Scan barcode
justmevictoria's review against another edition
3.0
Originally published on My Books Are Me
2.5 Stars
A very interesting read indeed, full of mystery, romance and intrigue, with a skeleton thrown in for good measure.
The La Motte family are fleeing Paris, running from creditors, when the happen upon a house to ask for directions. Instead of getting directions, they end up taking in Adeline, and asked to never return with her. With their new acquaintance, they soon take refuge in a rumbling abbey in the middle of a dense forest. When it's discovered that the Marquis who owns it no longer visits and that the village people fear that the horrible stories about the abbey are true, La Motte decides to live in the abbey, knowing that he won't be found by those hunting him down. The large abbey conceals many secrets and concealed passageways. La Motte happens across a chest containing a skeleton, while Adeline is haunted by nightmares that lead her to a manuscript and a rusty daggar. Soon, Adeline is pursued by the Marquis who is intent on marrying her, despite her objections, for she is in love with Theodore. Things get intense when Adeline is abducted by the Marquis but then escapes, only to be captured by him again, but then escape again and learn the truth about her heritage and legacy.
This book was definitely not what I was expecting. I went into the story hoping for some creepy intrigue and a ghost or two, with some romance and pretty scenery thrown in on the side. But it didn't really do it for me. True, there is intrigue, it's a little bit creepy and there was possibly a ghost, but the story fell flat, especially in the middle.
I really think this book would have benefited from being about 100 pages less, with a little less of the back and forth that filled the middle. I also felt like the 'sinister relics of the past' that were mentioned in the blurb played a slightly lesser roll than they sounded like they would. Yes, they were key parts to the story in the end, but there was an entire part in the middle where they didn't seem to matter at all. In fact, I nearly thought they wouldn't be mentioned again until they made a reappearance in the final few chapters.
Another problem I had with this book was the writing style. Written in the late 1700s, I knew it wasn't going to be what I was used to, and for the most part it was relatively easy to read and understand. But Radcliffe's heavy use of over-describing nature was, while helpful when writing my essay for university, bogged me down and made me loose interest - I did not need to have a whole page describing a sunrise in the beginning of the book.
Don't get me wrong, I enjoyed the story and the twist at the end was something that I honestly did not see coming. It's just that, by the end of the story, I had completely lost interest in the characters and what was happening to them. If I'm being honest, if I didn't have to read this for university and write an essay on it, I would have DNF'd it about halfway through.
If you enjoy classics and Gothic literature, definitely give this book a go. At this point in time, for someone who hasn't read too many classics, it definitely was not the book for me, and I will certainly give it another go in the future when I've read a bit more widely. But if you have experienced a range of classic works, then I'm sure you'll be able to appreciate the story a lot more than I currently do.
2.5 Stars
A very interesting read indeed, full of mystery, romance and intrigue, with a skeleton thrown in for good measure.
The La Motte family are fleeing Paris, running from creditors, when the happen upon a house to ask for directions. Instead of getting directions, they end up taking in Adeline, and asked to never return with her. With their new acquaintance, they soon take refuge in a rumbling abbey in the middle of a dense forest. When it's discovered that the Marquis who owns it no longer visits and that the village people fear that the horrible stories about the abbey are true, La Motte decides to live in the abbey, knowing that he won't be found by those hunting him down. The large abbey conceals many secrets and concealed passageways. La Motte happens across a chest containing a skeleton, while Adeline is haunted by nightmares that lead her to a manuscript and a rusty daggar. Soon, Adeline is pursued by the Marquis who is intent on marrying her, despite her objections, for she is in love with Theodore. Things get intense when Adeline is abducted by the Marquis but then escapes, only to be captured by him again, but then escape again and learn the truth about her heritage and legacy.
This book was definitely not what I was expecting. I went into the story hoping for some creepy intrigue and a ghost or two, with some romance and pretty scenery thrown in on the side. But it didn't really do it for me. True, there is intrigue, it's a little bit creepy and there was possibly a ghost, but the story fell flat, especially in the middle.
I really think this book would have benefited from being about 100 pages less, with a little less of the back and forth that filled the middle. I also felt like the 'sinister relics of the past' that were mentioned in the blurb played a slightly lesser roll than they sounded like they would. Yes, they were key parts to the story in the end, but there was an entire part in the middle where they didn't seem to matter at all. In fact, I nearly thought they wouldn't be mentioned again until they made a reappearance in the final few chapters.
Another problem I had with this book was the writing style. Written in the late 1700s, I knew it wasn't going to be what I was used to, and for the most part it was relatively easy to read and understand. But Radcliffe's heavy use of over-describing nature was, while helpful when writing my essay for university, bogged me down and made me loose interest - I did not need to have a whole page describing a sunrise in the beginning of the book.
Don't get me wrong, I enjoyed the story and the twist at the end was something that I honestly did not see coming. It's just that, by the end of the story, I had completely lost interest in the characters and what was happening to them. If I'm being honest, if I didn't have to read this for university and write an essay on it, I would have DNF'd it about halfway through.
If you enjoy classics and Gothic literature, definitely give this book a go. At this point in time, for someone who hasn't read too many classics, it definitely was not the book for me, and I will certainly give it another go in the future when I've read a bit more widely. But if you have experienced a range of classic works, then I'm sure you'll be able to appreciate the story a lot more than I currently do.
heather_freshparchment's review
adventurous
challenging
dark
mysterious
sad
tense
slow-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? No
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
3.0
clairebearrich's review against another edition
4.0
Careful! This review contains *gasp* spoilers! *faints*
Eighteenth century novels make me laugh. At the end of every book there’s a happy ending. All the loose ends are tied, everybody usually gets married and gathers around the lake singing kumbayah. Or, at least that’s how The Romance of the Forest ends.
But I get ahead of myself. So the heroine of this book is Adeline, another poor, pretty orphan being taken advantage of by her cruel relatives. She’s handed off to Monsieur La Motte by some mysterious men in the middle of the night as he is fleeing to avoid prison. The La Mottes and Adeline all end up hiding out in an abandoned abbey. Chaos ensues.
In case you were wondering, this is a novel of sensibility, which essentially means Adeline faints at everything (hence the spoiler warning.) And that gets real annoying, real fast. I’ve never been a huge fan of helpless characters and though she has her moments of bravery, Adeline qualifies.
While I liked this novel significantly more than Moll Flanders, I still wasn’t entirely sold on it. It didn’t grab me like Pride and Prejudice did, or entertain me like The Rover did.
3.5/5 stars
Eighteenth century novels make me laugh. At the end of every book there’s a happy ending. All the loose ends are tied, everybody usually gets married and gathers around the lake singing kumbayah. Or, at least that’s how The Romance of the Forest ends.
But I get ahead of myself. So the heroine of this book is Adeline, another poor, pretty orphan being taken advantage of by her cruel relatives. She’s handed off to Monsieur La Motte by some mysterious men in the middle of the night as he is fleeing to avoid prison. The La Mottes and Adeline all end up hiding out in an abandoned abbey. Chaos ensues.
In case you were wondering, this is a novel of sensibility, which essentially means Adeline faints at everything (hence the spoiler warning.) And that gets real annoying, real fast. I’ve never been a huge fan of helpless characters and though she has her moments of bravery, Adeline qualifies.
While I liked this novel significantly more than Moll Flanders, I still wasn’t entirely sold on it. It didn’t grab me like Pride and Prejudice did, or entertain me like The Rover did.
3.5/5 stars
jessthanthree's review against another edition
dark
emotional
mysterious
slow-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? No
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
2.5
Content Warnings
Moderate: Confinement and Misogyny
Minor: Death of parent
doinacondrea's review
5.0
Ah Ann has done it again!! Her books are magic (although this is only my second)!!
It's romantic, it's suspenseful, it's unlike any other!
This is my new favourite book..the world I get transported to with the most romantic language is both suspenseful and terrifying and calming. Absolutely magical.
It's romantic, it's suspenseful, it's unlike any other!
This is my new favourite book..the world I get transported to with the most romantic language is both suspenseful and terrifying and calming. Absolutely magical.
dexterw's review against another edition
dark
emotional
mysterious
reflective
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
3.5
slimikin's review against another edition
2.0
To me, the fun of a gothic romance lies in all the absurd and unlikely coincidences that arise in the course of the story. The Romance of the Forest does possess these, especially at the end, but I definitely wish there'd been less...Romanticism...along the way.
At final count, variations on the word "sublime"—because no other word will do when you're writing something Romantic!—number 31 throughout the novel. That's 31 instances of Radcliffe diving into the Romantic when maybe she didn't really need to.
And variations on the words "weep" or "tears"? 148! (Not counting that one time when a willow was doing the weeping.) Just think how much tighter the pacing of the book would have been if even half of these overwrought moments of horror and grief and despair and longing (etc., etc.) had been edited out.
Alas, as a modern day reader, I wanted a little more action. But if I'd read this when it came out? The lamentations might still have aggravated me, but I would've been penning the Georgian equivalent of fanfiction and sharing it with anyone who would read it.
At final count, variations on the word "sublime"—because no other word will do when you're writing something Romantic!—number 31 throughout the novel. That's 31 instances of Radcliffe diving into the Romantic when maybe she didn't really need to.
And variations on the words "weep" or "tears"? 148! (Not counting that one time when a willow was doing the weeping.) Just think how much tighter the pacing of the book would have been if even half of these overwrought moments of horror and grief and despair and longing (etc., etc.) had been edited out.
Alas, as a modern day reader, I wanted a little more action. But if I'd read this when it came out? The lamentations might still have aggravated me, but I would've been penning the Georgian equivalent of fanfiction and sharing it with anyone who would read it.
anomalousheart's review
3.0
Northanger Abbey is my favourite Jane Austen novel and Cathy Morland is my favourite heroine. A bookworm with a taste for adventure and danger, Cathy delights in Gothic novels, and Anne Radcliffe's works are mentioned a lot in the book. So, I thought I'd read The Romance of the Forest myself, and it definitely did not lack in Gothic, darkness, and mystery. I'm looking forward to reading more of Radcliffe's works!