Reviews

There is a scene in an Unsolved Mysteries episode on near death experiences that I believe inspired The Midnight Library. It’s an episode worth watching and a book worth reading.

candycandisco's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

THIIIIIS! Ughhh!!! All the emotions with this one .. I noticed people either love or hate this book. And I loved it… every single word. I felt it was something that I needed to read, Matt’s writing is beautiful and it did hit close to home a few times.This is a book that I will remember for a long time ❤️

marinabkat's review against another edition

Go to review page

dark emotional reflective

3.75

chaptersofnina's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

Wow. This book brought me a new perspective and appreciation for life. It found me at the perfect time. I’ve owned it for 2 years and picked it up on a whim a couple days ago off my shelf to give it a go. I’m so glad I did. I see a lot of myself in Nora, and I could relate to her emotions and outlook on life, as well as death. I loved the vast differences of worlds and alternate lives she floated through- it truly felt like I was experiencing it alongside her. The writing was beautiful and Matt Haig truly outdid himself with this one.

wouterk's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Between life and death you may find yourself in a library, with an infinite amount of possible lives you can sample. What if you've done things differently? You can crawl in your own skin, in another life. That is the premise that Haig gives us in this book, literally on the first page before the story begins.

I really flew through this book. It is well-written, fast-paced and thought-provoking. But it also invited me to reflect on regrets I might have, my view on the purpose of life and (mild spoilers but also trigger warning)

Spoiler

suicide

. I think it is a great book if you're in a good place. If you're not in a good place in your life I feel it might go two ways. On the one hand, it may really help reflect and get a more positive outlook on life. On the other hand, as many of the thoughts in this book can be dark, it may also hit quite hard.

What I really admire is that even though the book can make you think about all these things, it is by no means hard or heavy to read. Haig very intricately develops the concept of this sampling of lives and how different choices have different consequences for our own lives but also that of others. He works from a very powerful premise that knowing is not sufficient to experience and living a life is key. Each life becomes a puzzle to find out what has transpired and how our main character, Nora, got to this point. How did it affect her, how did it affect the people she knew in her root life?

I do have one minor gripe with the execution of the concept, which did not take from my enjoyment though. While Haig posits that you need to live a life to know that it fits you, Nora enters each life with her own memories of her root life and the library. To me that makes it impossible to actually live that life as you are not aware of the memories and experiences of the Nora up till the point where you entered the life you're currently visiting.

Another thing I really loved about the book was how it fleshed out all the characters, even in different lives, in so few pages. Nora's family, friends and acquaintances in each life, feel very recognizable and alive, even though they receive limited 'screen time'.

Finally, it is clear that Haig did not create this story lightly and did some research in thoughts about existence, life and its meaning. As Nora in her root life is a philosophy nut, we are frequently given quotes or explanations of different philosophers' takes. Also, special appreciation to the references to different great classical pieces and pop songs.

All in all, trying to summarize in one sentence, I'd say this is a more complex and less moral version of 'A christmas Carol' and definitely worth the read!

eletoo's review against another edition

Go to review page

Too depressing, I’m probably not in the right mindset to finish listening to it

jenmat1197's review against another edition

Go to review page

emotional hopeful inspiring sad medium-paced

Plot- or character-driven? Character
Strong character development? Yes
Loveable characters? It's complicated
Diverse cast of characters? No
Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

4.5

This is the story of Nora Seeds. Nora's parents are dead, she isn't on speaking terms with her brother, she has lost her job, and has just been feeling very down. She decides that no one would miss her if she dies. She takes a lot of pills and ends up in a library with a favorite librarian from her past who shows her different life paths Nora could have taken that would have changed her life in various ways. Even when Nora finds the life that she thinks should be hers, she still feels like an outsider who doesn't quite belong.

This was a good book. I thought it was well written and the story flowed well. Following Nora through various lifetimes where things changed for her (parents alive, brother heavily involved in her life, children/no children) was interesting. The story's take was not life after death, but life after life - to see what could be possible if you made different choices as a person. The only thing I would have liked to see if a bit stronger of an ending. It was a bit anticlimatic.

More...