Scan barcode
Reviews
But What If We're Wrong? Thinking About the Present As If It Were the Past by Chuck Klosterman
geoffdgeorge's review against another edition
Read this in intervals between novels. I like Klosterman. We might not always look at things using the same pop-cultural touchstones, but his patterns of thought resemble my own.
I also like the concept for this book. I think more people should think more often about the ways in which they (and we all) might be wrong. Doubt is a good thing! A healthy thing. And I feel like things wouldn't be half as bad as they are if so many people weren't walking around with blind certainty all the time and spewing that blind certainty out onto the internet for the rest of us to encounter—like finely misted spittle.
Point is, the book is likely to be a quick, enjoyable read for anybody who sits down and dedicates themselves to the task. Pick it up if you're interested in entertaining some of the ways that people hundreds or thousands of years from now might look back on us and see us as misguided, uninformed, or completely absurd.
I also like the concept for this book. I think more people should think more often about the ways in which they (and we all) might be wrong. Doubt is a good thing! A healthy thing. And I feel like things wouldn't be half as bad as they are if so many people weren't walking around with blind certainty all the time and spewing that blind certainty out onto the internet for the rest of us to encounter—like finely misted spittle.
Point is, the book is likely to be a quick, enjoyable read for anybody who sits down and dedicates themselves to the task. Pick it up if you're interested in entertaining some of the ways that people hundreds or thousands of years from now might look back on us and see us as misguided, uninformed, or completely absurd.
maticorde94's review against another edition
3.0
Interesting read
Not a bad book. Sometimes it got a bit repetitive and tiring. But it stated an idea that I always think about about the development of society.
Not a bad book. Sometimes it got a bit repetitive and tiring. But it stated an idea that I always think about about the development of society.
tiarala's review against another edition
3.0
I enjoyed this one. Klosterman is at his best when he's talking pop culture, and this book is worth the read if only for the discussions on music and TV. He lost me occasionally during his more philosophical deep dives, wielding circular language that was more confusing than thought-provoking (and, possibly, a bit over both his head and mine).
The choice of a British woman reader for the audiobook was an odd one, but in his own way I'm sure it was deliberate. She was lovely, but through her voice we sort of lose the author's, and I think that's a shame.
The choice of a British woman reader for the audiobook was an odd one, but in his own way I'm sure it was deliberate. She was lovely, but through her voice we sort of lose the author's, and I think that's a shame.
leahxcx's review against another edition
3.0
This book is and felt pre-Trump. I found the footnotes patronizing. Regardless, very approachable non-fiction read (for me)! I do really like his takes - he’s quite charming and dorky. I really enjoy reading other people’s perspectives on culture.
mitchellvolk's review against another edition
challenging
funny
medium-paced
3.75
A wide-ranging exploration of what “the present” might look like when it becomes “the past.” I was predisposed to like this book because I’m frequently asking myself this question and I like the way Klosterman thinks and writes. Fascinating, thought-provoking and a necessary exercise.