Reviews

Book Parts by Adam Smyth, Dennis Duncan

schopflin's review

Go to review page

4.0

This book relates to my PhD thesis and I had to put it aside when brain fog meant I couldn't give it the attention it deserved. So glad that I picked up momentum again. Nearly all the chapters are entertaining, some humerous, and all showing a great love of books as objects. The chapter on footnotes was really a literary history, rather than a paratextual one, as if footnotes were too obvious to write about as a concept. Conversely, the endleaves chapter was at the dry end of book production history. This book is possibly a niche pleasure but a joy nonetheless and a beautiful object in itself. 

losthitsu's review

Go to review page

4.0

I wish there was a less academic/history-heavy and more widely accessible reference-style version of this, but still a great resource with some lovely whimsical details.

pedantichumbug's review

Go to review page

informative reflective fast-paced

4.75

This is a very well-edited book that achieves to braid together the voices of more than 20 contributors, who all function like parts of a harmonious whole in terms of writing style, structure, and analytical/critical insight (with very few exceptions falling short of critical depth). It's not very common in academic publishing that we encounter such unison in edited multi-author volumes, but Book Parts manages that cohesion in a way that none of the chapters feel forced, out-of-place or slapdash.

Each writer in the volume employs a clear language, presents a wide array of examples on the topic in a limited space (every chapter is approx. 10 page long), and goes beyond merely compiling and describing facts. I especially enjoyed Helen Smith's chapter on "Acknowledgements and Dedications" where she creatively performs the conventions of the topic she writes on. In fact, the whole book is full of such self-reflexive moments. The editors' introductory chapter, for instance, is both an introduction to the book at hand and a chapter on "Introduction" as a book part. Every chapter features a title page that formally mimics what it talks about, which I thought was ingenious. These meta qualities resonate perfectly with the cover image Books on Books by Jonathan Wolstenholme.

Highly recommended to novices in bibliography like me.
More...