Scan barcode
k_cavacini's review against another edition
4.0
A very suspenseful novel. I thought it was a good book that kept me guessing all the way up until the end. Lisa Scottoline always leaves me wanting more!
myameegirl's review against another edition
3.0
3.5⭐️ - The plot was okay, the writing was fine, but parts of it went on and on and it got a bit repetitive and boring. It still kept me interested to see how it ended so that's why I gave it 3.5. I might pick up a different book from this author in the future since a lot of reviews mention that this was their least favorite book of hers.
kricket1467's review against another edition
2.0
It's supposed to be a murder mystery, but nothing interesting happens until about 3/4 of the way through. It was just OK.
lauraew333's review against another edition
3.0
I picked this up on a whim when I needed something to read whilst sun-bathing outside and this is the perfect book for such an occasion! While not perfect, it was a great mix of light and dark.
1. The characters. The characters are quite typical. While they don't have terribly complex pasts that are explored (except for Jill), they are fleshed out enough for the reader to be drawn right in. I certainly had issues with Jill's parenting style (though I've seen worse) although I loved how the author worked to make the problems and opinions facing Jill and Sam (her fiancé) as nuanced and multi-faceted as possible. I could understand where both of them were coming from. I was really interested in the dynamic between the sisters as there were multiple marriages which isn't easy on any child involved. There wasn't too much depth provided but again, there was enough to get a sense of their feelings. All in all, adequate but not phenomenal.
2. The plot. The plot was pretty interesting to me. While this book is mostly driven by the characters (it's a mix of mystery and coming-of-age style genres), the plot provided a good drive to the story. I also thoroughly enjoyed how the author kept up with the lives of the characters and made sure to include several secondary plot lines to better display the lives of the characters realistically. I honestly think that's my favorite part of this book. The author did such a good job in keeping the balance of the mystery and danger as well as the typical problems facing a family in the midst of another marriage with children involved. I didn't love the ending, however, as it was much too typical and cheesy. There is a certain amount of cheese I'm able to handle in a book but that was used up with a good amount of dialogue that felt off.
3. The writing. I personally like this writer's writing style. While I haven't read any of her other work, I have no doubt she writes wonderful contemporaries and romances. Everything is clear and laid out in a nice linear fashion and while her writing isn't over flowery or metaphorical (think Tahereh Mafi), it's functional which serves the genre well.
4. The atmosphere. Like I said at the beginning of this review, I picked this up on a whim (my friend had brought it with us and she leant it to me) while I was sun-bathing and it's the perfect book for such a setting. It has the perfect mix of light and dark and is such a great book to read outside in the warmth on a lazy afternoon. It's a very comfortable book that you can pick up and put down with ease.
The Final Verdict:
A comfortable, well-written and adequately developed contemporary mystery. However, there is an unacceptably cheesy ending and plenty of cheddar sprinkled throughout the book.
3 stars
Quotes:
“That’s what books do, isn’t it? That’s why I love to read. They bring us closer to ourselves.”
“She had lived long enough to learn that families didn’t dissolve or reconfigure neatly, but left debris lying everywhere, and it was human debris. And sometimes, like tonight, she felt as if she were tripping over the bodies.”
1. The characters. The characters are quite typical. While they don't have terribly complex pasts that are explored (except for Jill), they are fleshed out enough for the reader to be drawn right in. I certainly had issues with Jill's parenting style (though I've seen worse) although I loved how the author worked to make the problems and opinions facing Jill and Sam (her fiancé) as nuanced and multi-faceted as possible. I could understand where both of them were coming from. I was really interested in the dynamic between the sisters as there were multiple marriages which isn't easy on any child involved. There wasn't too much depth provided but again, there was enough to get a sense of their feelings. All in all, adequate but not phenomenal.
2. The plot. The plot was pretty interesting to me. While this book is mostly driven by the characters (it's a mix of mystery and coming-of-age style genres), the plot provided a good drive to the story. I also thoroughly enjoyed how the author kept up with the lives of the characters and made sure to include several secondary plot lines to better display the lives of the characters realistically. I honestly think that's my favorite part of this book. The author did such a good job in keeping the balance of the mystery and danger as well as the typical problems facing a family in the midst of another marriage with children involved. I didn't love the ending, however, as it was much too typical and cheesy. There is a certain amount of cheese I'm able to handle in a book but that was used up with a good amount of dialogue that felt off.
3. The writing. I personally like this writer's writing style. While I haven't read any of her other work, I have no doubt she writes wonderful contemporaries and romances. Everything is clear and laid out in a nice linear fashion and while her writing isn't over flowery or metaphorical (think Tahereh Mafi), it's functional which serves the genre well.
4. The atmosphere. Like I said at the beginning of this review, I picked this up on a whim (my friend had brought it with us and she leant it to me) while I was sun-bathing and it's the perfect book for such a setting. It has the perfect mix of light and dark and is such a great book to read outside in the warmth on a lazy afternoon. It's a very comfortable book that you can pick up and put down with ease.
The Final Verdict:
A comfortable, well-written and adequately developed contemporary mystery. However, there is an unacceptably cheesy ending and plenty of cheddar sprinkled throughout the book.
3 stars
Quotes:
“That’s what books do, isn’t it? That’s why I love to read. They bring us closer to ourselves.”
“She had lived long enough to learn that families didn’t dissolve or reconfigure neatly, but left debris lying everywhere, and it was human debris. And sometimes, like tonight, she felt as if she were tripping over the bodies.”
marcies_8's review against another edition
3.0
It was ok. Just ok. I wanted a quick, easy read, and that was all I got.
jenniferlyoung's review against another edition
3.0
So-so. I really like Lisa Scottoline, she is so amazing with her fans. And, she's a local, so it's fun reading about places you know (Philly and surrounding areas). I wouldn't say she is the best writer ever. This is my second book of hers, and it pretty much followed the exact same formula (Save Me). It was an ok, quick read.
icygrl7's review against another edition
3.0
I give this book a 3.5 out of 5. There was a lot I liked but also there was a lot I didn’t like. Some of it was believable while other parts of the story not so much. I have only read one or two other books by this author but I will continue to read other books by her. I liked the other book(s) better than this one. This one definitely makes you question how far the bond of step-parenthood should go...especially if it involves divorce. While I believe you don’t divorce the kids I am not so sure I would have gone as far as the main character did in this book...especially when her ex was such a jerk and cheated on her and stole from her...etc. This book was enjoyable but not something I will remember a couple of weeks from now.
daydreamer1983's review against another edition
4.0
Interesting book. Definitely held my attention. I found a few points repetitive, but at the same time, the characters were likable. Didn't see the ending coming which is a bonus :) will definitely read more by Lisa Scottoline!
pibblemama17's review against another edition
medium-paced
3.0
I really loved the story. But the writing reminded me of my own high school prose in many instances. And the narrator wasn't great on the audio.