Scan barcode
thatothernigeriangirl's review against another edition
3.0
In A Palace in the Old Village, Mohammed, our main protagonist, is a Moroccan man who has lived most of his life working in France and this book is an account of his thoughts on immigration. Although the story doesn’t seem to rise or fall throughout the book, the storytelling was still very poetic —and I imagine even more so in French, it’s original language. In fact, it was largely why I got through the book.
I also enjoyed the individual theme se that Taher Ben Jelloun discussed through Mohammed; very early on in the book, we see the anti-blackness rampant within the Magreb communities in their homeland, still very alive within their immigrant population in a “diverse” France. TBJ used multiple POVs to engage this topic with Mohammed himself agreeing that had he not known one ‘African’ coworker, he probably wouldn’t marry his daughter to a black man — African was repeatedly used by the characters to describe Sub-Saharan Africans and I imagine that that’s a common usage in the Magreb communities.
A larger portion of the story dissected the identity crisis that accompanies building a family in a foreign land. Mohammed loved his country and tried to instil the same love, or a fraction of it, into his children so that he felt like “France stole his kids from him” when they eventually grew to make decisions that didn’t honor their parents’ traditions. I think this is one major fear of most immigrant parents.
This naturally broke Mohammed’s heart because he had lived and worked for his family. The loneliness amplified when he had to retire from work and for a man that has lived the same routine for many years, the realisation that he might not have lived his life to the fullest hit him really hard. This brought me to the conclusion that Mohammed has brought up his kids in the comfort that they would “honor their parents beyond all else” like he was taught growing up in Morocco but he forgot to factor in the shift that comes with migration.
I think the parent-child relationship is a very complex one and it is important for parents to remind themselves to live their lives to its fullest potential, while loving and wanting the best for their kids; so that they are not saddled with regrets nor are their children weighed down with obligations.
wtb_michael's review
emotional
sad
medium-paced
3.5
A short, sad book about migration and the impossibility of really returning home
rebekah_florence's review
informative
reflective
sad
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? No
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
3.0
Content Warnings
Graphic: Racism, Xenophobia, Religious bigotry, Islamophobia, and Hate crime
Minor: Death of parent
The amount of anti-Black sentiments and anecdotes the author chose to include was unnecessary. I think there’s a way to show that the community in the story was anti-Black without some of the descriptions that the author provided.bettycomte's review against another edition
hopeful
reflective
relaxing
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
2.0
livre riche et intéressant sur l'appréhension de la retraite, d'un point de vue d'un immigre marocain en France. Les sujets traités (islam, retraite, différence france/maroc) ne sont pas des sujets que je connaissais et m'ont permis d'avoir un autre point et de les approcher par le regard du public type. Intéressant et facile à lire même si ce n'est pas un livre qui m'a passionné. En désaccord avec le personnage à des nombreuses reprises, mais laisse place a la confrontation et pardonnable par son inculture et naïveté.
amerreine's review against another edition
3.0
Le personne principal, Mohamed, m'a beaucoup agacé au début : trop parfait, trop de sagesse pour cet ouvrier analphabète...mais une fois le décor planté, la retraite effective, les failles apparaissent et Mohamed devient un personnage plus attendrissant et plus vraisemblable. de même la France et le Maroc du début du roman, véritables images d'Épinal, deviennent deux sociétés plus nuancées, il me semble que Tahar Ben Jelloun a très bien croqué les travers de ces deux sociétés.
L'écriture de Tahar ben Jelloun est toujours aussi agréable et fluide, son propos toujours aussi humain. C'est vrai que j'ai craint le pire dans les premières pages mais ce livre se révèle intéressant dans ses réflexions sur le sens de la vie, la France et l'immigration,les mutations de l'Islam, l'évolution de la cellule familiale...
L'écriture de Tahar ben Jelloun est toujours aussi agréable et fluide, son propos toujours aussi humain. C'est vrai que j'ai craint le pire dans les premières pages mais ce livre se révèle intéressant dans ses réflexions sur le sens de la vie, la France et l'immigration,les mutations de l'Islam, l'évolution de la cellule familiale...
lonesomelovee's review
4.0
tahar ben jelloun is quickly becoming a favorite of mine. his poignant writing and reflection in this novel was beautiful. this and racism explained to my daughter are wonderful reads.
lallalettrice's review against another edition
emotional
reflective
sad
slow-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.5
manorclassics's review
challenging
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? No
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
3.0
"The contract is clear: I work, they pay me, I raise my children, and then one day we all go home to our house, yes, because the house is my country, my native land."
Ostensibly this is the story of a man's life after retirement, but I would describe it more as a tangle of memories, disillusionment and disappointed hopes. I liked something about the style, but I found myself confused by the shifts between third person and first person narration and I couldn't always figure out whether the time jumps were real or in Mohammed's mind. Things picked up for me in the final third but then the ending totally lost me... I don't mind a meandering narrative or stream of consciousness type of thing, but it all became a bit too fantastical for my taste. So not for me, but I'd like to try another book by Ben Jelloun in future.
Ostensibly this is the story of a man's life after retirement, but I would describe it more as a tangle of memories, disillusionment and disappointed hopes. I liked something about the style, but I found myself confused by the shifts between third person and first person narration and I couldn't always figure out whether the time jumps were real or in Mohammed's mind. Things picked up for me in the final third but then the ending totally lost me... I don't mind a meandering narrative or stream of consciousness type of thing, but it all became a bit too fantastical for my taste. So not for me, but I'd like to try another book by Ben Jelloun in future.
atnmitch's review against another edition
5.0
C'est un livre vraiment émouvant, on ressent vraiment la tristesse et l’aliénation de Mohamed envers son travail, le pays dans lequel il a passé sa vie adulte, et les valeurs et la vie de ses enfants.
myk_yeah's review against another edition
2.0
Nothing wrong with the book. I found it insightful but boring.
More...