Scan barcode
rebekahrahrah's review
2.0
A good premise, a promising start... But lack of characterisation made it hard to connect properly with the characters, and hard to feel anything more for them than wanting to reach the end of their story arc for me to be able to move onto the next book in my pile
tildahlia's review
2.0
I wanted to like this book, but found myself cringing at the writing, which felt amateurish and clunky. The characters felt a bit cliched and underdeveloped and the quality of the writing wasn't enough to carry a book essentially about ordinary people doing pretty ordinary things, which made it a bit of a snoozefest. I've heard she is a great short story writer (so I'll give Australia Day ago) - perhaps her talents didn't translate effectively into a novel format.
rnmcfarlane's review against another edition
emotional
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.0
samstillreading's review
5.0
I have been dithering about, tweaking computer settings and looking at fuel prices, instead of writing this review. Why? Because Room for a Stranger is so good that my review won’t do it justice. The cheat’s way out would be to say, “Stop reading this review and start reading this book – now”. But a potential reader might not listen to that, so let me try to convince you.
The main characters in Room for a Stranger are an elderly lady, a university student from Hong Kong, their friends and an African grey parrot. The parrot is not only a lovely distraction with his spookily relevant English but an important part of the plot. These disparate characters create a story that is about loneliness and isolation, but also about unlikely friendships. Meg has been living at home alone since the death of her sister, but an encounter with an intruder leaves her feeling vulnerable and scared. She signs up for a home share program to let out a room to a university student. That student is Andy, who is from Hong Kong, studying biomedicine in the hope of getting into medicine. Andy’s not doing too well at university and he has worries about his parents and their situation. Meg is worried too about her health, her friends and meeting Andy’s expectations. What starts as an awkward home scenario where two strangers tiptoe around each other gradually develops into the kind of bond where they can discuss their deepest fears that they can’t reveal to those closest to them.
The story is wonderfully suburban and rather Melbournian in its descriptions of possums and trams. It’s not a ‘big’ story – when I say big, I mean that it doesn’t encompass huge travels, land or generations – but works to capture a short period of time in two everyday lives. Some may say that Meg and Andy’s problems are relatively small but they are huge to them. Fear of death, illness, failure and disappointing others. Meg is worried about not keeping up with her glamourous friends (and I thought female competitiveness might get better with age!) and she’s worried about starting a new relationship. Andy doesn’t want to disappoint his parents, so goes to extreme steps to ensure he passes his exams. Both Meg and Andy meet significant challenges and make mistakes, which is what makes this story and the characters so real. They are flawed, say stupid things and mess up. It makes the story wonderfully rich.
Small details further enrich this book. Meg’s ‘famous’ spag bol (spaghetti bolognese) is a dish she’s proud of and makes often for Andy. Andy can’t stand it and will often retreat to late night snacks of instant noodles. (I tend to agree with Andy – Meg’s additions to the dish are pretty weird for this spag bol connoisseur). Later Andy introduces Meg to the wonders of instant noodles during a late night meeting. I found this so sweet, as was the ending when Andy and Meg part and all the things are said.
Overall, Room for a Stranger is a quiet, beautiful book of what happens when we open ourselves to strangers. This is a quality Australian read that won’t disappoint.
Thank you to Text Publishing for the copy of this book. My review is honest.
http://samstillreading.wordpress.com
The main characters in Room for a Stranger are an elderly lady, a university student from Hong Kong, their friends and an African grey parrot. The parrot is not only a lovely distraction with his spookily relevant English but an important part of the plot. These disparate characters create a story that is about loneliness and isolation, but also about unlikely friendships. Meg has been living at home alone since the death of her sister, but an encounter with an intruder leaves her feeling vulnerable and scared. She signs up for a home share program to let out a room to a university student. That student is Andy, who is from Hong Kong, studying biomedicine in the hope of getting into medicine. Andy’s not doing too well at university and he has worries about his parents and their situation. Meg is worried too about her health, her friends and meeting Andy’s expectations. What starts as an awkward home scenario where two strangers tiptoe around each other gradually develops into the kind of bond where they can discuss their deepest fears that they can’t reveal to those closest to them.
The story is wonderfully suburban and rather Melbournian in its descriptions of possums and trams. It’s not a ‘big’ story – when I say big, I mean that it doesn’t encompass huge travels, land or generations – but works to capture a short period of time in two everyday lives. Some may say that Meg and Andy’s problems are relatively small but they are huge to them. Fear of death, illness, failure and disappointing others. Meg is worried about not keeping up with her glamourous friends (and I thought female competitiveness might get better with age!) and she’s worried about starting a new relationship. Andy doesn’t want to disappoint his parents, so goes to extreme steps to ensure he passes his exams. Both Meg and Andy meet significant challenges and make mistakes, which is what makes this story and the characters so real. They are flawed, say stupid things and mess up. It makes the story wonderfully rich.
Small details further enrich this book. Meg’s ‘famous’ spag bol (spaghetti bolognese) is a dish she’s proud of and makes often for Andy. Andy can’t stand it and will often retreat to late night snacks of instant noodles. (I tend to agree with Andy – Meg’s additions to the dish are pretty weird for this spag bol connoisseur). Later Andy introduces Meg to the wonders of instant noodles during a late night meeting. I found this so sweet, as was the ending when Andy and Meg part and all the things are said.
Overall, Room for a Stranger is a quiet, beautiful book of what happens when we open ourselves to strangers. This is a quality Australian read that won’t disappoint.
Thank you to Text Publishing for the copy of this book. My review is honest.
http://samstillreading.wordpress.com
essjay1's review against another edition
4.0
A story about 2 lonely people from very different backgrounds. There’s a lot to like about this book and some really great characters. I guess ultimately it’s a novel about empathy, and how we see the world through our own very personal lens and perhaps we don’t always understand, or often misunderstand, the motivations of others, even those closest to us.
llbel123's review
3.0
2.5 stars. I liked the accurate portrayal of modern Australian life, but the ending was abrupt, and left a lot of unanswered threads for me.
graceless's review
4.0
An easy book about an interesting relationship. I really liked the way it captured parts of Australian attitudes along with the differences between generations and across cultures. A nice selection for our May Virtual Book Club book.
rachhenderson's review
4.0
This book was a pleasant little surprise. Elderly Meg lives alone and decides to take in a university student after a break-in. Andy is an international student under pressure to meet the expectations of his family.
I will admit I expected this book to be dull so left it sitting at the bottom of the book pile for a while. Pleasingly, this was not the case. While not action-packed, it drew me in and I had no trouble losing myself in it for extended reading sessions.
I will admit I expected this book to be dull so left it sitting at the bottom of the book pile for a while. Pleasingly, this was not the case. While not action-packed, it drew me in and I had no trouble losing myself in it for extended reading sessions.
charan's review against another edition
emotional
reflective
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.0