Scan barcode
thepickygirl's review against another edition
4.0
Bess Crawford is a nursing sister during World War I. Having been raised in a military family in India, Bess is not the typical Englishwoman. She is self assured and independent. Her father is highly respected in the forces but never had a son; thus, Bess has her parents' full support (and worry) when she decides to join up. And rightly so. Bess is injured when the Britannic is attacked, and her bravery is immediately apparent as she helps to save others while herself dealing with a badly-broken arm.
While home recuperating, Bess is haunted by the dying wish of Arthur Graham. He wanted her to personally deliver a message to his family. Bess knows she should go, but it's an emotional journey as Bess cared more than she should have about Arthur. So when she finds that Mrs. Graham and Arthur's two brothers indifferent to his deathbed utterances, Bess finds she cannot simply leave, and the longer she stays, the more deeply she embroils herself in the family's dark past and the Grahams' willingness to keep those secrets buried.
I joined Jennifer from Book Club Girl in her Bess Crawford Readalong because I am so caught up in World War I. As you saw in last week's post about Maisie Dobbs, it's a time period that changed the world in many ways, so I couldn't wait to get started with the story of Bess Crawford.
Also, I cannot help but discuss Maisie when I discuss Bess. I like them for two completely different reasons. Maisie must work hard for her position, and she has dealt with quite a lot in her young life. Though Bess comes from a much different background, the war equalizes. Bess is afforded no special treatment as the daughter of a high-ranking officer, and she doesn't expect it. Neither is she a professional detective. Instead, it is the sense of duty instilled in Bess that causes her to poke and prod in order to find out the truth.
And prod she must. The Grahams have a secret they are intent on taking to their respective graves, and that secret has made them an unpleasant lot. Mrs. Graham buries her head in the sand and won't really discuss the situation with Bess, but she poses leading questions, trying to ascertain if Bess knows anything about the family. There's a mysterious brother, Peregrine, who is in a nearby asylum and who, during Bess's stay, takes ill. The family seems, again, indifferent. The two remaining brothers, Timothy and Jonathan, are brusque to the point of rudeness, and when Bess is called on to help the local doctor whose patient has a bad case of shell shock, they make horrible comments insinuating the man needs to "deal with it" and get back to normal.
What's so great about Bess? Bess is so easy to relate to. She isn't a professional, and because of that, she isn't always 100% sure of herself in terms of digging. She is certainly confident in herself and her abilities, but she also admits when she's stumped/unsettled/needs help. She feels bound by duty, which is easy to understand in a family whose code is honor.
Why does she stay with the Grahams? By all rights, the Grahams are pretty miserable people to be around. They keep Bess around when they need her, and when she's no longer useful, they give her the boot. As I mentioned, she stays because it's her duty, but I think she also had strong feelings for Arthur. The more she's around her family, the more she realizes she really didn't know him at all, and it helps her to heal a bit.
Why should anyone start this series? Well, I'll go ahead and admit that I quickly read every Bess Crawford book once I finished this one. I couldn't stop, and the further into the series, the more you see the face of the Great War and how it affected everyone involved. Several of the books follow Bess to the front, and the writing is very evocative. Plus, the idea of "leave" is so interesting. Mostly when you think of war, you think of soldiers down in the trenches from start to finish. "Leave" seems an odd part of war, though I can certainly see why it was necessary. And in the latest Bess Crawford, I think there might be romance brewing down the line, which is something that the Maisie series gives out only sparingly.
One last thing to note: I've read on goodreads that many people are turned off the Maisie Dobbs series because of the sort of "otherworldliness" of Maisie's training from Maurice, and it can be a bit much to take in - her intuition is much more literal than most mean the term, and her odd quirks seem to turn some readers off. I will say that Bess is much more accessible because she is amateur and also because her methods are more straightforward. So. If you aren't a Maisie fan, it does not mean you won't like Bess. Quite the opposite, really.
http://www.thepickygirl.com/?p=2164
While home recuperating, Bess is haunted by the dying wish of Arthur Graham. He wanted her to personally deliver a message to his family. Bess knows she should go, but it's an emotional journey as Bess cared more than she should have about Arthur. So when she finds that Mrs. Graham and Arthur's two brothers indifferent to his deathbed utterances, Bess finds she cannot simply leave, and the longer she stays, the more deeply she embroils herself in the family's dark past and the Grahams' willingness to keep those secrets buried.
I joined Jennifer from Book Club Girl in her Bess Crawford Readalong because I am so caught up in World War I. As you saw in last week's post about Maisie Dobbs, it's a time period that changed the world in many ways, so I couldn't wait to get started with the story of Bess Crawford.
Also, I cannot help but discuss Maisie when I discuss Bess. I like them for two completely different reasons. Maisie must work hard for her position, and she has dealt with quite a lot in her young life. Though Bess comes from a much different background, the war equalizes. Bess is afforded no special treatment as the daughter of a high-ranking officer, and she doesn't expect it. Neither is she a professional detective. Instead, it is the sense of duty instilled in Bess that causes her to poke and prod in order to find out the truth.
And prod she must. The Grahams have a secret they are intent on taking to their respective graves, and that secret has made them an unpleasant lot. Mrs. Graham buries her head in the sand and won't really discuss the situation with Bess, but she poses leading questions, trying to ascertain if Bess knows anything about the family. There's a mysterious brother, Peregrine, who is in a nearby asylum and who, during Bess's stay, takes ill. The family seems, again, indifferent. The two remaining brothers, Timothy and Jonathan, are brusque to the point of rudeness, and when Bess is called on to help the local doctor whose patient has a bad case of shell shock, they make horrible comments insinuating the man needs to "deal with it" and get back to normal.
What's so great about Bess? Bess is so easy to relate to. She isn't a professional, and because of that, she isn't always 100% sure of herself in terms of digging. She is certainly confident in herself and her abilities, but she also admits when she's stumped/unsettled/needs help. She feels bound by duty, which is easy to understand in a family whose code is honor.
Why does she stay with the Grahams? By all rights, the Grahams are pretty miserable people to be around. They keep Bess around when they need her, and when she's no longer useful, they give her the boot. As I mentioned, she stays because it's her duty, but I think she also had strong feelings for Arthur. The more she's around her family, the more she realizes she really didn't know him at all, and it helps her to heal a bit.
Why should anyone start this series? Well, I'll go ahead and admit that I quickly read every Bess Crawford book once I finished this one. I couldn't stop, and the further into the series, the more you see the face of the Great War and how it affected everyone involved. Several of the books follow Bess to the front, and the writing is very evocative. Plus, the idea of "leave" is so interesting. Mostly when you think of war, you think of soldiers down in the trenches from start to finish. "Leave" seems an odd part of war, though I can certainly see why it was necessary. And in the latest Bess Crawford, I think there might be romance brewing down the line, which is something that the Maisie series gives out only sparingly.
One last thing to note: I've read on goodreads that many people are turned off the Maisie Dobbs series because of the sort of "otherworldliness" of Maisie's training from Maurice, and it can be a bit much to take in - her intuition is much more literal than most mean the term, and her odd quirks seem to turn some readers off. I will say that Bess is much more accessible because she is amateur and also because her methods are more straightforward. So. If you aren't a Maisie fan, it does not mean you won't like Bess. Quite the opposite, really.
http://www.thepickygirl.com/?p=2164
deannah's review against another edition
4.0
I think my definition of cozy mystery, is dependent on a certain aesthetic. The English countryside during WWI definitely fits my cozy mystery aesthetic. I found this much more enjoyable than your traditional "cozy mystery."
That being said, I can't stand the narrator here. Her voices are fine, but her narrator voice is rather snooty, I have a stick up my bum, in the worst possible way. It will not stop me from listening to other books in the series, I just would have picked someone else to read my book.
That being said, I can't stand the narrator here. Her voices are fine, but her narrator voice is rather snooty, I have a stick up my bum, in the worst possible way. It will not stop me from listening to other books in the series, I just would have picked someone else to read my book.
kimveach's review against another edition
adventurous
dark
emotional
mysterious
reflective
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.5
I'm happy I finally got around to reading this. I've read all of the Maisie Dobbs, Maggie Hope, and Lady Emily mysteries, so I'm happy to add another series with a strong and intelligent woman protagonist.
Content Warnings
Graphic: Body shaming, Child abuse, Confinement, Death, Emotional abuse, Gore, Gun violence, Infidelity, Self harm, Suicidal thoughts, Suicide, Violence, Forced institutionalization, Blood, Medical content, Grief, Medical trauma, Death of parent, Murder, Abandonment, War, and Injury/Injury detail
luffy79's review against another edition
3.0
The second Charles Todd book I've read, and the first,literally, book of Bess Crawford series. It is a cozy mystery. I have been reading them recently. Didn't know of the term "cozy mystery" for a long time. And I didn't suspect that, e.g, Agatha Christie's books were in that category. Christie is the ultimate cozy mystery writer.
What I've come to expect of these type of novels is a lack of typically long winded showdowns. In contemporary mysteries, there is no impossible to reach solution. There's just the matter of the truth to be discovered. There's no bombastic monologue by the murderer, well there's not in either Charles Todd mystery that I've read. I'm not saying it would be better to have a twist at the end. But it does mean that in "A Duty To The Dead". the journey is more handsome than the destination.
Bess Crawford is the youngest heroine in any adult mystery novel. She is a nurse, which makes her mature beyond her years. She sees pain on a daily basis, she sees hopes rise to ecstasy and fall to despair, all in a single day. Her- and my- journey to solve the conundrum of Peregrine Graham's life and punishment is an engaging story, and the style makes for a pleasant reading. The town of Kent is the main location for all the hints, depictions and mood setters that the authors serve us. Near the end of this book, however, the authors might have hurried on, being less lyrical in an attempt to prioritize the plot, which is okay, but it's something you do notice, as a reader. As we progress, the broken arm that Bess suffered in the very beginning(the book does start off with a bang)heals in conjecture with the unraveling of a quite nice tale...just like many characters in movies, like Michael Corleone. Here the metaphor for healing is strong, maybe I'm missing something...maybe a more clever and astute reader has it pegged. I don't really know.
What I've come to expect of these type of novels is a lack of typically long winded showdowns. In contemporary mysteries, there is no impossible to reach solution. There's just the matter of the truth to be discovered. There's no bombastic monologue by the murderer, well there's not in either Charles Todd mystery that I've read. I'm not saying it would be better to have a twist at the end. But it does mean that in "A Duty To The Dead". the journey is more handsome than the destination.
Bess Crawford is the youngest heroine in any adult mystery novel. She is a nurse, which makes her mature beyond her years. She sees pain on a daily basis, she sees hopes rise to ecstasy and fall to despair, all in a single day. Her- and my- journey to solve the conundrum of Peregrine Graham's life and punishment is an engaging story, and the style makes for a pleasant reading. The town of Kent is the main location for all the hints, depictions and mood setters that the authors serve us. Near the end of this book, however, the authors might have hurried on, being less lyrical in an attempt to prioritize the plot, which is okay, but it's something you do notice, as a reader. As we progress, the broken arm that Bess suffered in the very beginning(the book does start off with a bang)heals in conjecture with the unraveling of a quite nice tale...just like many characters in movies, like Michael Corleone. Here the metaphor for healing is strong, maybe I'm missing something...maybe a more clever and astute reader has it pegged. I don't really know.
justasking27's review
4.0
I enjoyed this very much, especially the questions raised around eyewitness testimony and impressionable children. Recommended for historical fiction and mystery fans.
hannacolwrites's review against another edition
4.0
An excellent mystery for older readers. Sensitive readers might be put off by descriptions of violence.
bekstar's review against another edition
4.0
I have read a number of Charles Todd books, but not the first in this series.
It is always nice to be taken back in time where life was very different for women.
It is always nice to be taken back in time where life was very different for women.
theonewhereaimeereads's review against another edition
4.0
I read this book from start to finish in one sitting. Charles Todd fully engulfed me in the world he created filled with family, war, murder, and mystery. The plot's unpredictability made this novel fully enjoyable. I kept guessing and changing my mind as to who I believed the murderer to be. Bess Crawford is an incredibly likable character. She is sweet and smart, with insight well beyond her years. The plot never got too extreme, it was always believable and left me both excited and scared to read on! I would absolutely recommend reading this book!
literaryliz98's review against another edition
5.0
I really enjoyed this book! I was thoroughly engrossed the entire time, and loved that there was a mystery as well as historical bits. I was happy to note that there appear to be more Bess Crawford mysteries. Can't wait to read another one.
catepolacek's review against another edition
4.0
Interesting start to this series. It's slow-going at first, but I didn't really mind that as it thoroughly situates one in the WWI setting. It definitely picks up in the second half. It held my interest, and I want to continue reading the series, so I consider that a good sign.