alexandra_avital's review against another edition
4.0
3.5 that is being round up because some of the stories are Really good and some are mediocre. Loved the fresh voices and stories from a diverse set of characters.
bethreadsandnaps's review against another edition
3.75
This is a good YA collection, especially when you consider it was published five years ago. This anthology is diverse in format (graphic novel, play, etc.) and genre as well as including many races, gay and trans representation. It does feel a tad “check all the diversity boxes.” Like most short story collections, some resonated more than others. And like with some YA, some knocked you over the head with their non-subtlety. Overall, solid collection.
korinicolereadsss's review against another edition
4.0
Overall, four stars.
But specifically, Eraser Tattoo by Jason Reynolds gets 5 stars. I love his writing, but after seeing him speak at a conference last week, I see his writing in a whole new light. Loved the relationship between Dante and Shay. And the last line is nothing short of perfect.
I also really enjoyed Catch, Pull, Drive by Schuyler Bailar.
This was a really great collection of short stories, giving voice to so many diverse characters. Much needed in literature.
But specifically, Eraser Tattoo by Jason Reynolds gets 5 stars. I love his writing, but after seeing him speak at a conference last week, I see his writing in a whole new light. Loved the relationship between Dante and Shay. And the last line is nothing short of perfect.
I also really enjoyed Catch, Pull, Drive by Schuyler Bailar.
This was a really great collection of short stories, giving voice to so many diverse characters. Much needed in literature.
lunamoon62's review against another edition
3.0
3.5 stars. Overall a very stunning anthology, with a wide range of diverse voices telling personal tales that ranged from contemporary (most of them) to sci-fi and fantasy. This broadened my horizons and let me explore new voices and diverse identities. While some stories were better than others, I enjoyed most of them, with a few stand-outs that I absolutely loved. I recommend for those looking for a short story collection full of beautiful representation.
by_emilymarie's review against another edition
reflective
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
4.0
mrsleighmath's review against another edition
5.0
So many great stories and new authors to read more from.
My favorites:
One Voice by Melissa de la Cruz
Catch, Pull, Drive by Schyuler Bailar
Super Human by Nicola Yoon
My favorites:
One Voice by Melissa de la Cruz
Catch, Pull, Drive by Schyuler Bailar
Super Human by Nicola Yoon
carlybailey's review against another edition
3.0
I chose this book to fulfill my short story requirement.
This book featured an array of diverse characters and each story was unique. However, I would not teach this in school. I don't think this collection of short stories should be taught in school because it does not have a cohesive theme that can be taught and supplemented with other resources. Books featuring diversity, such as "On The Come Up" by Angie Thomas, have cohesive themes that can be taught while still having diverse characters.
Drugs: There are mentions of drugs in a few stories, but no character is depicted taking any.
Sex: No characters are shown having sex. There is one character that features two female love interests. Their interactions are flirtatious but innocent.
Violence: There is one short story featuring deceased teenagers who talk about their deaths. All of them died violently.
Rock&Roll: Maney of these stories may cause sadness and readers to become emotional. The characters are all POC and come from different backgrounds. It is difficult to put down every sad thing that happened since there are several stories. A few examples are deceased teenagers talking about their deaths, deceased parents, and an estranged grandmother and granddaughter.
Language: There is moderate language.
This book featured an array of diverse characters and each story was unique. However, I would not teach this in school. I don't think this collection of short stories should be taught in school because it does not have a cohesive theme that can be taught and supplemented with other resources. Books featuring diversity, such as "On The Come Up" by Angie Thomas, have cohesive themes that can be taught while still having diverse characters.
Drugs: There are mentions of drugs in a few stories, but no character is depicted taking any.
Sex: No characters are shown having sex. There is one character that features two female love interests. Their interactions are flirtatious but innocent.
Violence: There is one short story featuring deceased teenagers who talk about their deaths. All of them died violently.
Rock&Roll: Maney of these stories may cause sadness and readers to become emotional. The characters are all POC and come from different backgrounds. It is difficult to put down every sad thing that happened since there are several stories. A few examples are deceased teenagers talking about their deaths, deceased parents, and an estranged grandmother and granddaughter.
Language: There is moderate language.
rfonta69801's review against another edition
3.0
3.25 stars
Character Development: I think I had higher hopes for this book.
Diversity: Mostly.
Likes: I loved some of the stories.
Dislikes: Some of the stories just weren't my favorite.
What mood should you read this book in?: Emotional, Adventure, Romance.
Pace: Fast
Likable Characters?: 60% of the book.
Characters or Plot?: Character mostly.
Overall, I just would've liked "more" from some of the characters.
Character Development: I think I had higher hopes for this book.
Diversity: Mostly.
Likes: I loved some of the stories.
Dislikes: Some of the stories just weren't my favorite.
What mood should you read this book in?: Emotional, Adventure, Romance.
Pace: Fast
Likable Characters?: 60% of the book.
Characters or Plot?: Character mostly.
Overall, I just would've liked "more" from some of the characters.