Scan barcode
mjfmjfmjf's review against another edition
4.0
This story kind of came out of left field. And it went off the rails before the end. But I really liked it. I liked the writing and the art and tone. This book captured Luke for me quite well. But it took him out of New York and away from his cast of characters. Probably could have used a phone or text from Danny or Jessica. Not sure that Marvel needs another super-soldier conspiracy plot but this book was good enough to make up for it.
quirkycatsfatstacks's review against another edition
3.0
After the success that Jessica Jones comic has been having, it’s really no surprise that they decided to reboot Luke Cage’s storyline (and side note: Defenders is also on the way, so be excited!). Thankfully a few cues have been taken from the show, as far as style is concerned. So while there is still the iconic yellow shirt (which they even comment on!) most of the costume has been pretty modernized (and it looks fantastic).
I would just like to say this upfront; while fans of the Luke Cage Netflix show would probably enjoy this series, it is not the same continuity, so don’t expect everything to tie together with a neat little bow on top.
I was really looking forward to this series (I figured if it was even half as good as its counterpart – Jessica Jones – then I was going to love it), which I think resulted in me being just a bit disappointed by this story. There were times were I found myself confused about what was going on, and while I admit maybe I missed something, I’m not entirely sure what, and man do I hate that feeling.
Perhaps it’s because I haven’t read all of the classic Luke Cage comics (though I have read most, as well as most of his appearances with the Avengers), but I had a lot of trouble with all of the sudden character introductions. I’m not good at names to begin with (seriously – half the time I can’t recall the characters from my favorite series, even though I adore them), so the sudden onrush of ten or so named characters with minimal context throws me through a loop.
I think Luke Cage suffered from what a lot of series go through when they first start up. It’s hard to get any plot/character established, and I imagine that’s even more frustrating for the authors when it’s an established character in the world and they have long term ideas for him that they just want to get to. We’ve all seen that happen (Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood for example). So while the series isn’t bad it does try and go too far and too fast, resulting in character development and world building taking a backseat.
I think this series does have potential (though perhaps that’s my bias talking) and with enough time it could even out and become something truly amazing. The only way to find out (in my mind) is to stick with it and see where it leads. In the meantime I’m happy to say the next volume of Jessica Jones is out soon, as is the Defenders. Perhaps they’ll help explain and explore Luke Cage’s world a bit.
For more reviews, check out Quirky Cat's Fat Stacks
I would just like to say this upfront; while fans of the Luke Cage Netflix show would probably enjoy this series, it is not the same continuity, so don’t expect everything to tie together with a neat little bow on top.
I was really looking forward to this series (I figured if it was even half as good as its counterpart – Jessica Jones – then I was going to love it), which I think resulted in me being just a bit disappointed by this story. There were times were I found myself confused about what was going on, and while I admit maybe I missed something, I’m not entirely sure what, and man do I hate that feeling.
Perhaps it’s because I haven’t read all of the classic Luke Cage comics (though I have read most, as well as most of his appearances with the Avengers), but I had a lot of trouble with all of the sudden character introductions. I’m not good at names to begin with (seriously – half the time I can’t recall the characters from my favorite series, even though I adore them), so the sudden onrush of ten or so named characters with minimal context throws me through a loop.
I think Luke Cage suffered from what a lot of series go through when they first start up. It’s hard to get any plot/character established, and I imagine that’s even more frustrating for the authors when it’s an established character in the world and they have long term ideas for him that they just want to get to. We’ve all seen that happen (Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood for example). So while the series isn’t bad it does try and go too far and too fast, resulting in character development and world building taking a backseat.
I think this series does have potential (though perhaps that’s my bias talking) and with enough time it could even out and become something truly amazing. The only way to find out (in my mind) is to stick with it and see where it leads. In the meantime I’m happy to say the next volume of Jessica Jones is out soon, as is the Defenders. Perhaps they’ll help explain and explore Luke Cage’s world a bit.
For more reviews, check out Quirky Cat's Fat Stacks
noveladdiction's review against another edition
4.0
3.5 stars.
Pretty good. Definitely interested enough to continue.
Pretty good. Definitely interested enough to continue.
captwinghead's review against another edition
3.0
I wasn’t as engaged in this volume as I wanted to be, which was a bummer. I love the way Walker writes Luke; that hasn’t changed. It was the plot that just didn’t interest me as much as I’d hoped it would.
I was intrigued by the concept of Luke working with his “brothers”. It appealed to me a bit like X-23 working with the other clones. I thought it would be interesting to have Luke try to help them find their way the way he did and sort of be a really big brother to them all. Instead, this was more about trying to stop the rich bad guy from trying to market/sell Burstien’s formula. It’s a plot I personally have seen too many times for it to keep my interest.
But, the art was great and I always enjoy Luke. So, 3 stars.
I was intrigued by the concept of Luke working with his “brothers”. It appealed to me a bit like X-23 working with the other clones. I thought it would be interesting to have Luke try to help them find their way the way he did and sort of be a really big brother to them all. Instead, this was more about trying to stop the rich bad guy from trying to market/sell Burstien’s formula. It’s a plot I personally have seen too many times for it to keep my interest.
But, the art was great and I always enjoy Luke. So, 3 stars.
voidboi's review against another edition
3.0
An interesting start to a series. The art is simple but dramatic, and Luke is written very well- his internal narrative is captivating, and the dialogue is pretty funny at times.
However, the cast of characters is HUGE- and it's hard to keep straight all the names and faces, who's alive and who isn't. There's only time in these first 5 issues for a couple characters to stand out from the crowd. This kind of complexity doesn't have to be bad, but I don't think this series pulled it off all the way. Not yet at least.
I also continue to be frustrated by the "this thing makes people crazy and violent" trope, which is incredibly reductive and also boring for characterization.
However, the cast of characters is HUGE- and it's hard to keep straight all the names and faces, who's alive and who isn't. There's only time in these first 5 issues for a couple characters to stand out from the crowd. This kind of complexity doesn't have to be bad, but I don't think this series pulled it off all the way. Not yet at least.
I also continue to be frustrated by the "this thing makes people crazy and violent" trope, which is incredibly reductive and also boring for characterization.
More...