak elméletben, de gyakorlatban is, hogy miután kalandos úton visszatér otthonába már készen álljon arra, hogy álarcban az igazságért harcoljon és kiálljon a szegények mellett. A regény pedig nagyon jó érzékkel itt ér véget, hisz a többi már legenda…
Igazán jó kis történelmi kalandregény ez a XIX. Század elejéről, egy kiváló mester tollából, aki könnyedén vázolja fel a korszakot és a sok szereplőt, s végig izgalomba tart, s aztán az olvasóra bízza, hogy folytatásként melyik Zorro történetet képzeli az utolsó oldalak után.

swirls's review against another edition

Go to review page

2.0

Very disappointing.

buffyb's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

It was fun, the writing was excellent and it made me want to read it without putting it down. I find much less to criticise about a book when that's the case. Some people seemed to have a problem with the fact that it was narrated by someone who is only revealed at the end and felt that it kept them distanced from the story and, most importantly, the action. I felt that it made it more personal. To each her own, I suppose. I thoroughly enjoyed it.

borna761's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

I have been fascinated by the story of Zorro ever since watching the TV series in the early 90s, so when the opportunity came to read a book about him, I did not hesitate to pick it up.

While it is always fun and exciting to read the stories of heroes and how they came to be, Diego de la Vega's striving for justice does not come out as too heroic or over the top. We get to follow his struggles as he grows up, caught between two parents and cultures, not knowing where he really belongs. As he travels to Spain to continue his education, while always proficient in his undertakings, he also has his occasional shortcomings. However, his desire for justice is always his guide.

The narrative is well-written and captivating, and leads you along the way through his life without ever feeling boring. Knowing that at some point he will return and take on the double life of Diego and Zorro, it is still an interesting and compelling read, wanting to know how he gets there and what happens along the way. Recommended!

pennymine's review against another edition

Go to review page

2.0

I'm not sure if I get to rate this book or not, since I have decided to not finish it. I'm bored. There are so many other books out there that I could find interesting that I'm not willing to put in the time it would take to slog the rest of the way through it. I'm a little over 1/2 way through and I tried...I really did. But this book just does not cut it for me.

And by the by, I don't like that Zorro always gets it right. He never makes mistakes or goes overboard. Everything works out perfectly for him and everyone likes him. This is an overstatement, I know. But I found him difficult to relate to as a character-he was just a flat hero.