Scan barcode
celandine's review
2.0
This book is the second in the trilogy. While I was unable to put the first one down from pure enjoyment and thrill, this one was very rough to get through. The plot was plodding, and the characters became more grating the longer I read.
This book practically beat me severely about the head and face with complete and utter boredom.
Pages were devoted to the perfection of the character, Miriel, that after a while became superfluous. Characters that were interesting in Shadowborn became flat and uninteresting in Shadowforged.
All in all, a complete disappointment. I barely got out alive.
This book practically beat me severely about the head and face with complete and utter boredom.
Pages were devoted to the perfection of the character, Miriel, that after a while became superfluous. Characters that were interesting in Shadowborn became flat and uninteresting in Shadowforged.
All in all, a complete disappointment. I barely got out alive.
kaylakaotik's review against another edition
5.0
I’ve never been a big fan of the medieval genre before. No matter how much fantasy you throw in, Kings and Queens and the Court haven’t ever done it for me. So, when Moira contacted me about reviewing Shadowborn, I was pretty torn. Yes, the book has pretty good reviews… but would it be interesting enough to keep my attention?
Shadowborn moves a slow and steady pace. One thing I saw mentioned in a few reviews is that there isn’t a whole lot of action (danger, threat against Miriel) going on. Most people have counted this against the book. However, it felt right to me. I feel like Shadowborn was laying the ground work for the trilogy and it did so wonderfully. While there wasn’t a lot of action, there was a lot happening.
Moira’s writing is fantastic. I love that Shadowborn is done in first person. I think it added extra mystery to the story since we’re only able to see things as Catwin sees them. The characters are masterfully done. All of the characters had their own personality and depth. I loved watching Catwin and Miriel evolve through the story. I cannot wait to see how the story continues.
Shadowborn moves a slow and steady pace. One thing I saw mentioned in a few reviews is that there isn’t a whole lot of action (danger, threat against Miriel) going on. Most people have counted this against the book. However, it felt right to me. I feel like Shadowborn was laying the ground work for the trilogy and it did so wonderfully. While there wasn’t a lot of action, there was a lot happening.
Moira’s writing is fantastic. I love that Shadowborn is done in first person. I think it added extra mystery to the story since we’re only able to see things as Catwin sees them. The characters are masterfully done. All of the characters had their own personality and depth. I loved watching Catwin and Miriel evolve through the story. I cannot wait to see how the story continues.
kaylakaotik's review
5.0
What a great second book!
I’ve completely fallen in love with the characters in this trilogy. Catwin and Miriel are absolutely wonderful female characters. While they are certainly my favorite, I also rather enjoyed Garad, Wilhelm, and Temar. All of the characters have such a realness and depth that I can’t get enough of.
The writing is on par with the previous book (which is great in case you didn’t know). As the story progresses, it’s evident that Moira is a skilled author.
I cannot wait to read the third and final book in the trilogy.
I’ve completely fallen in love with the characters in this trilogy. Catwin and Miriel are absolutely wonderful female characters. While they are certainly my favorite, I also rather enjoyed Garad, Wilhelm, and Temar. All of the characters have such a realness and depth that I can’t get enough of.
The writing is on par with the previous book (which is great in case you didn’t know). As the story progresses, it’s evident that Moira is a skilled author.
I cannot wait to read the third and final book in the trilogy.
casseyt's review against another edition
2.0
This was not for me. I should have made it a DNF, but the idea intrigued me.
stitchsds's review against another edition
4.0
I downloaded this ebook when it was offered for free from Amazon, thinking it was worth a chance reading, and I was right. This first book in a series is surprisingly well-written and an interesting story. I currently have it classified as fantasy, but it isn't really a fantasy story. However, neither is it modern, urban-fantasy, or sci-fi.
lennert_h's review against another edition
slow-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? No
- Diverse cast of characters? N/A
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
2.0
rosegoldteacher's review against another edition
3.0
This book was only rising action, like a set up for the sequel.
aforestofbooks's review against another edition
4.0
Review is coming.
So I meant to write a review after letting the story rest for a day or two in my head, but I ended up reading the rest of the trilogy.
At this point I don't think I have the emotional capacity to write anything. All I can say is that people need to read this book! Like now!
This plot, the characters, the drama, the intrigue, the love and betrayal, the desire and pain all combine together to give you a masterpiece.
This series wasn't perfect. There were quite a few spelling and grammar errors (which I've heard have been fixed since), but for those of you who read this review, I want you to look past that and read the trilogy anyway. It has changed my life in a way I can't describe in words (this may also be because I just finished reading the last book an hour ago and my emotions haven't settled yet). Whether or not you think this book will be life changing, take a gamble and try it anyway. You'll be surprised to read something so different from any other young adult fantasy book.
Please. Read.
Overall rating of trilogy: 4.5/5 stars
So I meant to write a review after letting the story rest for a day or two in my head, but I ended up reading the rest of the trilogy.
At this point I don't think I have the emotional capacity to write anything. All I can say is that people need to read this book! Like now!
This plot, the characters, the drama, the intrigue, the love and betrayal, the desire and pain all combine together to give you a masterpiece.
This series wasn't perfect. There were quite a few spelling and grammar errors (which I've heard have been fixed since), but for those of you who read this review, I want you to look past that and read the trilogy anyway. It has changed my life in a way I can't describe in words (this may also be because I just finished reading the last book an hour ago and my emotions haven't settled yet). Whether or not you think this book will be life changing, take a gamble and try it anyway. You'll be surprised to read something so different from any other young adult fantasy book.
Please. Read.
Overall rating of trilogy: 4.5/5 stars