Reviews

If I Touched the Earth by Cynthia Rogerson

chylu's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

While I found this story difficult to really sink my teeth into for the first few chapters, by the time I closed the book I was very glad to have pressed on and seen these characters through their emotional journeys that all tie together, even those that never share a scene.

I struggled a bit to relate to the main characters because of their decisions, and yet this is part of the reason I enjoyed reading it; it was a chance to empathise with people making choices I wouldn't have made, and seeing where it leads them. There are several fantastic character arcs and Rogerson does well to illustrate the growth and change these characters experience after the sudden death of a young man.

Exploring how death affects us is a universal concept, and as such, it can pack a pretty meaningful punch when approached with care, as Rogerson does here. Stories like this appeal because I believe it's so important to be consciously grateful for every day we have, and every moment we get to spend with our loved ones.

The overall theme resonated with me, as did the denouement. My favourite character was one introduced in the second half (the main character's boss when she takes a job in Glasgow), as he seemed the most selfless, genuine, and generous, and by this point I felt the story began to reach its stride.

It's a quiet story that makes you think and makes you grateful for what you have, and because of that I'd definitely recommend it. Rogerson is very good at getting you into the characters' heads, even if they're not somewhere you necessarily want to be--which makes it all the more compelling.

serendipity_viv's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

This really isn't the type of book I would normally read, but after being extremely impressed with other books published by Black and White Publishing as well as being intrigued by the blurb for this book, I was curious to read it and on reflection I'm really glad I did.
This book looks at how an unexpected major event can change your journey through life, swiftly sweeping you into a completely different destiny. Alison's son Callum, is killed instantly in a car crash, a reality that appears in the news on a daily basis. When we see these accidents occur in real life, they linger for a moment in our minds, occasionally resurfacing through out the day but they do not stay with us for long unless we know the person who has died in such a tragic way. This book closely follows the day to day lives of the people that knew Callum well - the ones most affected by his death, paying close attention to their cycle of grief until the pain begins to ebb a little from their daily existence. Through very poignant and detailed writing, you experience their grief first hand - the angry thoughts, the confusion and the severe loss in their lives will bring tears to your eyes. Each character within the book is affected differently by the passing of Callum, reflecting how in life grief affects each individual in various ways.
The characters are very real and normal; the type of people you might expect to find living next door or within your own family. They are not perfect and they don't try to be, they just aim to be human and lifelike. This book doesn't even offer a happy ending full of solutions, but it does offer reality. By the end, Alice and Neil have made choices that often confound them and make them angry but they are choices they have made together and they reflect a normal married couple in society today.
Neil was my favourite character through out the book because he never gave up on Alison. When Alison was swallowed up by grief and unable to be found, he still held a flicker of hope that she would return to him and finally love him after waiting patiently for years. He was like a gentle giant whose bear hugs calmed the tempestuous nature of Alison.
I loved the personification of the A9 - the backbone of the story, holding all the fragile characters together, while weaving throughout the plot. It could easily represent any major road within England.
The descriptions in the book are detailed and yet contemplative. The book provides a quiet, reflective and poignant look at life, which will leave you with questions concerning your own journey. A quiet little gem successfully portraying a difficult and distressing part of human nature.
More...