Take a photo of a barcode or cover
cassowary_and_sachertorte's review
emotional
hopeful
reflective
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
3.0
starness's review against another edition
4.0
I knew from reading the blurb this would be a book for me and I’m happy to say it delivered and I got more from this book than I expected. I felt a particular connection. The main reason Tasmania being the central setting. Having visiting the Apple Isle back in 2016 I fell in love and developed a deep connection to the area. For this reason I felt at home and immediately felt a fondness for this book. The layers of our past, the known and unknown parts that shape who we are.
The writing is tender with a soft tone. It goes to show that keeping secrets can cause long lasting ripple effects. The book also delves into the plight of refugees, those asylum seekers who become embittered with the process and which brings a whole new set of problems to society that also have long ripple effects. The book tries to show another side, a human side to an issue we are only too aware of but haven’t necessarily been personally affected by, it opened my eyes in a whole new light which is something I really appreciated with this book. Although I did notice feeling that the author was holding back, a sense of reservation that she was treading carefully around this politically charged hotbed of a topic giving the reader a chance to weigh up both sides of the equation, it’s clear her personal opinions show through her writing and I’m ok with that as I agree with the moral and the heart of the story wholeheartedly. I didn’t feel it was preachy but eye opening and delivered gently within this lovely story of family and friendship. The need for understanding, inclusion and acceptance is a better way forward than the cruel alternative.
Thanks to NetGalley and Simon & Schuster (Australia) for my early review copy. Pub date 01 Oct 2018.
The writing is tender with a soft tone. It goes to show that keeping secrets can cause long lasting ripple effects. The book also delves into the plight of refugees, those asylum seekers who become embittered with the process and which brings a whole new set of problems to society that also have long ripple effects. The book tries to show another side, a human side to an issue we are only too aware of but haven’t necessarily been personally affected by, it opened my eyes in a whole new light which is something I really appreciated with this book. Although I did notice feeling that the author was holding back, a sense of reservation that she was treading carefully around this politically charged hotbed of a topic giving the reader a chance to weigh up both sides of the equation, it’s clear her personal opinions show through her writing and I’m ok with that as I agree with the moral and the heart of the story wholeheartedly. I didn’t feel it was preachy but eye opening and delivered gently within this lovely story of family and friendship. The need for understanding, inclusion and acceptance is a better way forward than the cruel alternative.
Thanks to NetGalley and Simon & Schuster (Australia) for my early review copy. Pub date 01 Oct 2018.
jennifer_c_s's review
4.0
‘My grandmother’s life story comes to me in staccato flashes, for she refused to tell me many of the details, perhaps even the most important ones.’
Sara Rose has recently separated from her husband in Brisbane. Sarah’s grandmother, Nina Barsova, has recently died and left her cottage to Sarah. Sarah decides to return to Hobart with her daughter Ellie. She needs space in which to think about the future, and where better than the cottage in which she was raised by her grandmother at the foot of Mount Wellington. But returning to Hobart raises other issues for Sara. She is estranged from her mother, who has refused to tell her who her father was. And while Nina raised Sara lovingly, she has never known why Helena abandoned her. Sara is a geneticist: these gaps in her self-knowledge matter, and she would like some answers. This is even more important now: she may be separated from her husband, but she wants her daughter to know him.
As Sara settles into life in Hobart, she meets a number of men who have travelled to Australia by boat seeking refuge and who are waiting to have their status as refugees determined. One of those men, Abdhul, is an Afghani whose wife and children are in Pakistan. Sara befriends Abdhul and tries to help him. Sara’s friendship with Abdhul leads her to take tentative steps towards establishing a relationship with her mother. But there are family secrets to be uncovered as well.
For me, the major themes of this novel are identity, belonging and the impact of family secrets. Sara wants to find out who her father is and why her mother abandoned her. Abdhul wants a place of safety, and to be reunited with his family. Sara’s past contains secrets, some of which will be painful. And what can I say about the plight of those, such as Abdhul, who seek refuge in this country? I enjoyed this novel because of the setting, and because Ms Johnson raises some important albeit uncomfortable issues. Those issues for me include: just how important is the past in shaping the future? How do our perceptions of those around us guide our responses to their needs? How easy is it to erect the ‘us’ and ‘them’ barriers?
Note: My thanks to NetGalley and Simon & Schuster (Australia) for providing me with a free electronic copy of this book for review purposes.
Jennifer Cameron-Smith
Sara Rose has recently separated from her husband in Brisbane. Sarah’s grandmother, Nina Barsova, has recently died and left her cottage to Sarah. Sarah decides to return to Hobart with her daughter Ellie. She needs space in which to think about the future, and where better than the cottage in which she was raised by her grandmother at the foot of Mount Wellington. But returning to Hobart raises other issues for Sara. She is estranged from her mother, who has refused to tell her who her father was. And while Nina raised Sara lovingly, she has never known why Helena abandoned her. Sara is a geneticist: these gaps in her self-knowledge matter, and she would like some answers. This is even more important now: she may be separated from her husband, but she wants her daughter to know him.
As Sara settles into life in Hobart, she meets a number of men who have travelled to Australia by boat seeking refuge and who are waiting to have their status as refugees determined. One of those men, Abdhul, is an Afghani whose wife and children are in Pakistan. Sara befriends Abdhul and tries to help him. Sara’s friendship with Abdhul leads her to take tentative steps towards establishing a relationship with her mother. But there are family secrets to be uncovered as well.
For me, the major themes of this novel are identity, belonging and the impact of family secrets. Sara wants to find out who her father is and why her mother abandoned her. Abdhul wants a place of safety, and to be reunited with his family. Sara’s past contains secrets, some of which will be painful. And what can I say about the plight of those, such as Abdhul, who seek refuge in this country? I enjoyed this novel because of the setting, and because Ms Johnson raises some important albeit uncomfortable issues. Those issues for me include: just how important is the past in shaping the future? How do our perceptions of those around us guide our responses to their needs? How easy is it to erect the ‘us’ and ‘them’ barriers?
Note: My thanks to NetGalley and Simon & Schuster (Australia) for providing me with a free electronic copy of this book for review purposes.
Jennifer Cameron-Smith