Reviews

(3.75) Il faudrait vraiment que je m'intéresse bien plus aux romans fantastiques pour la jeunesse. Le tout reste très très classique mais entre la touche de décalé et les chapitres qui se lisent si vite, on ne peut qu'en redemander ! Le peu de pages ne laisse pas grande place au développement mais en même temps le format m'a permis un bon petit moment sans prise de tête.

ameline's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous dark funny mysterious reflective sad tense fast-paced

Plot- or character-driven? Plot
Strong character development? No
Loveable characters? It's complicated
Diverse cast of characters? No
Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

3.75

rachelcabbit's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

This is the class reader I'm going to be looking at with my Year 7s, to link into their work on Gothic stories.
It surprised me how silly it was and yet it was an entertaining read. I expect the Year 7s will love it. It seems to have made an impact on my Year 8s, as some of them listed it as their favourite book.

It does have a lot of parallels with Harry Potter (though this came out long before!) but it is different enough to not warrant constant comparison. For one thing, the abuse the main character suffers at home is exaggerated and almost played for laughs, which did disturb me. Then I realised everything in this book is exaggerated and unrealistic - except the main character and his reactions. He is the reader through and through - confused, scared and a little excited.
Little by little the real mysteries of Groosham Grange start to unfold and the reader always gets the hints before poor David.

By the end I was hooked and I do want to read the sequel just to see how the characters will be now that the dynamic has changed from hating/fearing/trying to escape Groosham Grange, to understanding it.

More...