Scan barcode
bookish_slagathor's review against another edition
adventurous
funny
lighthearted
slow-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
3.5
Did you ever want to read the origin story of all those grand, old, wise wizards? Well, now is your chance!
This book was clearly meant as a love letter to LotR, no doubt about that. While I feel it wasn’t exactly perfect, it is clear the author was very passionate about bringing the story to life.
Where the book shines is the writing and the history surrounding the world. Sterling clearly thought a lot about the lore and put a lot of effort into world building.
Still, I felt the author wasn’t quite sure what tone he wanted to hit. Most of the book is lighthearted, sort of YA/middle grade style and highly devoid of any serious, life-threatening perils. Don’t get me wrong, our characters do get attacked, but until the very end they easily escape any danger, which makes it feel like a very low-stakes adventure.
Problem is, since this IS in essence supposed to be an adventure, the lack of real danger makes it feel more like a walking simulator. I will not lie, I felt like falling asleep for 60-70% of the book and the only thing keeping me going was the beautiful landscape and sheer curiosity. Sure, we do get some blood, death and whatnot by the end, but that was a bit too little too late.
Also there was a romance subplot that just felt so bland, I wasn’t even sure why it was needed in the first place. I could have lived another joyful day without it for sure. Oh and let’s not forget the one dimensional villains that to me felt more comical than threatening.
Still, I noticed that ever so sneakily I grew attached to this motley and lovable group of characters (that also lacked a certain depth, but not as badly as the villains) and the last few chapters intrigued me enough that I will probably continue with the series.
Content Warnings
Moderate: Confinement, Murder, Death, and Violence
Minor: Vomit and Slavery
More...