Reviews

Mud by E.J. Wenstrom

urbanaudreye's review

Go to review page

4.0

A good book, though not a favorite. It has an intriguing story. Adem is a golem. Tasked with protecting a box with unknown contents. He is then approached by an angel who wants him to bring him back a soul from the Underworld.

booklvrkat's review

Go to review page

4.0

This is a story of a golem. It's new. It's different. And it's something you won't forget. The author explains that she wanted something new and different to write about. Well she's done it. And it's an interesting story, imho, that takes you on a journey beyond your imagination.

mdoerr's review

Go to review page

4.0

This was a great surprise, I wasn't sure what to expect from this and I really liked it. Angels, underworld, gods, war, prophets, men made of mud. This was very interesting and Adems perspective made it even more intriguing. This was very easy to read and an enjoyable experience. I went right into the second book because it was so compelling.

frogggirl2's review

Go to review page

3.0

The writing style is solid and, aside from a few typos, this is a fast and competently laid out book.

The main character, the golem, is not really that interesting or well characterized. The repetitive telling not showing, complaining about the pull of the magic box and his loneliness and his otherness, grates after awhile. Neither Miriam or Jordan are made real enough to matter as much as they must in order to make the story work.

Initially, I really liked the world state and I was interested in it, but, then it just becomes an imitation of a traditional hero's journey in Greek mythology. Overall, this book draws too heavily on real world mythology to be particularly interesting or unique. There's potential here but neither the world building nor the characters are well-rounded enough to make this book stand out.
More...